Talk

Advanced search

As of 5pm Dawn Butler says trans women ‘should never be put in women’s jails’

(107 Posts)
stumbledin Tue 18-Feb-20 17:55:41

Dawn Butler has said violent transitioning male prisoners ‘should never’ be allowed in women’s jails, as a Labour row over trans rights rages on.

But when pressed for her position today, Ms Butler told Metro.co.uk: ‘There are bodies and advisory bodies within the judicial system that everybody would need to go through before that would even be considered and that (trans women prisoners in a female prison) should never happen.’ Asked directly if she disagreed with backbencher Ms Nandy’s stance, she added: ‘Yes… the prisons service has a separate area anyway and they have discretionary ways of dealing with trans prisoners. ‘So the prison service already have all of those considerations.’

metro.co.uk/2020/02/18/labour-split-dawn-butler-says-trans-women-never-put-womens-jails-12260746/

(Not saying I believe this as anything other than a party strategy but thought I would post as we monitor Labour seesawing all over the place.)

OP’s posts: |
FloralBunting Tue 18-Feb-20 17:58:21

What this should tell you is how big this story is now, and how it is clearly having a significant impact. This is pure damage limitation.

BoreOfWhabylon Tue 18-Feb-20 17:59:50

Does she still think babies have no sex though, or has she changed her mind on that?

happydappy2 Tue 18-Feb-20 18:00:12

Just seen this.....now waiting for the backlash

TwoHeadedYellowBelliedHoleDig Tue 18-Feb-20 18:00:21

But this is the same Dawn Butler who thinks babies are born without a sex?

BatShite Tue 18-Feb-20 18:01:16

Hmm. Narrative change..out of the blue given yesterday(?) she claimed babies don't have a sex...

BINtersectionalFeminism Tue 18-Feb-20 18:02:27

But what about the giraffes?

Siameasy Tue 18-Feb-20 18:02:29

Oh dear. Popcorn!

GCAcademic Tue 18-Feb-20 18:03:56

If you ever needed a illustration of how TRAs live to fling the word “transphobia” around to try to shut people up, just count the number of times the word appears in this sentence:

The Labour Campaign for Trans Rights . . . told Metro.co.uk: ‘We believe that due to the transphobic nature of society, a culture that is transphobic, or at the very least non-confrontational to transphobic views, is enmeshed within the fabric of the Labour Party, and our campaign seeks to help confront the issue of transphobia head on.’

Mockersisrightasusual Tue 18-Feb-20 18:08:33

So where are we going to put them?

Can they move in with Dawn and the giraffes.

"There's millions," said Jeffrey, "all under one roof."

NotAnotherFeckingMuftiDay Tue 18-Feb-20 18:13:32

But what about the giraffes?

I think she is moving on to ferrets.

FloralBunting Tue 18-Feb-20 18:15:12

'You can’t have people who feel that they can’t attend a meeting because they are scared or worried.’ says Butler.

She's not even thinking about women when she says this, is she?

Datun Tue 18-Feb-20 18:15:33

As far as I'm aware, that's a complete denial of the actual policy which says if they have a GRC, they go to a female prison. Unless, I believe, they are a category A offender, because there is no such accommodation to be found in the female estate.

So, she is literally rolling back on the current policy.

I wonder how that's going to go down...

RipleysCat Tue 18-Feb-20 18:16:42

Honestly it’s like a parody now, they look ridiculous.
I am sure that before long these numpties are going to be pointing at each other with accusations of transphobia.
It’s like a competition of who can be the least transphobic ever, over you know being an effective opposition, or giving a shit about or holding the government to account over the NHS, food banks, housing etc, who cares about that when you can be talking about giraffes or braying to get rapists into women’s prisons hmm.
Boris Johnson must be pissing himself.

PiedImperial Tue 18-Feb-20 18:17:45

But Dawn thinks babies are born without a sex, so how would she know which prison anyone should go to?

CaptainKirksSpikeyGhost Tue 18-Feb-20 18:18:03

Flip flop, Flip flop.

Flip Flop.

HandsOffMyLangCleg Tue 18-Feb-20 18:19:10

Talk about mixed messages, Dawn.

I saw my Tory MP some 18 months ago and raised concerns over men being housed in the female estate.

Even though I do believe she is GC, I could tell my MP viewed the prison debate as being quite removed from her everyday life, so I am at least pleased to see more exposure being given to this very important and very real situation of dangerous and predatory men like Karen White accessing and sexually and violently assaulting women who are at their most vulnerable.

jadefinch Tue 18-Feb-20 18:21:06

I don't think there's even been a bigger shambles in politics than the Labour Party at the moment.

If you're being criticised by Dawn Butler for being too pro trans, as Lisa Nandy is, that's surely a badge of honour.

But what does Butler mean by 'a transwoman is a woman but she must never be put in a women's jail'?

And if you thought this craziness was just confined to the leader and deputy leader contenders, look at this. A group of Labour MPs have got together to show their support for trans rights by wiggling in front of a camera while holding the trans flag: twitter.com/zarahsultana/status/1229459634559291393

zanahoria Tue 18-Feb-20 18:21:43

There would be a huge incentive for every male prisoner to declare themselves a woman.

what if they all did it?

MrsSnippyPants Tue 18-Feb-20 18:27:48

Over half of all sex offenders already have zana

Floisme Tue 18-Feb-20 18:28:21

Lord above. Butler will surely get a caning for that from her lobbyists so things must be bad if even she's backtracking.

I see in that article Ms Butler also said it is ‘vital’ that the next leader or second in command is female.
grin

R0wantrees Tue 18-Feb-20 18:28:36

Did she though?

The Metro headline says "Labour split as Dawn Butler says trans men ‘should never be put in women’s jails’"

Dawn Butler has said violent transitioning male prisoners ‘should never’ be allowed in women’s jails, as a Labour row over trans rights rages on."

I have no idea what she means.

This would be so much easier to understand if she hadnt asserted that trans women are women , trans men are men & babies are born without a sex.

Mockersisrightasusual Tue 18-Feb-20 18:32:10

I have no idea what she means.

You are Dawn Butler and I claim my free £100

R0wantrees Tue 18-Feb-20 18:35:34

Lord above. Butler will surely get a caning for that from her lobbyists so things must be bad if even she's backtracking.

2018 TRA Conference where Dawn Butler MP (Shadow Women & Equalities) was keynote speaker was a who's who of prominent trans lobbyists.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3398737-We-re-Still-Here-Conference-8th-September-A-report-from-the-inside

R0wantrees Tue 18-Feb-20 18:37:17

Im not even identifying as Dawn Butler!
grin

Join the discussion

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Join Mumsnet

Already have a Mumsnet account? Log in