Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

*rollonthesummer* 's Broadchurch Series 3 thread, PART 2

981 replies

ThaliaLuxurySpa · 30/03/2017 23:15

(Hope ok with you, rollon, to continue thread on your behalf?).

part 1 Broadchurch series 3 here

Let's go onwards with our intriguing or madcap theories, people...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SpanishFly · 12/04/2017 13:16

but how were they all to know about the light during the rape?! But my point was also that Trish didnt react in any negative way to all the lights shining in her face.

throughgrittedteeth · 12/04/2017 13:34

My theory is that its taxi driver and rope boy. One doing it - and one filming it. Both not necessarily involved in the other two rapes but with Trish's...

If not rope boy then I think taxi driver definitely filmed it, its right up his street and he's gross.

TizzyDongue · 12/04/2017 13:39

I'm going to put £2 each way on TaxiMan and RopeBoy.

TaxiMan is sole rapist from historic rapes, and now RopeBoy is his apprentice.

It's either RopeBoy doesn't (or hadn't considered) it rape - some women are commodities to him (over exposure to porn causing this as an ingrained attitude) so DodgyTaxiMan made a video of RopeBoy having sex with (in fact raping) Trish.

Or he knew all along he has raped but considered it OK as he'd seem her having sex with Jim via the Spyware so felt the attitude of one man, consent with all so it wasn't really rape

Think his cocky attitude has disappeared because it's either finally dawned on RopeBoy (because he's now been interviewed, by the police, that it's actually rape he has committed) or he's now going with the poor me, I'm just a young clueless boy because he's not prepared to be responsible for his actions.

TizzyDongue · 12/04/2017 13:40

Cross posted with throughgrittedteeth!!

Want to go in with my e/w bet?

ScrambledSmegs · 12/04/2017 14:00

If we're going on the assumption that they're trying to make this realistic, it's quite unlikely that the DNA of the rapist would actually be on the sock, and even if it is then it probably won't be definitive evidence.

It's a football sock that gets thrown in a bag with the rest of the team's kit, therefore possibility of transfer. The rapist may not have worn the sock but picked it out at random from the bag. It was in Trish's mouth, then lying around in the grounds of the estate for goodness knows how long. This DNA is most likely to be that of the person who wore the sock to play football in, which doesn't necessarily make them the perpetrator.

But presumably the law of telly will prevail and miraculously the DNA evidence will be that of the rapist, hurrah, all solved Hmm

TreeTop7 · 12/04/2017 14:51

I think that the perpetrator will be taxi guy or rope guy. The series has tried to dispel rape myths, one of which is that rapists are seedy, unattractive little losers who can't get a woman to have sex any other way. Both men are young and pretty good looking - taxi guy has had several consensual affairs, and rope guy is dating the gorgeous ice-cream lady... but even so, they could still be rapists.

I don't think that the porn involving the schoolchildren is relevant to Trish's case. I reckon it's a subplot to bring the detectives' home lives into it a bit. It might also be there to preach to teen viewers about internet safety (a good thing, in my view).

APlaceOnTheCouch · 12/04/2017 15:04

I think it's the taxi guy. The DNA on the sock will link back to him (through his son) and that will be enough for his submissive wife to finally tell the police about the trophies' drawer, etc.

SirVixofVixHall · 12/04/2017 15:07

DH also thinks it will be rope man and taxi driver man together, one filming the rape. (Grim even writing that).

hollyisalovelyname · 12/04/2017 15:21

I think perhaps taxi man's wife will be killed by him.

Mimimouse4 · 12/04/2017 15:41

But isn't the younger boy the taxi mans step son? I thought in one of the earlier episodes his wife said he bought him up as his own.

Surely that would rule out that DNA link

hackmum · 12/04/2017 16:23

I don't think it can straigthforwardly be one of the suspects already in the frame. There has to be a twist, so it has to be someone they don't suspect OR it has to be something peculiar, like two different men doing the rapes, or doing it in cahoots.

ScrambledSmegs · 12/04/2017 16:29

Yes, he's the step son. Although I think we don't know who his biological father is so that's a potential plot twist. Don't know if they'll go that complicated though.

I think taxi man is a nasty little shite but hope he's not a killer. Don't think he's the rapist but not sure why - maybe because every single bloody episode they've done an 'ooh this guy looks BAD' set-up and then in the next episode it's all 'oh, well now we suspect someone else'.

ScrambledSmegs · 12/04/2017 16:30

Btw I really think Hardy made a mistake, ripping up his daughter's train ticket. There's a strong seam of misogyny running through many of the men in this town, being passed down to the next generation. My instinct would be to get my child the hell out of dodge if I were him.

throughgrittedteeth · 12/04/2017 16:57

Tizzy I will go in on that bet, though it seems others are in on it so the odds might be narrowing.
I'm currently 37 weeks pregnant and can't decide whether I'd like baby to to come before or after the finale. Very unlikely to be before but maybe if I will it enough...

IAmNotAUserNumber · 12/04/2017 18:30

Could Taxi Driver be the serial rapist; on this occasion Rope Boy saw him - thought he was just witnessing a scene of consensual sex and filmed it for his porn library.

LIZS · 12/04/2017 20:02

Jim has something on the taxi driver - could he have turned up for the breakdown but after the rape and seen something. I don't think either raped Trish though. Cath is fitting him up, as would Ian if he saw her having sex with Jim via the spyware.

Missanneshirley · 12/04/2017 20:23

Yes maybe the rapist was actually unaware of the filming?

ThaliaLuxurySpa · 12/04/2017 20:44

"I think the vicar is there to show the emotional fall-out of crimes which was always supposed to be Broadchurch's focus. How can you maintain your faith when awful things happen to good people? When church attendance is falling? When you can't give explanations for all the suffering in the local community never mind in the wider world?"

Very good point, APlaceOn...I agree.

I've come to the conclusion that LocalPaper(now EX)Editor was included for similar reasons: to remind us about dwindling readership/ online replacement of what once would have been another important hub of small community Broadchurch.
And her growing despair at public appetite for what now passes as 'journalism' i.e. salacious scandals/ celeb stuff, instead of local interest stories.
(Unless hard-hitters like Danny's murder, of course, which made her/ the book and the paper briefly important again?).

She also proved her integrity, esp. when promising Beth she'd keep Mark's suicide attempt quiet.
In contrast with the brash, younger journo, who was pretty unlikeable...kind of got the feeling she'd sell her soul for big stories, and not give a toss about how individuals would be affected.

(Especially loved Ex-Editor's barely disguised dig at The Fail Grin Sidebar of shame etc. got a sarcastic comment or two, didn't it? No sad face from her...more a frustrated and angry one). Wink

OP posts:
Missanneshirley · 12/04/2017 20:54

I don't know how to C&p from Twitter however there is a pic on there showing that beardy band man is also on the football team! I'm sure it's him

IAmNotAUserNumber · 12/04/2017 22:10

But was Beardy Band Man playing football as part of Rope Boy's team, or as part of the one-off village get together? I do remember he was happy to give a sample when asked.

Missanneshirley · 12/04/2017 22:56

I think it looks looks the team and not the get together?

*rollonthesummer* 's Broadchurch Series 3 thread, PART 2
TizzyDongue · 12/04/2017 23:06

Beardy Band Man!!?

I don't even recall him, bar him putting his kit into a bag.

thenewaveragebear1983 · 12/04/2017 23:16

Tizzy me neither! That one passed me by totally. I will be cursing if it turns out to be someone I hadn't even clocked!

PreemptiveSalvageEngineer · 13/04/2017 06:41

I still think:

  • SleazyTaxi's stepson is Ed Burnett's natural son.
  • Rapist is either SleazyTaxi or TwineGit or both, but if people want a stunning twist there'll still be one, maybe, say, how they did it.
  • I didn't used to have a strong opinion on whether it was a female hand that removed the bag back in Ep.1, but:

"That's two [three?] you owe me" (TwineGit's girlfriend)
I'm going to just leave that right there. Hmm

I think the bag was planted at the farm shop by the rapist/accomplice.

Hope it's not a spoiler, but I know from IMDB that we're not going to see Jim Howick any more, so I'm guessing it's not him.

I see what PP is saying about the phone lights possibly triggering Trish, but maybe it was offset by the sheer love and solidarity and empowerment she would have been feeling (worked for me! >blub

APlaceOnTheCouch · 13/04/2017 08:41

Oh, I forgot the taxi driver's son was a step-son . . .hmm, I'd still put a bet on it being the taxi driver.
Maybe rope boy was filming himself having sex with his gf and Trish saw the light from his phone but it wasn't filming her? The woods were definitely busy that night - Trish, rapist, Ed, Jim and the waitress.
I'm forgetting what happened in the earlier episodes. Did they find a used condom beside Trish that had her DNA on it? Or did they assume a condom had been used because they found the empty wrapper?