wrong :-
petunia didn't reveal that she knew what 'dementoids' were. I do feel this is important for the book, although obviously not for the films
no brains! no bell jar!
didn't like that snape got occumalted/leglimensed and harry saw the memory. part of snape is that he is wary of potter so pops the memory in the pensieve. memory not long enough ( you see james and a glimpse of pettigrew behind him, but i couldn't focus on a sirius and i assume Lupin would have been disapproving from the sidelines. also no lily!
could have made more of the fact that Luna is bullied and James was a bully. a bit too subtle - also (hemhem!) does hogwarts have an anti bullying policy? Luna just accepts it ( this would be a criticism of the books as well i guess)
no firenze!
Right:-
casting of Luna. adorable. love how she skips
Umbridge. fabulous. love the little insane giggle ta the end of a sentence. costuming amazing ( anyone see that on ITV last night btw?) also the inspections ( you applied for the posistion of defence of the dark arts professor?' 'yeesssssssssss')
young snape. rarrrrrgh!
Ginnys cross little face when Harry is mooning over cho ( i would like to see her a bit gingerer though - she is quite dull of hair)
Snape appearing in harrys mirror of whatever it's called. fab.
bella. just nuts enough. hope she isn't hacked out too much in the next two. wasn't too keen on her avading sirius, pretty sure he stumbled or was stupified.
I liked the tapestry, but i kept trying to get a look at narcissa. i do hope they cast her for the next one. where was mundungus btw?
the films, out of necessity leave SO much out.