@PirateCatQueen
We ate the puff pastry mince pies yesterday. I had forgotten about the shortcrust ones until I went in the cupboard for something else...mmm mmm.
Added more to cart.
But the mince pies bought at this time of year are just quality control, seeing which shops sell the nicest ones so you can get some more for Christmas.
A lot of the time, the best before date is before Christmas anyway. You aren't expected to save them until Christmas. This year's been bad enough without having to eat out of date substandard mince pies at Christmas.
On the other hand, Roses are a trick and you fell for it OP. They start selling the huge tubs in September because they know people will eat them all and have to buy more.
And they're even that nice now. We don't buy any of them because despite them all being horrible cheap crappy chocolate, we still manage to eat them all and then get given another tub as a gift at Christmas.