It doesn't bother me to distinguish between AGP and other reasons for a male to desire entry into spaces and rights designated for women only.
I just don't care what the reason is. The answer is no
This ^^
What is of particular concern are the reasons & implications for children, especially young females being diagnosed with 'gender dysphoria' which seem markedly different to adult males. Listening to those who describe themselves as 'detransitioners' or 'desisters' requires that we seriously consider how 'kind' or 'progressive' it is to prioritise the affirmation of belief in gender identities over the material reality of children & young people's sexed bodies.
January 2020 Standpoint article by Helen Joyce:
'Speaking up for female eunuchs
The woes of “detransitioners” are a warning: treating children with gender dysphoria is riskier than zealots admit'
(extract)
“I regret it all,” says a slight 23-year-old in a lumberjack shirt, hunched behind a microphone. She is one of eight young detransitioners from several European countries here in Manchester. All are lesbian. They, and many in the audience, see the doctors and clinicians who supported their transitions as the post-modernist version of those who sought to turn gay people straight—only now they are seeking to fix bodies rather than sexual desires. “Transition has been presented as so progressive, but the only thing I see is it reinforcing gender stereotypes,” says one.
“If there is a ‘gay conversion therapy’ of our times, it’s this,” says Charlie Evans, the network’s founder, who identified as trans for a decade before switching back last year, aged 28. Of the 300 or so detransitioners who responded to her social-media call some months ago, most were young and female. That chimes with the changing caseload at paediatric gender clinics around the world, which used to see mostly prepubescent boys but now mostly see teenage girls.
These young women have been indelibly marked by their quest for manhood. Five took cross-sex hormones: their voices are deep and some have receding hairlines. Five had their breasts removed, and two their ovaries and wombs as well. Those who underwent hormone treatment will not know whether it harmed their fertility until they try to have children. Those without reproductive organs know they never will.
The eloquence of a 23-year-old German who goes by “Satan Herself” (@sathananas on Twitter) prompts tears among many. She talks about the difficulty of living as a young lesbian without cultural role models or social networks, in a world that values women only insofar as men find them attractive. Meeting other detransitioners was a revelation, she says. “Where have these women been all my life? . . . It was just so normal to be a lesbian and a masculine woman and I’ve never felt that, ever.”
Between 14 and 16 she was repeatedly hospitalised with anorexia.She started breast-binding at 18, seeing a gender therapist at 19, taking testosterone a month after her 20th birthday, and had a mastectomy, hysterectomy, and oophorectomy (removal of ovaries). “I’m really glad my parents forced me into treatment for my eating disorder and didn’t let me die,” she says. “I wish someone had been there to tell me not to get castrated at 21.”
One young woman after another describes eating disorders, discomfort with her same-sex orientation and alienation from “compulsory femininity”: pink, glitter and princesses—and body-shaming and ubiquitous porn. In gender therapists’ telling, they say, transition was their salvation. “There’s a very strong narrative that if you don’t transition you are going to kill yourself,” says Satan Herself. “I genuinely thought it was the only option.” (continues)
standpointmag.co.uk/issues/february-2020/speaking-up-for-female-eunuchs/