Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Book icks

329 replies

butimamonstersaidthemonster · 20/07/2026 23:05

I love hearing peoples biggest book icks.

I hate when plot holes are explained by characters being so rich that they have access to technology that doesn’t exist.
I hate when a character is paralysed and then it turns out that they were faking it - you can’t fake it for months or in some books years!
I hate when books are described as ‘the next gone girl’ like it isn’t a major spoiler.

I'm sure I have loads more I can’t think of right now.

OP posts:
HelenaWilson · 30/07/2026 16:23

But as TinyToeBeans said, women don't always want to read about women. It does sometimes seem like box ticking bandwagon jumping by publishers. Some years ago it seemed like every other new book was a police procedural where the central character was a woman DI or DCI. Who of course has to contend with jealousy and sexism from her male colleagues, and probably has personal problems too.

FlorbelaEspanca · 30/07/2026 16:46

Latenightreader · 21/07/2026 11:19

Lazy research for books set in another place or time period. I have a long rant about abook set in Bethnal Green in 1942-4 where a character sees that a shop has bananas, comments that theyhaven't seen them for a while, and casually pops in to buy a few. So many things wrong, but they had also paused a conversation because church bells were ringing loudly, so I shouldn't have been surprised.

Then there was the book where someone sheltered from an air raid in a Jubilee line station...

Talking of Bethnal Green, Hester Burton's In spite of all terror has London schoolchildren setting off for evacuation from a tube station which is not named, but is clearly on the Central Line east of Liverpool Street, but the Central Line didn't run east of Liverpool Street until after the war.

FlorbelaEspanca · 30/07/2026 17:03

CreativeGreen · 21/07/2026 11:27

Different fonts for different narrators - how dumb do you think we are that we won't be able to remember it's Lizzie now not Paul unless Lizzie writes in Arial?

And teenage slang - read an appalling one by Adelle Parks whose 20 year old narrator kept saying things like 'literally all the fam were in the pub, no cap' and described her mother's response to a younger sister being in a coma as 'having a full-on menty b'. Yuck - and dates so quickly!

I will allow one exception: Susan Gates's Criss-cross, where the story is told entirely through notes passed in class by schoolchildren. Then the different fonts make sense as surrogates for different handwritings.

AFigureWalks · 30/07/2026 20:43

pollyhemlock · 24/07/2026 19:43

I don’t think this is what happens? Spoilers ahead. The Count befriends Nina as a child . When she returns aged about 18/20 she has become very political and goes off with like- minded friends to help peasant farmers. However she falls foul of the authorities and entrusts her daughter Sofia to the Count as she has no one else. Nina dies in Siberia. The only person the Count has a relationship with
is Anna, who is an actress, about the same age as him. It is a while since I read it but I think his relationship with Nina is perfectly innocent.

I have rather embarrassed myself! I will get a new copy and reread; paying proper attention this time! Oh dear. The shame.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page