re low carb being a fad diet (brace yourselves for self-indulgence of the worst kind)
i had seriously disordered eating for about ten years, and it is only since i starting low carbing that i have actually managed to change my eating behaviour properly. i am still working on the psychological side, but on a behavioural basis i have been 'normal' for nearly 8 months
i haven't admitted this on here before, but actually started 'low-carbing' (with a bmi of over 40, up from a bmi of about 15 nearly 8 years ago) in early 2011, and within a year had almost got myself to an 'overweight' bmi. but i had been doing my own sort of plan which involved low fat and low cal, as well as low carb (and included things like milk, oat bran, carrots, occasional sweet treats, A LOT of coffee etc), so i was pretty miserable and i did still relapse into bingeing and/or starving and i could see myself at risk of undoing my good work.
it was only when i discovered and lurked on the pre-bootcamp low carbing threads on here in early 2012 that i realised what i had been doing wrong with respect to fats and low carb foods. since 16th feb 2012 i haven't looked back and it has literally changed my life.
anyway, all that blethering on was to make the point that, while i am aware that some might argue that i have transferred from one disordered eating regime to another (i.e. 'demonising' carbs), i don't know how anyone could suggest that my diet now could possibly be considered 'faddy' when it contains such a wide variety of fresh foods, eaten regularly and in normal quantities, and makes me feel so bloody good and positive about life. i have managed to, for the most part, separate emotions from food which is nothing short of miraculous
and anyone who says 'just eat less and do more' when you're dealing with that level of disordered eating is an idiot. we are talking about something that would have killed me, either through overeating or starvation.
i'm not saying that low-carbing is the one and only cure (I definitely still need help with the mental health side, and that is ongoing), nor is it the best thing for everyone, i'm sure, but it really is one of the best things that has happened to me and i have all you chaps and the low carbers on previous threads (especially biwi) to thank for the support and advice (even when you didn't know you were giving it... i lurked for AGES on those threads). it has given me the hope that i can have a normal relationship with food in the future, and i honestly never thought i would