Watch in real time as Trans Reddit turns on one of it's own for suggesting that maybe they are biological men and arguing they are not makes them look unstable.

[SingleSexSpacesInSchools]

www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/comments/1t0t604/trans_girl_says_were_all_biological_males/

Ugh

Nope, Science GCSE hasn't gone downhill.

GCSE Biology specifications still state that XY makes a male and XX is female. Puberty differences, contraception and tje female menstrual cycle are also still in the specifications.

Source: been a science teacher for 18 years.

💯

💐

"...posters like onepost showing up and banging on about there being no difference between biological women and trans women post-surgery."

I've never said there is no difference. It is your claim that I 'bang on' about no difference. Just as sex realists make wild claims and impose motivations on others to strengthen their beliefs amongst themselves.

I hit enter too early and forgot to add this quote from a surgeon who performed such surgeries as well:

Georges Burou, a Casablancan physician who has operated on over 700 American men, expressed the superficiality of sex-conversion surgery in these words: “I don’t change men into women. I transform male genitals into genitals that have a female aspect. All the rest is in the patient’s mind.”

In 5 years you may not be able to talk like this

This is a wild ride. The straw neovagina is formidable!

Because vaginas are not just sex toys. It is a misogynistic reduction that allows men to claim to be women

And ewwww.

Last year (May 2025) AQA Biology 2 paper had a question that required students to correctly sex a rabbit, from the chromosome array. Rabbits, as other mammals, have XX chromosomes as female. Even my bottom set students got that one right! And the examiners comments remarked that it was, nationally, a well answered question.

A reasonable person would know my answer was not a comprehensive declaration on the function of all vaginas.

In 5 years I could be dead. So, there's a possibility. Yes.

I only have direct experience of one vagina. I'm pleased that it is a genuine one, that has coped with everything that it is designed for. It doesn't, of course, have any feelings, but is part of a wonderful reproductive system which, in cooperation with a male reproductive system, has done its job. It is not a surgical imitation, carved and sewn out of other body parts. It is an organically grown part of the complete body of a wonderful, glorious woman. It is fully integrated with the rest of that complex organism.

I'm so, so sorry for what you went through SirEctor.

I'm e-hugging you very hard right now.

And yes, you're so right regarding the vile misogyny of reducing our complex reproductive systems to a hole. Male people will never understand.

This is getting silly now

That's awesome for you.

A Frankenfanny is not a vagina. You know this really.

Is this the official sex realist term of art?

You are not the only transwomen who posts on here. You have expressed the belief that you are a woman because people “treat you as one”. It is offensive to biological women to tell us that being a woman is only about your reflection in the eyes of others.

I have NEVER seen you express any respect for or acknowledgement of the experiences and understanding of female people that might lie outside your own experience. It is all about the appropriation and minimising of differences. I can see why you would need to do that, but don’t imagine that it changes how biological women feel about the attempts to remove our ability to discuss the reality of our lives without including males who have adopted a female identity.

You don’t have to come here to repeatedly tell us off, that’s your choice.

It’s how I went from be kind to here lol

@nutmeg7 it's important that there is genuine discourse on the topic rather than this being an echo chamber just like every other place on the internet

Eerrr no. Makes with a trans identity who get. That surgery need to dilate every day for the rest of their lives. Why do you not know this? I thought as you’d had the surgery you would know. Or are you er… fibbing about that?

"...You have expressed the belief that you are a woman because people “treat you as one”.

I have shared this as one aspect in an answer to "how do you know you're woman?" and other sex realist 10 most common questions regarding the social lives of trans women.

"I have NEVER seen you express any respect for or acknowledgement of the experiences and understanding of female people that might lie outside your own experience."

I assume this is because you choose what to see and squeeze that into your belief system. You choose to evaluate life experience as appropriation. You choose to recontextualise answers and statements about lives within a value system that invalidates the experiences of such people in this space.

There is no other sex realist space like this on the Internet. I am here to understand. Sometimes I need to challenge assumptions to do this.

As I said, not every sex realist belief is real.

Parklife

I have no idea what a parklife is.