@barskitsyes I agree it would have been suspicious, but it wouldn’t have mattered at all if cat was under suspicion if she, Jonathan and Alan had got someone, anyone, else out at the round table. Because then it would be game over. I think that if Cat had waited a beat and let it play out just a bit more and made encouraging noises rather than going for it herself it wouldn’t have been a foregone conclusion that Jonathan would have gone out. I mean, David voted elsewhere, so it only needed Kate to wobble (even if she voted for Alan or cat themselves) and they’d have been home and dry!
Mathematically and tactically, I think it wouldn’t have been that hard to have a discussion engendering a David/Alan/Jonathan split between Celia, Joe, Nick and Kate.
I think that this scenario where 3 traitors get to the end would have been a slam dunk if they’d chosen to murder Nick over Lucy and a piece of me wonders whether they were prevented from doing that by the producers.