There is so much that's wrong with this show that it makes you realise how well-produced GBBO and Masterchef are.
(1) Odd set and weirdly filmed with some strange camera angles. Everything looks a bit cheap.
(2) Terrible mix of presenters. The two male judges are indistinguishable from each other and completely lacking in personality (whatever you think of John and Gregg/Paul and Prue etc, at least they have some sort of screen presence and a different function from each other).
(3) In fact, the 4 of them just don't gel at all well and look like they only just met each other 5 minutes before filming. I normally like Claudia but the supposed pairing of her & MB is entirely forced - she needs someone to bounce off like Mel and Sue.
(4) There is no reason whatsoever why the contestants have to share a house. It adds nothing to anything.
(5) Everything about it seems forced - when the contestants have to sit around the table with cups of tea, when they perch on stools watching the cook-off and making comments - it's meant to look all spontaneous and natural but you can practically hear the directors telling them where to sit, what to say.
(6) I do actually like the cooking challenges, though (although I wonder why in god's name you'd come on a show like this if you've never made a pie/cooked fish etc).