I am so frustrated with the "no phones at school policy" that I just need a rant. First, they already are banned this year, but it seems the government thinks they didn't spell it out clearly enough, so they need to update the wording.
Since they already are banned, DS's school followed the statutory guidance by banning phones from the premises this year. That means students don't have them for their commutes, which is stupid.
Yes, I know, they'll live and make do and build resilience, blah blah blah.
Back in my day, there weren't mobile phones, but there were pay phones. The school had a phone by the entrance that we could use after school to call our parents if we needed a ride home. In a pinch, we knew that nearby shops would let us call home if we really needed to.
None of that exists anymore... BECAUSE EVERYONE HAS MOBILE PHONES!
Yes, schools can provide pouches or lockers or collect phones at the beginning or end of the day. But that all takes money or time that is better for schools to spend on LEARNING because they are SCHOOLS. (Even pouches that parents pay for still need the school to invest money in the unlocking stations, I think I have heard.)
At out school, the policy now mostly means the parents spend their late afternoons whatsapping each other saying their kids aren't home yet, and asking if anyone knows if there are activities going on.
If social media will be banned for kids, isn't that supposed to be the government protecting them anyway?
Prior to all this, our school used the "in bags switched off, never seen or heard" rule and it worked just fine.
Ok, rant over.