Hi OP, honestly not sure how useful this thread is going to be to you! People have different tastes in wedding dresses - like in baby names, home decor, and EVERYTHING in life... If you made all your decisions according to random internet strangers' opinions you'd probably be very unhappy...? Would you get them to vote on your fiance? :)
For what it's worth I had a church wedding and still chose a very simple, understated, non-frou-frou dress. I personally don't like beaded meringue-y dresses and wouldn't ever choose that. Obviously there are a lot of people who think that without a beaded bodice and a tulle underskirt it's not a 'proper' wedding dress! But they do them, I do me, they're happy, I'm happy, life goes on.
I just think you should choose a dress you really like and feel good in and then not worry about what anyone else thinks!
My dress was a dupe of an elegant, 1930s, parachute silk vintage number. It was made by a clever friend of mine who sourced the perfect fabric and then made the design even more pared back and 'clean'. I absolutely loved it on the day and still love it in the photos 12 years on - it was totally 'me', beautiful and special but understated, not fussy. I felt completely like myself but the best version of me.
Hope you have a lovely day and find the confidence to go with whatever dress you choose.