To use the childrens' coats from last winter again this winter?

[Purplegirlie]

Am I? Both of my younger childrens' coats still fit them perfectly well. They were both bought brand new about a year ago from M&S and are in great condition.

My mum says I'm being unreasonable by not buying them new this year. I say there's no point spending £60 or so when they each have a perfectly adequate coat.

yanbu. How ridiculous!

Your mum's being ridiculous. YADNBU.

Your mum is being ridiculous.

No of course you're not being unreasonable. Why on earth are you even having to ask?! Since when does being a year older warrant buying a new coat every year (unless of course it doesn't fit) The mind boggles.

Of course you are not, unless she is prepared to fork out for them.

absolutely not unreasonable. dd1 has had three seasons out of her winter coat.

You're Mum is right and I think deep down you know she is too

Your children will suffer badly from this selfish attitude you have...maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow....but some day they will.

Of course YADNBU!

ehhh?????
I purposely buy them too big so they fit for three years - too big, just right, bit small :) ok so sometimes the 3rd year doesn't work, but definitely two years.
And then ds2 wears ds1's old coats a few years later.

YANBU, if they fit & aren't threadbare then why would you spend another £60 or so. Ask your mum how she'd feel if you asked her to set fire to a wad of cash

Of course YANBU. They still fit and are in good condition. Does your Mum buy a new coat for herself every year?

What a silly question?

YANBU. You mother is though.
My dd had a coat that we said grew with her
It survived 3 years & is still going strong with my nieces.

Hmm I suppose you can whip out the sewing machine and bring them up to date fashionwise a la Gok.

It does border on child abuse though.

Madness!! Of course you shouldnt buy new ones if the old ones fit!!

I agree with worra

I am stunned any sane adult would need to ask tbh!

Blimey - I buy my dc's coats big so as to get two years out of them!! YADNBU. It would be a waste of money to buy coats when the old ones still fit!

YANBU!

YANBU. Winter coats should hopefully get at least 2 years out o fthem, and then get passed on down. DSIS still remembers the brown M&S duffle coat that she apparently wore 5 years on the trot - hers first, and then my passed down one.

YANBU.

Why on earth would you replace something that doesn't need it??

Your mum IBU.

No wonder there is so much waste around.

YANBU at all. DD still fits last year's winter coat. The only reason she might not wear it is because there are two more coats in the beautifully clean and ironed bag of hand me downs from her cousin. But she was wearing it today and I'm sure it'll have its uses.

YANBU. How strange to buy a new one if the old one still fits. DS1 has a new coat this year after his old one did him two years. DS2 now has the old one.

My mum wouldn't dream of commenting on whether my boys needed new things or not. None of her business.

I didn't think I was being unreasonable BTW. My mum has been going on and on and on about it, so thought I'd ask the jury on here.

Anyway, glad you all agree with me.