Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Taxpayers should pay £40 million for trans men to have penises fitted abroad to bypass NHS waiting lists

132 replies

inkjet · 03/12/2022 09:23

apple.news/AOPrr5ERrTlOl2lwYl1lM3g

It’s an LBC article I saw on Apple News.

“Some 7.1 million people were on the waiting list in October, with 400,000 waiting for more than a year. Mr Brown said he understood that his group’s demands could seem outrageous in this context.”

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 03/12/2022 18:06

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/12/2022 18:04

That is not what I expected.

This thread must have someone here, with their thumb absolutely hovering to report. Maybe it's the spokesman in the OP.

Someone is always waiting I think. Anything less than enthusiasm for these things, is considered transphobic.

VioletLemon · 03/12/2022 18:07

You are completely correct. Any NHS funds need to be directed at positive mental health and wellbeing in early years, for young parents and directed to CAMHS. We need healthy preventative innovation in health.

If society as a whole can overcome awful aggressive marketing of sex stereotypes, breakdown homophobia and support isolated and vulnerable young people who often find their tribe among reddit posts and social media groups promoting trans ideologies as a cure all, there could be hope. It's all very sad but being masculine and a woman doesn't make you a man.

Also the disgusting disease of porn that is terrifying girls and young women into not wanting to be held in a male gaze or have these expectations placed on them that they think boys or other girls are looking for.

pecanpie24 · 03/12/2022 18:12

They should be paying for this surgery by themselves just as normal tax payers do every single day for cosmetic surgery. This angers me greatly. Complete con!!!!!

2bazookas · 03/12/2022 18:15

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 03/12/2022 10:51

7 million ? That can’t be right. There are only Thirty million adult females in the UK, and if you say that at least two million will be over sixty and therefore unlikely to be caught up in this, that would mean that one In four British adult women are yearning for a stick on penis.

Do we hazard think that this spokesperson may not be too good at counting? (I’m tempted to make a joke about where they keep their brains, but that would be flippant )

7 million is the entire NHS treatment waiting list. For everything. New hearts, hips, fertility etc.

Pressure group Transactual says there are about 2,000 people waiting to have the (phalloplasty) operation in the UK.

Waiting a few years is no bad thing; time to try living as a man. A significant number of trans youngsters change their minds
post surgery.

Tillylime · 03/12/2022 18:17

The NHS will no doubt be sued eventually for allowing surgery on the
poor dears who didn’t realise what having a huge operation compromising your bladder function actually meant.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/12/2022 18:17

If they want enthusiasm, I'll post more from Gabriel. Remember, this is from someone who thinks it was a good decision!

extract

On discharge day five, I woke up with a six-square-inch pool of blood seeping through three layers of bandages from the donor site (“Fine, nothing unusual,” came the text back), which during surgery had been covered with thin skin shaved from my other thigh with an instrument like a motorized cheese slicer, then laid over and stitched into the edges around the exposed muscle of the donor hole. On day seven, blood soaked through two additional layers of bandages and another of gauze. (“Looks good,” the doctor said when I had my friend emergency-drive me back to the city.) Every morning, I got up, after trying to sleep perfectly still on my back with my penis propped and my hips and my legs aching fire, and hobbled with the help of a cane to the toilet, where I used one hand to keep my penis level and the other to reach over to the sink and fill a bowl with warm water, then slowly, gently wash my genitals. Still, my whole lap smelled unrecognizable, not-human seeming, like a cross between hospital air and a livestock barn. (“Everyone freaks out about that,” a different nurse said over the phone, laughing a little, when I asked if I was okay.) For more than 30 days, my donor thigh oozed fibrinous fluid from wet holes, which became big, open red gashes where the skin graft hadn’t taken. (“It’ll close. It’s just like any other wound,” said Dr. Andrew Watt, the other microsurgeon, at my fourth weekly post-op appointment — to which I’d responded, “Is it?”) My other leg, the one the graft had been taken from, had dried blood always flaking from the sometimes burning, four-by-seven-inch skinned site trying to regrow itself, and at some point my penis started to separate a bit from my body.

It was a tiny gap, the littlest hole, between the base and my pelvis at the underside where the stitches hadn’t closed, small compared with many people’s wound separation, as it’s called, which happens “90 percent of the time” and is self-resolving. But it was so distressing that I mostly just refused to look at or touch it for two weeks, the panic spreading harsh electricity through my whole torso, even worse and for much longer than the time I stood alone in my kitchen, hyperventilating, holding my penis level in one hand and my phone in the other as I Googled, “What does gangrene smell like?”

“The whole process is constant body horror,” Berrian said at one point — after he’d told me that the penis-tip discoloration I was worried about might just be sloughing tissue that’s dying off, which is also fine. And this was a recovery with no complications that required surgery. The overall proportion of phalloplasties that need surgical revision, while lower for some surgeons (including mine), is about one in two. The highest number of corrective follow-up surgeries needed by anyone I know personally is 12.

This is what some people do for their penises. And though phalloplasties that survive a couple of weeks tend to survive, period, through all manner of regular penis life and then some, I was hysterical over the possibility that mine wouldn’t. If it died, I felt certain, I would die. I had pushed myself up against the absolute limits of enduring life without it, and I wouldn’t go back to before.

I couldn’t go back to before.

One day, in that first week out of the hospital, I stood with my leg in a brace and my weight on a cane, thudding the tip of it rhythmically into the floor while listening to upbeat Billie Eilish. It was the closest thing to dancing I could do, but I understood then, for the first time, that what dancing is about is that Our. Bodies. Are. Spec. Tacular.

Soothsayer1 · 03/12/2022 18:29

I'm shocked and horrified that these patients have been persuaded to subject themselves to this😟

DdraigGoch · 03/12/2022 18:31

7.1 million people were on the waiting list in October, with 400,000 waiting for more than a year

I could draw two possible hypotheses from those two figures. The first is that the NHS routinely to provide around 6.7m operations per year, and 400k aren't being seen quickly enough.

The second possibility is that there has been a sudden surge in applications - social contagion spreading like wildfire.

I think we all know which is more likely.

Billybear1 · 03/12/2022 18:33

Its not just the cost of the surgery, its the aftercare and further cost when complications occur.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/12/2022 18:34

Tillylime · 03/12/2022 18:17

The NHS will no doubt be sued eventually for allowing surgery on the
poor dears who didn’t realise what having a huge operation compromising your bladder function actually meant.

Given that NHS clinics seem very happy to give patients misleading information, it's impossible to see any other reasonable outcome.

I think that surgeons who have realistic views to impart on likely surgery outcomes and unlikely-but-possible outcomes must self-select out of these surgical specialities. The only ones left are either evangelical about the benefits of these procedures, or sociopaths who are willing to lie.

WomaninBoots · 03/12/2022 18:41

Death cult.

That's all I can think reading those extracts.

RedToothBrush · 03/12/2022 18:46

MrsOvertonsWindow · 03/12/2022 16:13

Contrast these demands with the relative silence about the abysmal state of maternity care for women with (I think) nearly half of all NHS trusts with services rated inadequate. The silence & lack of action from the NHS about this in contrast to the endless resources spent on rainbow washing really tells you where women and babies stand on the priority scale - it's right at the bottom.

NHS negligence payments in maternity dwarf whole department budgets.

ErrolTheDragon · 03/12/2022 18:47

DdraigGoch · 03/12/2022 18:31

7.1 million people were on the waiting list in October, with 400,000 waiting for more than a year

I could draw two possible hypotheses from those two figures. The first is that the NHS routinely to provide around 6.7m operations per year, and 400k aren't being seen quickly enough.

The second possibility is that there has been a sudden surge in applications - social contagion spreading like wildfire.

I think we all know which is more likely.

Those figures are total NHS waiting lists.

According to the linked piece
'Pressure group Transactual says there are about 2,000 people waiting to have the operation in the UK.' (Ie phalloplasty) So the £40 million figure is 20K each to queue dodge.

zen1 · 03/12/2022 18:52

There does seem to be much more of a push for females who wish to transition to have surgery. I wonder how many transwomen are on the waiting list for a surgical procedure?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/12/2022 18:56

Hysterectomy is sometimes clinically indicated for women as a last-ditch method when women's menstrual conditions are making normal life impossible. Yet the NHS is very reluctant to perform hysterectomies in such situations, because it is not a risk-free procedure at all. It requires general anaesthetic, constitutes major surgery and...carries the risk of post hysterectomy vaginal vault prolapse.

The terrifying thing is that when I speak to middle-aged women who've had hysterectomies for clinical reasons, they all seem to have been thoroughly informed about the risks beforehand, but if you speak to younger females who've had a hysterectomy for elective reasons... they don't.

informational link

ClaphamSouth · 03/12/2022 19:03

I'm sure I saw a discussion on here about a Tissue Viability Nurse being advertised for in relation to an NHS gender surgery service. I know most hospitals have these specialist nurses, but does each surgical department usually have their own?

Soothsayer1 · 03/12/2022 19:17

WomaninBoots · 03/12/2022 18:41

Death cult.

That's all I can think reading those extracts.

yes that kind of thing!
It's as if they have surrendered themselves to the process and are now glorifying in the pain and horror, I think part of it may be that it aligns with the idea of having some kind of higher calling, an arduous initiation ceremony after which you become a new being, there are similar rituals around puberty for boys in some tribal cultures I think? There is some kind of symbolic death and then you are reborn. This kind of thing seems to align with that, I think it connects with unconscious archetypes and that's part of the mechanism via which the patients are drawn in so that they commit themselves?

Managinggenzoclock · 03/12/2022 19:18

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/12/2022 18:17

If they want enthusiasm, I'll post more from Gabriel. Remember, this is from someone who thinks it was a good decision!

extract

On discharge day five, I woke up with a six-square-inch pool of blood seeping through three layers of bandages from the donor site (“Fine, nothing unusual,” came the text back), which during surgery had been covered with thin skin shaved from my other thigh with an instrument like a motorized cheese slicer, then laid over and stitched into the edges around the exposed muscle of the donor hole. On day seven, blood soaked through two additional layers of bandages and another of gauze. (“Looks good,” the doctor said when I had my friend emergency-drive me back to the city.) Every morning, I got up, after trying to sleep perfectly still on my back with my penis propped and my hips and my legs aching fire, and hobbled with the help of a cane to the toilet, where I used one hand to keep my penis level and the other to reach over to the sink and fill a bowl with warm water, then slowly, gently wash my genitals. Still, my whole lap smelled unrecognizable, not-human seeming, like a cross between hospital air and a livestock barn. (“Everyone freaks out about that,” a different nurse said over the phone, laughing a little, when I asked if I was okay.) For more than 30 days, my donor thigh oozed fibrinous fluid from wet holes, which became big, open red gashes where the skin graft hadn’t taken. (“It’ll close. It’s just like any other wound,” said Dr. Andrew Watt, the other microsurgeon, at my fourth weekly post-op appointment — to which I’d responded, “Is it?”) My other leg, the one the graft had been taken from, had dried blood always flaking from the sometimes burning, four-by-seven-inch skinned site trying to regrow itself, and at some point my penis started to separate a bit from my body.

It was a tiny gap, the littlest hole, between the base and my pelvis at the underside where the stitches hadn’t closed, small compared with many people’s wound separation, as it’s called, which happens “90 percent of the time” and is self-resolving. But it was so distressing that I mostly just refused to look at or touch it for two weeks, the panic spreading harsh electricity through my whole torso, even worse and for much longer than the time I stood alone in my kitchen, hyperventilating, holding my penis level in one hand and my phone in the other as I Googled, “What does gangrene smell like?”

“The whole process is constant body horror,” Berrian said at one point — after he’d told me that the penis-tip discoloration I was worried about might just be sloughing tissue that’s dying off, which is also fine. And this was a recovery with no complications that required surgery. The overall proportion of phalloplasties that need surgical revision, while lower for some surgeons (including mine), is about one in two. The highest number of corrective follow-up surgeries needed by anyone I know personally is 12.

This is what some people do for their penises. And though phalloplasties that survive a couple of weeks tend to survive, period, through all manner of regular penis life and then some, I was hysterical over the possibility that mine wouldn’t. If it died, I felt certain, I would die. I had pushed myself up against the absolute limits of enduring life without it, and I wouldn’t go back to before.

I couldn’t go back to before.

One day, in that first week out of the hospital, I stood with my leg in a brace and my weight on a cane, thudding the tip of it rhythmically into the floor while listening to upbeat Billie Eilish. It was the closest thing to dancing I could do, but I understood then, for the first time, that what dancing is about is that Our. Bodies. Are. Spec. Tacular.

This is heartbreaking and horrific. I am not anti trans people. I desperately want to protect vulnerable children (and adults too unless an extreme last resort) from this sort of experience. I worry so much what will happen when those who had these kind of appalling surgeries done ‘wake up’ to what they have been able to do to themselves and that no one who should have known better, stopped it from happening.

We can’t let people go through this.

ClaphamSouth · 03/12/2022 19:19

Found it - it was MNers discussing planned masculinising genital surgery services being opened at Chelsea and Westminster https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/nhsserviceeforprovisionnof_mas#incoming-2108473

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/12/2022 19:23

ClaphamSouth · 03/12/2022 19:19

Found it - it was MNers discussing planned masculinising genital surgery services being opened at Chelsea and Westminster https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/nhsserviceeforprovisionnof_mas#incoming-2108473

Excellent search-fu!

WomaninBoots · 03/12/2022 19:41

Soothsayer1 · 03/12/2022 19:17

yes that kind of thing!
It's as if they have surrendered themselves to the process and are now glorifying in the pain and horror, I think part of it may be that it aligns with the idea of having some kind of higher calling, an arduous initiation ceremony after which you become a new being, there are similar rituals around puberty for boys in some tribal cultures I think? There is some kind of symbolic death and then you are reborn. This kind of thing seems to align with that, I think it connects with unconscious archetypes and that's part of the mechanism via which the patients are drawn in so that they commit themselves?

Yes. It's real "descent into hell" stuff isn't it.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/12/2022 19:42

Managinggenzoclock

I worry so much what will happen when those who had these kind of appalling surgeries done ‘wake up’ to what they have been able to do to themselves and that no one who should have known better, stopped it from happening.

That reminds me of Scott Newgent's posts. Scott is another adult human female who went through phalloplasty, but Scott's procedures went much more badly than Gabriel's. Now Scott is dedicating their life to calling out medical transition. I'll post the details of how it went wtong in another post.

extract

The road to medical transition had plenty of warning signs. Each time the doubt arose, I reached out to professionals to help me figure out what would be best for my life. As I look back, I realize their influence over my journey, and I recognize the power these two therapists not just held but still hold over my life because medical transition? It's not reversible; the decision to transition medically cannot be undone.

When I think of these conversations now, my blood boils because I recognize that if these conversations went differently? I might have made the right decision, the decision not to medically transition. I realize now that not transitioning was the right choice, yet I live the wrong decision. The bad decision and the responsibility of these therapists? It feels criminal like they need to be held accountable for what they pushed. I realize that will never happen. But what I can do? I can walk you through how to make a different decision if you are in the quandary I was.

I listen with an open heart, piercing tongue, and take my words and SCREAM Louder with all my love.

Scott

(Continues)

Lord knows I will never get the chance, but I wonder how these two therapists would take my new responses? If they knew that what they were pushing for would result in my life being cut short, knowing my kids would not have me for the period parents are supposed to be here. Knowing the health issues I still face and will face for life, would their response change? Their encouragement initiated a long line of suffering from generation to generation for many connected to me, not just me.

I wish I were able to go back to each pivotal point and react differently. If I could, here is what I would say to the therapists pushing me to transition medically.
The first therapist (A Trans Woman) asked me, "So, how long have you been dressing in male clothing?"

My initial response was silence with the realization that she was right; I was born in the wrong body. I instantly became embarrassed for missing something that seemed so apparent to her. My response now, after the journey I have taken.....or shall I say...endured.

Today, this is how I would respond:

"How dare you say something like that to someone who is gender-confused, projecting the idea that clothing magically makes someone male or female. As a trans woman, how dare you use your position as a therapist to justify your decision to have plastic surgery to create an illusion of a woman. Your desire and the key here is your desire to keep your delusion close forces people at vulnerable times in their lives to deal with your issues. How dare you!
"I do not have male clothes on; I have heels, lipstick, earrings, eyeliner, and a silk blouse with female slacks to a female business suit. Yes, I am a female business sales executive. Does that make me even more male that I dominate every man that ever tried to sustain my numbers? So tell me what precisely out of all the female attire I described makes me a biological male and proves I was born in the wrong body? Because from where I'm sitting? We need to change seats because you, yes, you "Big Boy", you are the one that needs serious help."

The second therapist responded to my concern and apprehension about going through the phalloplasty, the transman bottom surgery. "Scott, why wait? What's the difference in a month or two? You are correcting an error in your gender, and it's so brave you could be such an inspiration to younger trans."

Today I would say,

"An inspiration because I will be enduring an entirely cosmetic surgery that is experimental at best and has a 67% complications rate. I am an inspiration because I am brave enough to allow a surgeon who is banned from surgery in California to experiment on me with nine medical malpractice cases. It is an inspiration for not taking an extra year to understand this surgery and the absolute carnage it renders on every person who completes it. An inspiration?

"You out of line with that comment, and another thing? I don't give a rat's ass if I am an attractive man and someone you would be interested in if you met me on the street? That comment was out of line too, and someday soon? Therapists like you? The carnage will catch up with you. "

Trans Rational Voices website

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/12/2022 19:50

Scott's description

"During my own transition, I had seven surgeries. I also had a massive pulmonary embolism, a helicopter life-flight ride, an emergency ambulance ride, a stress-induced heart attack, sepsis, a 17-month recurring infection due to using the wrong skin during a (failed) phalloplasty, 16 rounds of antibiotics, three weeks of daily IV antibiotics, the loss of all my hair, (only partially successful) arm reconstructive surgery, permanent lung and heart damage, a cut bladder, insomnia-induced hallucinations—oh and frequent loss of consciousness due to pain from the hair on the inside of my urethra. All this led to a form of PTSD that made me a prisoner in my apartment for a year. Between me and my insurance company, medical expenses exceeded $900,000," Scott writes.

"During these 17 months of agony, I couldn't get a urologist to help me. They didn't feel comfortable taking me on as a patient—since the phalloplasty, like much of the transition process, is experimental."

From Quillette

Slothtoes · 03/12/2022 20:03

These stories from people that have been experimented on while thinking they are getting ‘treatment’ are horrific.
And the NHS should have nothing to do with this gaslighting of vulnerable patients whatsoever. These surgeries are way too dangerous physically and mentally and what is all that risk actually to achieve? You can’t ever change your biological sex. You can’t ever have female or male sexual function or sensation with a surgically constructed roll of flesh as a ‘penis’. This is just heartbreaking. More support and more therapy for vulnerable people but the NHS should never provide or fund others to provide this risky experimentation on vulnerable people.

WomaninBoots · 03/12/2022 20:24

It is absolute insanity to cause so much damage to a person deliberately. How much therapy would it take to get a person accepting themselves as a woman who is "gender non-conforming" (I mean.... whatever the heck that means anyway)? Not that much. (If there wasn't the incessant trans cult brainwashing going around anyway.). Compared to the hours and hours of horror and pain and complete mutilation of a healthy body? Followed probably by therapy to come to terms with the damage done.

It is insane.

Swipe left for the next trending thread