Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

The tack room

Discuss horse riding and ownership on our Horse forum.

Has anyone ever made a mistake buying a horse?

55 replies

Greyhorses · 17/04/2015 21:18

Hi everyone. Sorry this will be long.

Some years ago I bought an absoloutley gorgeous talented show cob. He knows his job inside and out and has won more ribbons than I can count. He had many many homes on his passport but I assumed that this was because he had been unlucky- now I know why! Nobody has kept him for more than 6 months since he was 4. he is now 9.

His behaviour is horrendous and I am starting to feel like I am not enjoying him any more but I feel too sad for him to pass him on again.

Basically he has a very strong panic button which means he can not be stabled,tied anywhere except one place or put in a horsebox without almost being flattened with sedation. This means I have stopped doing much competing, stopped taking him anywhere and don't want to compete him anymore. A behaviouralist said he was the worst she had seen, he has smashed stable doors clean off, put a hole in the side of a trailer and been stuck over the breast bars. He box walks, kicks, rears and eventually will climb out of a stable. When at events he is very difficult to handle and needs a team of people to help me as he is so hyped up. He flips if another horse comes near him while he is confined (either by a tie, stable or held) however is fine in the field. He is a nightmare in the lorry as he rocks it when rearing and stamping, he can not be travelled alone and needs a companion at all times (which I don't have any more hence the issues becoming worse!)

At home he is more relaxed, however he stomps/rears/kicks walls/spooks/snaps headcollars and is generally a thug. He has a number of issues I am too exhausted to fix! He has seen a number of professionals over the years and can only be handled by me or the most experienced groom at the yard. I have had lots of trouble on yards and he has even been thrown off one for persistent damage to property.

Riding at home he is sometimes very good and sometimes very horrible depending on his mood. He can sometimes buck which does not bother me but he has an annoying habit of spinning and pretending to gallop in the wrong direction of spooked, he is not scared he has just learnt this trick as it scares me and gets him out of working. He is strong and he knows it but I can generally cope. He is happiest in the field and would be over the moon if he was never ridden again, however I can't afford an expensive field ornament. He lives out at present with a few friends.

From some digging in his past I found he was kept confined while still entire in a stable until he was 4 and was used as a stallion hence where I think the provlems started. Various owners I have traced admitted they couldn't cope and sold him. One said he was very dangerous. He is definatley not a rig and was gelded after producing 7 foals at 4.

I am seriously debating selling him, I love the bones of him but realistically he is sucking all enjoyment out of it for me. I don't really want to ride as there's no point as I have nothing to aim for, I can't go anywhere and he is unpredictable in most respects. In the wrong hands I think he could be dangerous. I used to love to compete and happy hacking does not do it for me!

He has some good points. When he works well he tries his heart out, he loves attention and is very quiet and easy to do in the field plus he is a great show horse (if you can get him to the ring!) he would suit someone looking for a happy hacker to live on a very quiet yard with no other people he can hurt and a few small companions, it's not going to be that easy to find though!

Has anyone else ever bought the wrong horse? I wanted an all rounder to compete and have fun with and have ended up being stuck with him. Problem is I do love him and do not want to see him fall into the wrong hands- plus who would seriously take on a happy hacker who can't be stabled or boxed and who does not enjoy fuss or being ridden and who is only 9?

Not expecting a resoloution to this and I proberbly will end up keeping him and resenting him regardless but it's made me feel better to admit how I feel to someone!

OP posts:
ChlorinePerfume · 02/05/2015 17:03

I feel so sorry for you and I think it is clear that this horse is not for you sadly. I used to have a horse which most people felt was dangerous. I could not ask anyone to ride him. I tried it once or twice but people just thanked me after just one session and said they would not ride him again. He could not go in the field as he was likely to attack other horses and do serious damage. His stable door was double locked and tried with a rope so he would definitely not get out... Thing is that he was a good show jumper and had it not been for his faults I would probably never have been able to afford a horse who could jump at that level. I bought him as a neglected 5 year old and enjoyed/ loved him for what he was. Perhaps you could find someone who wants to take him on warts and all. May give him out on loan with view of selling him so people know what they are in for? If he is good in the field with other horses I think that is a big plus. Not everyone wants to load a horse in a trailer or stable a horse... Some people would be happy with a horse in a field and do some local hacking. When I was younger used to train young horses and have to say that I have seen a lot of "bad behaviour" in horses that were gelded late. Personally I think that is were your problem lies.

Let us know how you are getting on. Good luck...

splitheart · 02/05/2015 20:32

Can you start from scratch with him? Leave him out and then gradually do little bits with him so that he trusts you. e.g. approach him in the field and just give him a pat and a carrot every day for a week. The second week, whilst he's having a pat have the headcollar on, 3rd week walk back to the gate but then let him 'free', 4th week out of the gate and onto the yard but not into the stable etc 7th week, put in stable but stay with him brushing for half an hour then let him back out etc etc. Sounds like every time he is put in a confined space he think he'll be shut away for 4 years. You have to show him that is not the case. My friend has a difficult horse and does the softly softly approach. When she was younger, my friend would sit for hours with her in the stable to get her used to being in. Take a book and a flask of tea! Good luck.

Greyhorses · 03/05/2015 08:19

Hi Splitheart,
I worked with a behaviouralist for 6 months using this technique and spent hours with him in the stable just grooming etc with the door open but the improvement was little to none.

Now he lives a 45 min drive away as this was the only yard I could find that meets his needs (ie living out and that can cope with the damage and are very understanding!) so it would be difficult for me to get there every day.

I am currently considering a loan or just retiring him but I'm still undecided at this point as i would struggle to afford to keep him and then ever be able to afford to ride or own another horse again (so 10 years of no riding at least!) as money is tight as it is right now. If I pay retirement livery I will pretty much have no money at all and still no hobby.

Thanks everyone I do appreciate the advice.

OP posts:
splitheart · 03/05/2015 11:51

Aw, okay. In that case it does sound like you really have tried your hardest. Like you say, retiring him but still paying is not really an option and leaves you no money to actually enjoy horses. Could you sell him as a 'companion' horse only to someone that has land where he could live out. That way the cost for the person looking after him would be minimal - he wouldn't need shoes, no need for a permanent stable. Finding someone would be difficult but maybe there is someone who also has a retired/older horse that can't be ridden but would like company and they just like having the horses as pets rather than for riding.
I found my loan on a site called preloved, might be worth advertising on there.

ExitPursuedByABear · 04/05/2015 13:03

Seriously, try Horses4Homes. You can explain his problems warts and all and there may be someone willing to give him a home.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page