AM I THE ONLY ONE WATCHING AMERICAN IDOL THIS YEAR?

[ItsPotatoesForYouMyLad]

Come ladies, there was a gang of us last season!!

I can not believe Michael has gone out this week -am so and

I'm also enjoying Jason and Brooke. How about anyone else???

This is true... and so IN THAT CASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

After the results show we can talk freely. I'm all caught up now you see!

In fact.... I'll start it... but first....

SPOILER ALERT SPOILER ALERT SPOILER ALERT

i've always really liked jason and brooke, but tonight i realised that tho they are likeable, they are not the singing talent of david c or a.
i liked sayesha tonight for probably the first time.

What I don't want is someone to come on and announce the winner before we've gotten there! So won't be able to turn on MN until I've seen the finale as someone is bound to start a thread saying "&(*(&(&)_" has won American Idol. What do you think?

Now that would pee me off!

anyhoo.........back to tonight....

I think it was only a matter of time before Carly was voted off. I agree that Michael went because he's not "Proud to be an American". Oh the joy when Kristy Lee went!

I actually like Jason singing Memories. It sounded nice and angsty like all of his songs. I was amazed by the quality of David Cook's voice even though he's been my favourite since week 2. I don't remember him from the audition stage at all.

I was shocked that Sryesha was in the bottom 2 because she was absolutely fabulous. I don't think that America are voting for talent as much as personality... but then.... why am I surprised?

wasn't lord andrew hilarious tho?! omg if that's what american's in general think all brits are like

wow marslady, don't hold back there

i absolutely would not post a contestents name in the title - and i didn't do that here (not suggesting you're saying that btw)

yes jason was nice and angsty - but he's getting a bit samey don't you think?

cankles????????????

toffee ankles? can't say i thought much of her legs as a whole. and she could do with standing with them a bit closer together imo!!!

Yes but so is the loveable David A. He needs a bit of oomph don't you think?

ah....gotcha!

I think it's just the way that she stands. Why do you think they make her lie down in the videos.

Do you know when my DSis saw the Bleeding Love video she could only think of bleeding the radiator and thought it rather unfortunate!

i'm not a huge david a fan, but thought he was fab tonight. why o why did no-one tell him to keep his eyes open before?!

bleeding love annoyed me before - now it's just bleeding hilarious

lol!

So who do you want to win?

Did anyone else thinkLeona's eyes looked a bit funny tonight? Wonder if she's got an eye infection or something?

lil... she was bleeding!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

lol

am fully expecting it to be david.

what i noticed about leona's eyes was that she rarely looked in our direction - may be they're not well...

Cali.... are you about to commit a felony????????????????

david a's face when lord andrew suggested he think of a 17 year old girl was a picture!!! - what's the legal age in US?