Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU re MIL and wedding?

136 replies

changeroonie · 16/02/2011 15:44

Hello all, I am a regular poster but have had to namechange for this due to people in RL knowing my usual nickname. Sorry, this will be a long one so get comfortable! Smile

DP and I are getting married at the beginning of July. From the word go my parents expressed their desire to pay for the reception. They did the same when my two older sisters got married and I know its very generous of them to do the same for us. They've also helped us loads with the planning/arrangements, and everything has been so much easier thanks to them.

However, DP's parents haven't contributed a thing, not just money but anything at all, and neither of them even bring the wedding up in conversation unless DP or I do first. The problem is the demands MIL is making on us, which I feel are unreasonable since she has contributed nothing to the wedding or its planning.

A few examples:

  • DP has told everyone he intends to get ready in our home with his best man only, and that the two of them will be making their own way to church to greet our guests as they arrive. I will be getting ready in my parent's house, then a car will arive to take my DF and I to church, and another for my DM and bridesmaids. I mentioned this to MIL and she said "well what time will FIL and I's car be arriving?" I had to explain that we had not booked a car for them, to which she replied "oooh well we have to have our own car, it is my son's wedding after all" Shock I gather DP and I are supposed to be paying for this car then?
  • I told MIL we had chosen beef as part of the main course at the reception, reply: "I would prefer chicken, can you change it?" GRRR.
  • When I was going shopping with my bridesmaids to buy their dresses MIL stated "oh no I won't be able to make it that day to get my outfit, we'll have to go another time - don't worry I won't choose anything too expensive for you" Shock There is no way I am paying for her outfit, haven't brought it up with her again since and luckily neither has she... yet. Oh and I should probably mention here I'm not paying for my own DM's outfit either!
  • MIL wants to invite long lost family members that DP hasn't seen since he was a baby. DP explained to her that we don't have room to accommodate them at the reception, as it is close family and friends only, but to compromise we would invite them to the evening party if she wished. Que massive strop and the suggestion that there are more of my family members coming than DP's - this is true but I have a larger family and we both actually know them (also DP has more friends coming than I do to even out the balance).

These are just a few of many examples.
I can imagine MIL's face on the day when she dresses in clothes she has bought herself, no car arrives to collect them, then she sits down to a meal she didn't choose herself. It would be almost funny if I didn't think her moody strops have the potential to ruin our day. In a way I almost feel sorry for her as I think she just wants to feel involved. However anything I've asked for her help with (e.g. her ideas on flowers, music, cake, anything just to get her involved) she practically turns her nose up at and doesn't seem the least bit interested.

AIBU or is she? Should we give in and let her have the things she wants to ensure a happy smiling MIL on our wedding photos?

Another thing I'm worrying about is that on the day I intend to get my DM a big bunch of flowers to say thanks for all her help, and something for my DF too. It would be so embarrassing to leave PILs out but seriously they've done nothing to help out with this wedding (and also I don't want to undermine all the effort my parents have gone to by thanking PILs for nothing!)

WWYD?

Sorry about how long this is! Blush

OP posts:
theoffsiderule · 17/02/2011 13:33

YANBU - agree with all posts re no to paying for car, no to paying for dress, no to extra guests (unless it costs you nothing to have them - paying bar / no evening buffet), no to chicken. Explain why - protocol, money, space, catering restrictions - to your DP and make him do the telling. A good "out" with the chicken might be to say that the caterers will accommodate special dietary requirements for religious/health/vegetarian reasons but not just for personal preference as the extra individual portions incur a surcharge.

If you ordinarily have a good relationship (as in you can stand to be in the same room as her), then do the flowers for both mums. My personal suggestion would be to give your mum and dad presents beforehand, thank them publicly during speeches for their support and generosity but don't present flowers to your mum. That way you don't have to do it for MIL as you've nothing to directly thank her about WRT to the wedding itself. I don't think your guests will think badly of you if you don't present flowers and if you speak movingly, that will be remembered far more than a bouquet.

I don't think I could keep the sarcasm from my voice when saying "thank you" to my MIL for anything, nor could I live with my hypocritical self as it is well known that she and I have a very mutual dislike of one another. So I wouldn't be able to do the flower thing!

Good luck and enjoy your day - you've got loads of time to deal with these hurdles, at least it's not being sprung on you with a couple of weeks to go!

supersewer · 17/02/2011 13:55

I had a complete nightmare only it was my DM causing the problems - no financial contribution but wanted to make all the decisions (you will understand when you have a daughterHmm)
She upset everyone from dressmaker to fiancee, then shouted down the phone at me one day "anyone would think this was your wedding!!"Shock

At this point fiancee told her to leave me alone and she nearly didn't come to wedding.

Poor DH is stuck with me now as I will never go through another wedding day!!!Wink

do what makes you happy, but remember it is just one day and you will have a lovely DH at the end of it to give you many beautiful days that don't involve a trollSmile

supersewer · 17/02/2011 13:56

by the way, I have a daughter now, still don't understand!

CPtart · 17/02/2011 14:03

.....god, wait until you have children!!!!!!!!!!!!

Alibabaandthe40nappies · 17/02/2011 14:09

I can't believe she is trying to get you to buy her outfit! That is hysterical, I would love to see her face when she realises you aren't Grin

And definitely no to chicken, chicken at weddings is so boring, beef much yummier Wink

MissyKLo - you didn't have your PILs on your top table? How rude are you? Hmm

chelstonmum · 17/02/2011 14:24

My DM and DF paid for our entire wedding. PIL mentioned giving us a wedding 'gift' of offering to pay for the evening tea.......I had already ordered it, consisting of a hot supper for everyone, tea, coffee and small cakes. They paid for the cups of tea!!!

PIL do not traditionaly have a wedding party car. Everyone other than bridesmaids/ushers etc buy their own outfits. I got my MIL flowers as im too nice, but I stressed my thanks to my own DM and DGM when I gave them their flowers. My MIL dictated to my DH's choice of best man, seating arrangements and quibled at my DH's lack of guests (we had the same amount each, with the exception of my grandparents, his are deceased!).

Weddings are very stresfull and sometimes you need to remember its a day for you and your DH to be, let her be a grump, and dance the night away! x

chocadoodle · 17/02/2011 15:42

Agree with other posters YANBU

No way to buying her outfit and no way to arranging them a car. If the car thing is brought up again explain DM is having a car as your parents are paying for it themselves.

Similar situation at my wedding 4 years ago. My parents contributed so I was happy to invite some of their friends. DH's parents contributed nothing, financially or interest. FIL actually said in all seriousness when we told them the wedding was booked for 1.30pm "what will I do about having my lunch?" Shock A man of routine.

I did however buy flowers for both mums. Mine was thanked for her help and contribution towards the wedding and for being a wonderful Mum and MIL was thanked for being a wonderful Mum.

If there are any further comments or questions around something they want but you don't or comparisons to your parents politely explain that as your parents are contributing to the wedding then you feel it is only fair they have some say in the occasion.

changeroonie · 17/02/2011 17:05

Wamster I know some people aren't lucky enough to have their parents pay for the reception, and believe me, I'm very thankful.

I wouldn't say I wind her up, no. We've always got on fine (been with DP for 8 years) but like I said in a previous post, we'll never be close. She's pretty hard work, but I've always made such an effort to get on with her and never given her any reason not to like me. I suppose I'm just not used to people like her because my parents are nice kind people who welcomed DP into the family from the word go and practically treat him like a son. Now that I've wrote this down, I'm thinking that maybe she really does just want to be involved - she's going about it the wrong way though, isn't she?! Unless she really does just want to ruin the day! Grin

Lamzig can't believe your MIL did that so close to the wedding! Shock

theoffsiderule you're right, at least I have time to sort this out!

Thanks to everyone who suggested getting DP to speak with her about this instead of doing it myself. I think that would probably be for the best, and I know DP will fight my corner all the way if necessary.

OP posts:
Jane054848 · 17/02/2011 17:27

I don't think you should give in to her to avoid ruining the day. My friend's MIL was a complete and utter cow all during the planning and frequently threatened not to come. But on the day even she loved it and was really nice about what a great wedding it was. Hopefully your MIL will be carried away by the lovely occasion and won't sulk and spoil things.

catsmother · 17/02/2011 17:29

I'd get MIL a lovely big bunch of flowers .............................

.... from outside Texaco. Those dyed blue crysanthemums are especially nice. Grin

MangoTango · 17/02/2011 22:30

Good idea catsmother and how about hiring her this car.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page