Really though do we want to spend an hour watching lovely but slightly dull people sitting around chatting every evening. If Andre wasn't slightly dull he would have been involved in something, anything that would have given him some airtime. If you get rid of all the big characters you are left with a boring show so it's a catch 22 really.
It's like people being shocked Catherine was in the least fav 3, she seems lovely and as a fellow Irish person I wanted to rate her but other than flutter her eyelashes at Zach and then rebounding back to Andre when Zach didn't want her anymore she hasn't really brought anything.
Like I said lovely is great but sitting around watching a lot of lovely people sit around being lovely to each other isn't good tv, you need funny, exuberant people too. Look at Whitney, she hasn't done much in the love stakes but she has gotten airtime because she has some personality about her.