Talk

Advanced search

To not understand "gender grief"

(113 Posts)
PetalMettle Sun 19-Mar-17 08:35:53

E.g. Being "devastated" that you're expecting one gender over another? Maybe it's because I had a long wait for what looks like my one and only child or because I've seen people who desperately want children unable to have them, but I actually get quite annoyed that people say they have such strong preferences.
However this does seem to be quite common and universally acknowledged as a thing which the mother should be sympathised with and cosseted for.
Am I weird for feeling like it's very self indulgent unless there's a reason like an inherited disease one gender doesn't get?

quicklydecides Sun 19-Mar-17 08:38:44

Well i don't understand people who go to bed at the same time every night.
There you go, we've both discovered that other people are not the same as us!

PetalMettle Sun 19-Mar-17 08:38:49

I guess I should add where there's not structural reasons for e.g. Preferring a boy so you don't get stuck with massive dowry payments

WhiskyTangoFoxtrot Sun 19-Mar-17 08:40:00

Yes, you're weird

Of course people welcome the child they get, but being wistful for the not-quite-real one you had hopes for during pregnancy is utterly normal. And best met with understanding, not scorn.

PaperdollCartoon Sun 19-Mar-17 08:40:21

The human mind is strange and turns up things that don't always make sense.

AuntieStella Sun 19-Mar-17 08:40:47

Agree with quickly !

PetalMettle Sun 19-Mar-17 08:41:27

But @quicklydecides that's a bit different isn't it? this is about not being grateful for what you have. I guess a closer equivalent would be someone feeling grief about a free meal they've been treated to as it was Italian and not Chinese

BirdPerson Sun 19-Mar-17 08:41:52

I am currently expecting and desperately hope it is a boy. If it is a girl, yes I will be disappointed. Generally when a person doesn't get something they really want, they become disappointed. I'm sure I will get over it though, as will most parents.

CrochetBelle Sun 19-Mar-17 08:42:23

I'm grateful I've never experienced this. It is very real, and very heartbreaking, I imagine.
Just because I haven't experienced it, doesn't mean I can't respect it. It's called empathy

SailAwaySailAwaySailAway Sun 19-Mar-17 08:42:50

Yanbu to not understand it but yabu to be so judgmental and annoyed about something that, by your own admission, you don't understand.
Or is this just a 'come on everyone let's have a pop at these awful people' threads hmm

LostSight Sun 19-Mar-17 08:43:06

Is that really a thing now? It sounds really sad. I just hoped my children would be be born safely and were healthy.

noeffingidea Sun 19-Mar-17 08:43:11

whiskey there's a difference between being 'wistful' and 'devastated' though, surely?
I can't really understand it either, OP. Surely a baby is an individual human being, first and foremost, before being a boy or a girl.

Knifegrinder Sun 19-Mar-17 08:43:42

Has 'gender disappointment' now been upgraded to 'gender grief???

And it's sex disappointment/grief, rather than gender, anyway, though the reason no one says that is it sounds like something to do withberectile dysfunction

SailAwaySailAwaySailAway Sun 19-Mar-17 08:43:52

Yup. Looks like.

PetalMettle Sun 19-Mar-17 08:45:11

It's not let's have a pop, I just genuinely can't understand it. Point taken though that just because I can't understand something doesn't mean I should judge those experiencing it, as a pp said mental health is a funny thing and I wouldn't say "I can't understand why anorexics don't just eat"

DonaldStott Sun 19-Mar-17 08:45:38

Yabu for speaking of dowry payments. Are you from the past?

PetalMettle Sun 19-Mar-17 08:46:16

@knifegrinder "sex grief" has made me giggle somewhat however.

RueDeDay Sun 19-Mar-17 08:46:17

I desperately wanted a little girl, any have a little girl. I'm sure, had I had a boy, that I would have loved him just as much as I love DD and wouldn't have been able to imagine having it any other way, but equally I would still have mourned the girl I didn't have, for a time at least. I think if you have a gender preference which doesn't work out, that's a really normal reaction.

PetalMettle Sun 19-Mar-17 08:46:43

I was talking about structural issues - so at any point in culture/time

SailAwaySailAwaySailAway Sun 19-Mar-17 08:46:59

There have been some very interesting and informative threads about it in the past. I think advanced search might be a good bet if you're genuinely interested in understanding the subject.

BellonaBelladonna Sun 19-Mar-17 08:47:50

I agree OP. Just awful when the poor dc picks up on it.

stitchglitched Sun 19-Mar-17 08:48:37

I think it's fine to have a slight preference. But if you are so desperate for one sex that having the opposite would cause devastation then you have no business having a baby imo, since there is a 50-50 chance.

PetalMettle Sun 19-Mar-17 08:48:50

Thanks SA. I do appreciate I'm coming at this from a biased viewpoint and should read around the other side.

KoolKoala07 Sun 19-Mar-17 08:48:57

Personally all I want is a healthy baby (currently pregnant with first child). If I'm being honest, I would like a daughter at some point, purely because I want the relationship me and my 2 sisters have had with our mum. My husband is so uninterested in spending time with his mother and I think that would hurt in future years. Although I do think she could have treated him differently and they would have a different relationship now.
But I get that people can't help they way they feel.

noeffingidea Sun 19-Mar-17 08:49:14

Donaldstott I think dowry payments are still a current thing in some cultures and communities.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now