I respect this pov, that was why I asked if the royal family was locked in, whether boarding school is mandatory for future royal heirs. Because with the exception of QE2 it seems to be a tradition of the RF.
But with the ongoing sagas of the last 40+ years and increasing republican sentiment, I question if boarding school is resulting in mentally well adjusted adults who are in touch with the public at large. To me it further entrenches the idea of being set apart.
And I accept that not everyone has a negative experience of boarding school. There are always deviations from the mean. Coping strategies that can result in high self-reliance and confidence or emotional and mental instability. But even if successful that doesn't mean they don't exhibit problems in other ways.
Personally, even if he 'wants' to go I am very skeptical of how much of a true 'choice' that is. I don't see boarding as a choice a child can make. How can a child possibly understand the possible complex psychological ramifications of such a choice at 11? And there are always ramifications. There may be many positives, but I don't think there's much child psychology in support of children being sent away from their parents most of a year and brought up in institutions. Certainly children can be subtly socialised from a young age into seeing boarding as a valid choice by their family and social circle. But I do not see a child under 16 being able to make a choice to be separated from their family and parents the majority of the year, anymore than they can consent to the ramifications of many other serious life choices.
We know Charles had a rotten time at boarding school, you could say that was exceptional, but Andrew (based on things I have heard others say in AL book, I could be wrong) experienced both highly detrimental egoflation with a sycophantic peer group and damaging precocious sexual encounters (Lownie says he was also abused but I don't specifically know when, either way he was shockingly vulnerable). No respectful manners for those beneath him in station appear to have been instilled in him at boarding school either.
Again, W&K both profess to understand child well being (K) and mental health (W principally, and K) this to me is totally out of synch with that.