@BaileyKat I agree that more engagement is the key here from what you’ve said. I know what you mean about letting them get away with it because they’re nice dogs that don’t bother people or other dogs and come back when asked and I’m definitely guilty of that too, but it doesn’t do them much good in the long term if you want them to do more than just run about. Just depends on what you want out of them.
There are various ways to teach the stop whistle, all of which are a bit complicated to write down but if you’re keen to try it have a look at Mordor Gundogs on YouTube. Charlie does fabulous videos and he’s done a stop whistle one recently.
I used to have the same issue where she wouldn’t work well with me while we were out and about but she would at home and the way I fixed it was to just train her consistently when we were out and about in suitable places. I made familiar woodlands places for training and now she expects to be trained there. She goes in knowing that something is coming, but she doesn’t know what it will be or when. It has helped enormously with her general engagement. You only need do five/ten minutes and then you can let him go and run about.
This morning we went to some woodland where we always do hunting together and she literally would not get out from under my feet because she was desperate for me to put some balls and dummies down for her. Now if she’s being feral I chuck a ball behind me where she can’t see it and stop her, sit her up and ask her to hunt and it chills her right out. She is a different dog after some good controlled time with her nose down. The way I think about it – and I think about it a lot – is that yes it’s their instinct, to find things, but hunting is also a muscle that needs to be worked.
We have done a lot of steadiness work and it’s so rewarding for both of us. I could jabber on about this all day and am always happy to. I’m not in any way an expert – it’s all just what I’ve done with my girl with help from my own trainer and I write partly about fieldsports for a living so see lots of dogs and am in constant contact with lots of trainers and people who work their dogs.
Don’t think of it as anything but a new exciting phase of his training. As you know, they are such rewarding dogs and working more with him will be better for both of you x