Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not reprt afriend for benefit fraud even tho she has told me she is livin with her partner but pretending she doesn't?

162 replies

burgerandchipswithredsauce · 08/09/2010 00:54

My friend has told me that her partner is living with her but pretending he ives with his mother so that friend can claim benefits for herself and her 3 children whilst her partner works fulltime to earn money to enable them to afford luxuries that most working families can only dream of.

AIBU not to report them because I am afraid of losing her friendship even though I do not agree with her lifestyle.

BTW myself and OH work all the hours God sends to provide ourselves and our children with basic essentials. We have no money left at the end of the week for an evening out as we cannot afford a babysitter. We have to pay our rent in full - no HB for us as we are a working family. We also have to pay full costs for childminding as we are not a single parent family. Our council tax costs per month push us over the edge.

Also our children have to have a packed lunch every day for school because we cannot afford to pay for hot school dinners. My friends children, however, get their hot school dinners free.

Friend has been awarded over £500 for a laptop for her eldest to have access to the internet so that he is not made to feel different from his peers - even though friend already has 3 PC's at her home. We have a secondhand PC which is well past its sell by date but cannot afford a laptop as we make sure our bills are paid on time as our priority.

Friend has informed us that she is going to try for another baby because that will enable her to obtain a larger house for her family. We live in a (very) modest two up, two down terraced house and would love to have another child but cannot afford to move to a larger house to make this possible. As the law states the ages of my children it would be against the law for different sexes over the age of 8 to share a bedroom. Because of this law the LA go all out to house families on benefits accordingly.

Am I jealous? Yes in monetary value I suppose I am, but overall I think I would prefer my children to know they have a mother and a father who is always there for them and will always put them first.

OP posts:
Dione · 10/09/2010 00:09

Huh?

lookatthetime · 10/09/2010 00:11

Awww Dionne (or whoever else you may be posting as) my heart bleeds for you. Welcome to the the real world!! Get off your arse and provide for yourself and your family the same as most people do!!

And BTW you know the jobs that the Illegal immigrants do? You know - the jobs that the lazy British people don't want? Well if there was no benefits you may be grateful for those jobs!

fin54 · 10/09/2010 00:12

Well you know what Dione, most of us working class people have had it hard at some time in their lives but that doesn?t' mean we all commit fraud by claiming money that we are not entitled to, we have struggled and made do with what we can afford at the time.
I have also brought up children and worked in some crap jobs and feel I am entitled to complain about spongers who are stealing (for the want of a better description of them) from the government and every other person who works and pay?s their taxes , Oh and my head is not done in but I can go to my bed at night and not fret about someone knocking on my door because I?m stealing from people.

Giddyup · 10/09/2010 00:17

But I can't find any posts made by people condoning benefit fraud or saying they don't "live legally"? Sorry if I am genuinely being thick, where are they?

Also, If I had the time or the inclination to make up pseudo persona's at this time of night to discuss strangers lives I would certainly make my-selves a bit more imaginative and less tired and trite than the tabloid nonsense being regurgitated my a person/persons on this thread.

I expect most "Benefit fraudsters" are illegal immigrant paedos too?

Giddyup · 10/09/2010 00:19

haha I knew "them illegal immigrants" would pop up eventually

Dione · 10/09/2010 00:19

Honey I am only me. I know that this must be hard for you but a lot of people disagree with you and your spite. Is that really so difficult for your little mind to deal with? Illegal immigrants are not permitted to work.

fin54 · 10/09/2010 00:23

Giddyup I can assure you I'm one person and not bugers or justusfive, I would just like to know why people think it?s ok to defraud the system and think it?s acceptable to everyone else , it?s a form of stealing as far as I?m concerned and nothing will change my mind on that

Dione · 10/09/2010 00:29

It's not that people think that it's ok to defraud the system, it's just that some people don't think that it's ok to shop a mate out of spite and probably not save the system a penny in the process.

sparky159 · 10/09/2010 00:32

ive been following this thread with dismay.
i wasnt going to make any comment as im sick of seeing stuff about benifit claiments.
as Alison said-havent you heard of 1984?
i remember reading it and it scared me-
but it is now a reality-except some are too blind to see this[well said Alison btw]
at the moment-we have all this crap in the papers about people claiming-having loads of kids ect ect ect-but why cant you see that this is just properganda?
the goverment has fucked up-and now they are pitting people against others-why cant you see this?
yeah-there is the working poor and i can really understand why the working poor are so angry-but youre looking the wrong way-
and why cant you understand this?
look at the bigger picture-stop being blind.
a while ago-there was all stuff everywhere about people coming into this country and taking the social housing and benifits ect-and actually-it was said that they was taking our jobs aswell-no win situasion for them really.
now we have the benifit families all over the papers and jolly ol cameron saying he will get rid of them!!
er with what mr Cameron-there is no jobs-
and theres even whole factorys and shopping centres closing down you dick!
this is depressing how dim our goverment is!
people who had really good carreers are now living on benifits or taking anything they can-you have youre head so much up youre arse mr cameron that you can probably see youre own tonsills.
inceddently-im one of them bastards on benifits-i also claim DLA-im disabled and so is my daughter.
i dont have a big fuckoff telly-my telly was seconhand-
and yes-people see me get in taxis-and probably think the gov is paying me too much-
but the realality is-i use the dla for taxis as im not allowed to drive and i cant get to places often[my legs are wonky and i have another condition]-but thanks to the media[who are up the goverments arse]we are all scum.
[and actually-if no ones realised-this nastiness is now seeping out to people with disabilitys]
as i said-look at the bigger picture.
BTW-op-actually-i think youre spineless-
why write what you did and then ask if you should stay her friend?
i dont agree with a lot that goes on in life-but why make the children suffer-youre jealousy has got in the way-this says more about you!
Thethersend-ive read youre last few posts-
i love youre sense of humour-thank god there is still people like you aboutSmile

sparky159 · 10/09/2010 00:48

groan-Blush
sorry op-i take back what i said to you-
i thought you said you did report her-sorry wrong thread.
dont take back the rest tho
diffrent threads-same diffrence.

kylesmybaby · 10/09/2010 01:09

justusfive - you dont have to wait to be in secondary school to get the easy access computer grant - it starts in yr 3. its also so these kids can do their homework on it (and their mums can mumsnet he he) not to be the same as other kids. oh and you also dont need to be a single parent just on income support.

thought i'd let you know the facts about it.

just reminded myself i must get to the post office tomorrow and get the reduced bus travel oyster card that i'm entitled to as i'm on income support. My cars just broken down and motobility are picking it up in the morning to fix it.

burgerandchipswithredsauce · 10/09/2010 01:10

Well I have reported her now - keep up!

Well I agree that the labour govt fucked up by giving out benefits for nowt - that is soon to change and boo hoo you may soon have to get off your arse and earn a living!

So if there are no jobs and no benefit handouts what are you going to do??

Oh yer - take the jobs that you didnt want before I guess!

OP posts:
kylesmybaby · 10/09/2010 01:11

are you going to let her know it was you that reported her?

justusfive · 10/09/2010 01:16

My disability car will be here next week too. Can't wait! It will be much easier for me to go to work to pay for scumbags in my car than catching three buses to work. I may even be able to see my three children off to school before I go.

Oh the simple pleasures in life!!

burgerandchipswithredsauce · 10/09/2010 01:19

To another new poster Kyle yes she knows I have reported her. I made no bones about it. Does that suit???

OP posts:
sparky159 · 10/09/2010 01:25

Burger-fuck off-
youre a bit thick arent you.
sorry-i shouldnt be like this towards teenagers-[sorry towards teenagers no offence-but this is a thick un]

burgerandchipswithredsauce · 10/09/2010 01:28

LOL sometimes people have to take a hint??? There again some people are too thick to recognise a hint when they hear one. Happy days and I wish you all that is coming to you!!!! It won't be long. You muppet!!

OP posts:
burgerandchipswithredsauce · 10/09/2010 01:30

Oh and BTW Illegal Immigrants do work! They do the work that people like you think is beneath you but at least they are not scrounging scum!

OP posts:
sparky159 · 10/09/2010 01:36

happy days youreself-stay happy in youre ignorence-
ah-you the muppet but you cant see it.
silly person.
goodnight.
look forward to youre ignorant ramblings tommorrow.
maybe one day you will see-ah i feel sorry for you.
someone should of told you-ignorance is not bliss.

justusfive · 10/09/2010 01:37

Well said Burger! Some people need a wake up call! Fucking free laptops indeed! I cant wait for the Conservative Govt to implement their policies and I never thought I would say that!! Anyway I'm off to work Goodnight Burger and Good Luck xx

burgerandchipswithredsauce · 10/09/2010 01:42

G'night five. Have a good shift. Don't forget to work the weekend to make sure the scum can afford their fags. Better still don't declare it. xx

OP posts:
sparky159 · 10/09/2010 01:44

oh how dare people get free laptops-
oh sounds like a troll song-
"where are we all coming from-we re from troll land where we belong"
Btw-i appologise to all the decent people on here[this includes the decent people that i dont agree with and i can see youre point and youve give a decent argument without making others feel bad-respect]

burgerandchipswithredsauce · 10/09/2010 01:51

Aww do you feel bad Sparky et al - Well tough!! So you should you parasite!

OP posts:
sparky159 · 10/09/2010 01:53

be careful burger-
the rate youre going-you wont do youre blood pressure no good-
and youll have to take up our NHS.
calm down.
you dont need to take up these resourses to prove youre point.
relaaaaaaaaaaaaaaxxxxxxxxxxxxx.
after all-the scumbags are walking into our hospitals and taking the resourses aswell innit-
as i said-relaaaaaxxxx-

burgerandchipswithredsauce · 10/09/2010 01:57

Yes you are right the scumbags are taking over the hospitals - they are usually admitted with drug or alcohol misuse. I am relaxed BTW. Scummy remarks dont bother me.
Goodnight, sleep tight. Don't forget to get out of bed in the morning - or afternoon!

OP posts: