Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband giving me an ultimatum - forcing me to get a job or sell our house

847 replies

namechanged808 · 08/08/2023 23:04

My husband and I have a mortgage on our house.

I am a SAHM of three children, 3, 5 and 7.

He says we can't afford the house we live in and wants to move to a rented council house.

I don't want to do that as I enjoy having a house of my own, that I can make mine. I don't want to rent for the rest of my life. I like stability for my children.

My husband is now forcing me to get a job if I want to keep the house.

I don't know what to do

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Tailfeather · 08/08/2023 23:59

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/08/2023 23:54

The OP's children are 3, 5, and 7. Are people REALLY suggesting she gets off her arse and gets a JOB? Because her husband is a poor provider??? She HAS a job. A full time mother, wife, and homemaker. Confused People on here are banging on like the kids are 10 years older.

I would find any man who I had given THREE children to, who are all under 8, whining at me to get a job - because his earnings were not enough to look after his family - DEEPLY unattractive. I would question this relationship truth be told. I would be looking into selling up, moving into the relative's home that the OP mentioned - (or her parents,) and setting up a life of my own without him. OP would get all kinds of help from benefits, and her husband would be forced to give financial help too, and would have to look after his own kids 2-3 days a week.

This is literally alien to me. I can't imagine for a second my husband telling me to piss off out to work to bring more money in, or he'll put the house up for sale. He would have got a better job, or an EXTRA job to bring more money in As it happens I carried on working part time and we were OK financially, but like fuck would I have tolerated him demanding I go to work full time because he was a shit provider.

@namechanged808 Your DH needs to earn more. As I said, you HAVE a job FFS! It's not your fault he is a poor earner, (and a poor provider.) Tell him to do better! Do better for his family!

Yes, we are suggesting that. Everyone should be financially responsible for their families. Split the responsibilities however you like, but it's down to both parents.

monsteramunch · 08/08/2023 23:59

So I will be doing the exact same amount of childcare + a full time job.

Why can't you get a part time job?

Deadringer · 09/08/2023 00:00

I think the dh is being unrealistic here, they won't get a council house, and private renting is a crazy idea. Maybe he is worried about paying the bills but unless the op is highly skilled its unlikely that she will earn enough to even cover the childcare let alone contribute to the bills. And i would bet my house that even if op works full time she will still be doing all the cooking and cleaning, paying for the childcare, and ending up not a penny better off.

namechanged808 · 09/08/2023 00:00

Deadringer · 09/08/2023 00:00

I think the dh is being unrealistic here, they won't get a council house, and private renting is a crazy idea. Maybe he is worried about paying the bills but unless the op is highly skilled its unlikely that she will earn enough to even cover the childcare let alone contribute to the bills. And i would bet my house that even if op works full time she will still be doing all the cooking and cleaning, paying for the childcare, and ending up not a penny better off.

You are 100% right

OP posts:
FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 09/08/2023 00:00

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/08/2023 23:54

The OP's children are 3, 5, and 7. Are people REALLY suggesting she gets off her arse and gets a JOB? Because her husband is a poor provider??? She HAS a job. A full time mother, wife, and homemaker. Confused People on here are banging on like the kids are 10 years older.

I would find any man who I had given THREE children to, who are all under 8, whining at me to get a job - because his earnings were not enough to look after his family - DEEPLY unattractive. I would question this relationship truth be told. I would be looking into selling up, moving into the relative's home that the OP mentioned - (or her parents,) and setting up a life of my own without him. OP would get all kinds of help from benefits, and her husband would be forced to give financial help too, and would have to look after his own kids 2-3 days a week.

This is literally alien to me. I can't imagine for a second my husband telling me to piss off out to work to bring more money in, or he'll put the house up for sale. He would have got a better job, or an EXTRA job to bring more money in As it happens I carried on working part time and we were OK financially, but like fuck would I have tolerated him demanding I go to work full time because he was a shit provider.

@namechanged808 Your DH needs to earn more. As I said, you HAVE a job FFS! It's not your fault he is a poor earner, (and a poor provider.) Tell him to do better! Do better for his family!

FFS

2 of her children are in school and she's said that the 3 year old goes to nursery some of the time so yes she has time to work, she's currently spending all her time doing housework and cooking, no one can convince me that with all the kids out of the house there's hours worth of cleaning and cooking to do everyday.

CobraKaiNeverLoses · 09/08/2023 00:01

namechanged808 · 08/08/2023 23:58

Thank you xx
I am confused and frankly feeling a bit teary about all the backlash I am receiving

You’re confused and teary because people don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect a grown woman to get a job?

Right. 🙄

Sunshineboo · 09/08/2023 00:01

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/08/2023 23:54

The OP's children are 3, 5, and 7. Are people REALLY suggesting she gets off her arse and gets a JOB? Because her husband is a poor provider??? She HAS a job. A full time mother, wife, and homemaker. Confused People on here are banging on like the kids are 10 years older.

I would find any man who I had given THREE children to, who are all under 8, whining at me to get a job - because his earnings were not enough to look after his family - DEEPLY unattractive. I would question this relationship truth be told. I would be looking into selling up, moving into the relative's home that the OP mentioned - (or her parents,) and setting up a life of my own without him. OP would get all kinds of help from benefits, and her husband would be forced to give financial help too, and would have to look after his own kids 2-3 days a week.

This is literally alien to me. I can't imagine for a second my husband telling me to piss off out to work to bring more money in, or he'll put the house up for sale. He would have got a better job, or an EXTRA job to bring more money in As it happens I carried on working part time and we were OK financially, but like fuck would I have tolerated him demanding I go to work full time because he was a shit provider.

@namechanged808 Your DH needs to earn more. As I said, you HAVE a job FFS! It's not your fault he is a poor earner, (and a poor provider.) Tell him to do better! Do better for his family!

@FadeAwayAndRadiate could i ask whether you have boys? would you be happy watching them
work themselves into the ground to care for their family if his other half could contribute a little through some paid work?

and what if you have a great provider but they get ill/loose their jobs? would you really never look to helping out getting money into the family?

genuinely interested in your view as it is so opposite to how i see the world.

Titfortat78 · 09/08/2023 00:01

You would be better off staying put than private rent or even downsizing if possible.

monsteramunch · 09/08/2023 00:02

OP, you genuinely want us to believe you spend 6-8 hours every weekday cooking and cleaning? Come off it.

Deadringer · 09/08/2023 00:02

I don't know where the op lives but round my way part time term time jobs are harder to find than hen's teeth.

namechanged808 · 09/08/2023 00:02

CobraKaiNeverLoses · 09/08/2023 00:01

You’re confused and teary because people don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect a grown woman to get a job?

Right. 🙄

I access people don't agree with me.

I don't think it's necessary for people to attack me and call me an entitled gold digger.

OP posts:
namechanged808 · 09/08/2023 00:02

namechanged808 · 09/08/2023 00:02

I access people don't agree with me.

I don't think it's necessary for people to attack me and call me an entitled gold digger.

I can accept*

OP posts:
weirdoboelady · 09/08/2023 00:02

It may be that your husband is useless, cannot hold down a job etc.

However, I must say that you are coming across as very very naive, so I want to set you straight on a few facts.

The cost of mortgages is going up astronomically in this country at the moment. The cost of food and other essentials is also rising very high and very fast. You say that things are tight at the moment but you still have enough money, but it is quite likely that the full impact of these changes has not hit your family yet - for example, your mortgage may go up even higher, or it may be that you are on a fixed rate mortgage which will go up a LOT when the current period comes to an end.

I suspect that your husband may NOT be being horrible or unreasonable. Lots of people - including lots of south Asian women - are in exactly the same situation. They will have to get a job in order for their family to survive. This is what the cost of living crisis is all about. Most European women are already working (and.or panicking about finances).

You will be a complete fool if you sell your house and start renting in the current climate. Renting puts you in an even more vulnerable position. And no, council houses are NOT out there for the asking. You would probably get SOMEWHERE to live, eventually, as you have young children, but the somewhere is quite likely to be one or two rooms between you all in a B & B. You would have the lowest possible priority of all families as you had made yourself intentionally homeless by selling up.

Sorry to be so blunt, but you do not seem to understand the society you are living in or how it works at all. If you are struggling financially, yes you need to get a job. THIS is what being a team is about, not just relying on your husband to bring in money. Try reading some more threads on here about how people are struggling, with women working and looking after kids.

mightymam · 09/08/2023 00:03

As a SA woman myself who works all the hours God sends, I'm calling bullshit on you OP- it's stereotype upon stereotype in your posts. Of course you can and should fucking work- culture or no culture. You're just being an arse.

andthat · 09/08/2023 00:03

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 08/08/2023 23:54

The OP's children are 3, 5, and 7. Are people REALLY suggesting she gets off her arse and gets a JOB? Because her husband is a poor provider??? She HAS a job. A full time mother, wife, and homemaker. Confused People on here are banging on like the kids are 10 years older.

I would find any man who I had given THREE children to, who are all under 8, whining at me to get a job - because his earnings were not enough to look after his family - DEEPLY unattractive. I would question this relationship truth be told. I would be looking into selling up, moving into the relative's home that the OP mentioned - (or her parents,) and setting up a life of my own without him. OP would get all kinds of help from benefits, and her husband would be forced to give financial help too, and would have to look after his own kids 2-3 days a week.

This is literally alien to me. I can't imagine for a second my husband telling me to piss off out to work to bring more money in, or he'll put the house up for sale. He would have got a better job, or an EXTRA job to bring more money in As it happens I carried on working part time and we were OK financially, but like fuck would I have tolerated him demanding I go to work full time because he was a shit provider.

@namechanged808 Your DH needs to earn more. As I said, you HAVE a job FFS! It's not your fault he is a poor earner, (and a poor provider.) Tell him to do better! Do better for his family!

This.

OP’s partner is totally unreliable and does absolutely nothing with his three very young kids… yet the OP is the selfish one? Unbelievable!!

doireallywanttostartthisnow · 09/08/2023 00:03

OP, you really need to decide what you want. Your husband has said that he is feeling too much pressure to be the only provider, you must listen to him. Yes you are a team, so you must be a team player too. If he is saying that he doesn't think his wage is enough and that you may lose the house unless there is more money coming in, you should listen to him.
You can either leave him and be a stay at home mum on universal credit or stay with him and find another solution. That might be moving to a smaller house or cheaper area. That might be you working. That might be seeing what help is out there, could you get an interest only few years on your mortgage, not sure if this still exists, but you would have to have a plan to pay it off.
Consider night shifts if you don't want to miss time with your children. If you work your husband will have to help more with childcare, cooking and cleaning.

Ponderingwindow · 09/08/2023 00:03

Your husband is an unreliable provider.
you have no marketable skills
you have 3 children relying on you

the absolute best thing you could do for yourself and your children is to find a career. Having a stable income will benefit the whole family and it will give you power on a relationship that may currently be unbalanced.

if your husband doesn’t work a 9-5 job, then he likely can fit his schedule to do his share of the child ferrying. Many fathers who don’t do shift work also manage to adjust their schedules to cover their fair share of child responsibilities.

Agadontdontdont · 09/08/2023 00:03

lemonsaretheonlyfruit · 08/08/2023 23:47

It may not be the norm in your culture to work - but I bet there are plenty of women in your culture that do?
I would without question put aside my ideals and what the tradition is if my house was under threat.

There are millions of women out there who would give anything to spend more time with their DCs but they don't get the luxury of that as their family needs a roof over their heads, and that stability and start in life is provided by both parents - unless it's financially viable not too.

In any case - sone marriages don't last forever - and those women that have never worked (and their children) are left in a very bad position financially. I am not saying yours will end but you should be doing everything you can to safeguard your position.

I’m from the same culture as OP and pretty sure I’m a LOT older than her, women not working is not the norm in my circle of family and friends.

but they don't get the luxury of that as their family needs a roof over their heads
In any case - sone marriages don't last forever

My mum was widowed when my sister & I were a toddler and 8 months old. I’m so glad she didn’t have the OP’s mindset otherwise we definitely would have ended up on the streets! My dad had started his own business just before he died so no pensions, insurance for mum just his debt. She worked her butt off and taught us to be strong, independent individuals that can take care of ourselves.

SleepingStandingUp · 09/08/2023 00:03

namechanged808 · 08/08/2023 23:59

I helped my dad run his cash and carry

That's a job.

namechanged808 · 09/08/2023 00:03

Deadringer · 09/08/2023 00:02

I don't know where the op lives but round my way part time term time jobs are harder to find than hen's teeth.

Exactly! I don't have any qualification that is relevant to anything I could do right now.
I would have to g back to education and I can't afford that

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 09/08/2023 00:03

I think you cannot see the wood for the trees! You are focusing on one issue but ignoring the general state of your relationship.
Your husband sounds controlling and deluded. How on earth does he think you will be given a council house. Unless you are truly homeless through no fault of your own you won't even be accepted onto the list let alone given a tenancy. Your other option is private rental which would be madness if you're able to (just) afford your mortgage. Rentals are £1000+pcm and there's no security. Not that you have security with your husband.
It's your marriage so lm not going to suggest leaving him however you do need to take some responsibility too. If you feel unable to work for a few years you need to start laying the foundations for a career when the children are older, so research training options. Start small then progress. Involve your OH in these plans and if he knows there is 'light at the end of the tunnel' he may be able to apply himself better. At the moment it seems like he's panicking or just giving up. Reassure him you are both on the same side and he just needs to hang on in there until the kids are a bit older. Don't give up on your home, you'll regret it and may never get back on the housing ladder.

Tailfeather · 09/08/2023 00:03

So you don't have a daughter to set a good example to, but you have 3 sons to teach good work ethics and to show them that women are equals and entirely capable of being not only s nurturing mother but a financial provider.

porridgecake · 09/08/2023 00:03

If your youngest is at nursery already you need to get a job.
The cost of everything has rocketed recently.
Everyone is trying to save and earn more and spend less.
You will never get a council house if you sell your home.
Private renting is insecure and expensive.
You need to do everything you can to keep paying your mortgage.
Do you know how much the mortgage, energy bills, house insurance, grocery bills have increased recently?
I just renewed my house insurance and the cheapest I could get is nearly 3 times last year's bill. I spent a couple of hours today going through the household expenses to see what could be stopped or reduced. It is actually quite frightening.

fullbloom87 · 09/08/2023 00:04

@FatAgainItsLettuceTime

To be fair children are only in school 6 hours a day 5 days a week 9 months a year. There's still 3 months worth of full time childcare needed.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 09/08/2023 00:04

Mariposista · 08/08/2023 23:59

Oh boo hoo!
Get a job. So work-shy.

Boo-hoo. You are so RUDE!