Hi Jasper ..... I want to lose 45lbs in total (!!!) - just over 3 stone. I've lost 17lbs so far in 5 weeks - I am keeping everything crossed that I continue to lose at this rate but need to be realistic. However, I think it's not unreasonable to hope that I'll have done it by Xmas.
Like you, I did Points last year, starting 3 months after my daughter was born. I lost 27lbs then in 3.5 months, but I found it very very hard even with the extra points allowed for breastfeeding. I then went through an absolute load of hassle buying & selling and I'm afraid I gave up. In some respects, of course points is great in that you can "eat what you want" ..... but somehow I always felt a bit cheated by that claim, as what I wanted to eat was chocolate, cheese, creamy sauces, pizza etc., and to do this on points you have to be very disciplined with portion sizes.
I actually prefer NC, because I don't have to weigh, measure or record anything, but I do have these "extra" 21 points a week which I've found I don't need to spend, but instead use at the weekend for a decent helping of chocolate. That method works so much better for me personally than trying to meet my chocolate cravings with a "fun" size bar that's really no fun at all ! Now, I've been looking forward to a Crunchie (3.5 points) on Friday & Saturday and obviously still have 14 points left. These come in handy if you're eating out (though found it easy to stick to NC entirely in the Chinese) or, for some extra chocolate, like some good quality Lindt or Green & Blacks !
Somehow, this time round, I feel so much more inspired and far less resentful at watching what I eat. Stupid I know - 'cos I think suceeding in any diet is all in the mind, but fingers crossed, this time I will do it. I do not want to be fat and 40 !