Interesting hypocrisy from the TRAs

[Pota2]

twitter.com/joss_prior/status/1180592610894700547?s=20

See, I naively thought that medical transition wasn’t a requirement, that it was literal violence to point that out in the case of Lily Madigan. But apparently it seems you do have to medically transition- otherwise you’re just a faker and a bullshitter. Well, if you were born female, in any event.

Meanwhile Lily lands women’s officer job without a single hormone taken.

Nicked from elsewhere, apparently originated on GC Reddit. Very appropriate for this thread.

Ooh, if we're playing this game can I be Jo Rowling? Only I'd quite like the extra money.

I could also be Lang's slightly more evil twin.

If a male has hoop earrings and a necklace, is that enough to say they’ve transitioned so if they then take the earrings off they could then say they have detransitioned?

Asking for a friend.

Joss is here in spirit...

twitter.com/joss_prior/status/1180769014437560320?s=19

OldCrone
Men become women by putting on a dress

That is so transphobic! Men do not have to wear a dress to be women.

I could also be Lang's slightly more evil twin.

Welcome to the family!

Kittens

If you’re going to be Jo Rowling, I’ll be Robert Galbraith.

#genderequality

That said, everyone knows I'm really Lewis Moonie's trans alter ego, right?

(The swearing gives me away.)

Lol, nice try, Joss, you saddo. Charlie said she identified as a man so why is that suddenly insufficient? Why is it enough for males to be real women even if they neither medically nor socially transition, like Alex Drummond, Cathy Brennan or Danielle Muscato?

That said, everyone knows I'm really Lewis Moonie's trans alter ego, right?

Um. Should we be saying Oflewis in that case?

twitter.com/faintlyfalling/status/1180769531997892608?s=19

Men can and do:

• Menstruate
• Give birth

Men do not:

• Wear bikinis

Also:

• This is not about stereotypes.
• This is about breaking the binary.

Got it.

That said, everyone knows I'm really Lewis Moonie's trans alter ego, right?

Damn, I wanted to be Lewis Moonie. I always fancied a Lordship.

OK fine, I admit it - I'm actually Ricky Gervais.

OK fine, I admit it - I'm actually Ricky Gervais

With that username? I bet you’re actually his cat Ollie.

Um. Should we be saying Oflewis in that case?

Doxxer.

"As ever, mumsnet attracting the dumbest and the gormless."

Awww, and yet here you are Joss.

Aw, Dunning Kruger syndrome is so adorable sometimes.

I accidentally read that as

Mumsnet attacking the dumb and gormless

And i thought ‘gosh thats rude they dont do that!’

But ive not been up long and ive onky had one coffee so theres that

Awww, and yet here you are Joss.

Oflang still trotting along after us. It’s quite sweet really.

So - has short hair and presented as male, and had a male identity is not trans according to Joss.

Looking female in the middle of a period of identifying as male is also not trans.

But but acceptance without exception.

And declaring I’m a woman is sufficient to access all female single sex services.

I’m very confused.

Could someone please tell me how I know someone is true trans before I have concerns somewhere I’m taking off my clothes? I don’t want to get it wrong.

A list of criteria would be very helpful.

Also where do examples like Alex Drummond, Danielle Muscato and Phillip Bunce fit in here? Are they still truetrans?

What does Joss think of Freddie McConnell? Is Freddie trans enough if Freddie got pregnant and had a baby? Come on Joss, tweet a list of rules. Maybe ask your buddy McKinnon’s opinion.

Excellent, Sunset, that has clarified it for me. Biological functions have NOTHING to do with womanhood. Bikinis and presumably gold lame purses have EVERYTHING to do with it. Awesome. This ideology is ever so progressive, as we all can see.

NotBad no, that’s fine, see above. Giving birth has bugger all to do with womanhood. Freddie has short hair and wears lumberjack shirts so what more proof do you want of real manhood. Also, being called a mother is something that is for women, whereas giving birth isn’t.

God, this stuff is so mind-boggling.