JKR vs Police Scotland?

[IcakethereforeIam]

Tras are trying to get JKR arrested.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/03/10/trans-activists-scottish-police-arrest-jk-rowling-crime/

https://archive.ph/5TEU4 highland fling yourself over the paywall, cos Scottish!

Thought to give IW a break.

The Hate Crime...crime(?) comes into force on 1st April, according to the article. The SNP has not engaged with any of the organisations who have expressed concerns and no-one knows what, if any, training the Police have been given.

"attention-seeker" really. You see what IW writes on the twits and that's the Executive Summary. Yeah, IW is a bit of an attention-seeker but yanno, we love IW really, such a character

Since you are trying to twist context and make a direct comment about one person into a generalisation of a group (which is very naughty and dishonest of you) perhaps you can start off with your meaning of transphobia.

< waits >

It's just as transphobic when applied to Willoughby alone.

It's not transphobic at all.

It's an accurate observation based on Willoughby's own ramblings.

Interesting that Willoughby misgendering others and calling lesbians 'men' for not being feminine enough for Willoughby's liking is merely ''attention seeking'', but a woman pointing out the motivation for such behaviour is being ''abusive''.

Why does IW say that women with short hair, wearing jeans and checked shirts are men?

I mean that sincerely, why?

If not misogyny, then what is it?

Why does IW say that one of these photos is a woman and the other is six men?

What is the motivation behind it, if not misogyny?

Stated about all TWs, that would be transphobic as it's an unfair generalisation. It's been stated about a specific individual in this instance, based on that individual's documented behaviour. That difference in scope and basis in individual behaviour are critical.

Trans women are 'cosplaying a misogynistic male fantasy of what a woman is,' surely passes the very high bar for what even gender critical people think is transphobic?

Why am I unsurprised that the resident TRA/MRA would post this completely dishonest and totally inaccurate version of what JKR actually tweeted.

You are aware that we can all read the actual tweet for ourselves aren't you DadJoke? How embarrassing that you have to stoop to dishonesty to attempt to make your argument when your dishonesty can be so clearly exposed.

If "It's just as transphobic when applied to Willoughby alone." Then why the need to alter the context and make it appear JKR was speaking about all trans women? It is my belief your intention was to deliberately mislead. If you had posted the original unedited and made the argument you are now making, that would have been much better for you. Once you are caught with your hands in the cookie jar, you've already lost the credibility.

The thing is JKR in her tweet you butchered was taking about the behaviour of one individual. JKR was being critical of a person's behaviour irrespective of their other traits. Once you changed the context to all trans people it was then about the trait of being trans not behaviour. You changed the context from an individual's behaviour to a group of people sharing a trait ( not behaviour ). You changed the very meaning in doing so. If JKR had said what you falsely reported I would agree with you that it would have been transphobic. She would have accused a group of people of bad behaviour based purely on their shared single trait. But she didn't. She commented on one person's behaviour because of their behaviour. The motivation behind that person's behaviour may be connected to that trait for that individual, but it was not the trait that JKR was critical of. It wasn't transphobic abuse, it was criticism of behaviour.

If you have to change what JKR said to try and make your point maybe your point isn't as solid as you think it is.

Is there a single gender critical person on this board who thinks it was transphobic?

We don't have a definition of transphobic other than 'you're all big meanies'

Au contraire - everything is transphobic -
https://wingsoverscotland.com/everything-is-transphobic/

I've seen it all now

https://twitter.com/HazelAppleyard_/status/1767345137523233220/photo/1

JKR: Tinkerbell Syndrome: the conviction that unless all women, everywhere, believe a man is a woman, he will die.

https://twitter.com/jk_rowling/status/1767570059017273675

😂

Yeah that has the same grounding and foundations in logic as everytime somone farts God kills a kitten.

Men don't get to tell women how it is to be a woman. Men don't get to tell women what misogyny is. It's both absurd and insulting.

Thanks @Waitwhat23 . That clears the matter up.
It really is basically everything.

😲 Christmas dinner hates cats!!!

Brussel sprouts mass genocide the most vulnerable cats!
Bigots! Who would do such a thing??????

Anyway, bat faeces is supposed to be even better than horse manure for roses (true) so maybe collect it up for fertiliser and "good things can grow from bad"

Depends what you mean by 'transphobic'.

Explains the sudden volte-face.

'Isobel Gowdie gave a person in the street a dirty look motivated by racism/transphobia/ageism/ableism/sectarianism'

Those of subleased with "resting bitch face" are going to be in a lot of trouble. I am one. I'd better start my crowdfunder for my defence now.

Personally I think everyone who asks the police to record an NCHI against another person should also have that record of reporting against themselves. The police should consider if the reporter is a serial reporter using the police as a weapon against people they disagree with in thier considerations.
Disclose it to employers doing vetting too. This person recorded 200 NCHIs against other people last year. Hummmmmmmm.........

Yep

Those of subleased with "resting bitch face" are going to be in a lot of trouble. I am one. I'd better start my crowdfunder for my defence now.

Or we could start wearing veils. 'Offending blokes' is not that far off 'raising impure thoughts in blokes', I honestly wonder wtf the SNP are thinking. Or if they think at all.

Her tweet, every bit of it, was directed at IW being transgender. There is plenty to criticise about IW without being transphobic.

Is it only IW who JKR thinks is "cosplaying a male fantasy of womanhood" or all trans women? Do you honestly think JKR thinks otherwise? She's just said out loud what she thinks about trans women in general.

AND anyone/anything identifying as "catgender"

Dog-genderists are dancing in the streets . . .