PLL - Who do you think A is?

[SuperBeagle]

I've been re-watching PLL, and I want to know your A theories.

Alternatively, who do you want to be A?

I know the person I suspect of being A is not the person I hope it will be.

Go, go, go!

Oh no! On the subject of Lucas...(and MK is such a turd she would actually do this) here are my predictions if NOT AD. The Five will start to suspect him, right up until the last minute...then he will end up dying trying to save Hanna, and will go to his grave thinking she hated him and thought he was A!

I've been observing Maya too. A few things I never noticed before;

She wanted Emily and her to be an open couple; suddenly, the whole.world and his dog has seen the pics.

She looked mighty pissed when Emily's dad came home and Pam (love Pam!) kicked her out so that they xould have some family time.

Toby was "competition" just before he got into trouble and did a legger from the cops. I know Jenna called the cops, but on who's orders?

And that's just SO FAR! We know a lot more (no body when she died, Mona's crypric "Maya Knew" message, and the fact that her name has been dropped into two- that I can recall- episodes in s7)

All coincidences on their own...but put together...

Any thoughts?

I would LOVE for Maya to be A. She's been my favourite A candidate from the outset, and I would love to see them bring her back.

She's suspicious as hell.

Until Emison got together I'd have been gutted for Emily. However, now Em is with her first love, I think it would be a fab twist! Especially if that Nate guy was sent by Maya to kill Paige...(that girl drives me batshit)

I thought they did find Maya's body at the end of s2? (although we didn't see it tbf... Interesting!)

I loved Maya, it would love some flashbacks with her at least! Did you know she's played by the same woman who was Kendra on Buffy?! She does not age!

We never see the body do we?

Ep1s12. Lucas has just totally lost control at Hanna's party. It makes me wonder if, if he can lose it as easily as that, could he really play such a long game?

I can't believe you guys have got me analyzing each episode.. 😂😂

We never see the body do we?

Nope! Which makes her the only "dead" person whose body we haven't seen, I believe.

Lucas has just totally lost control at Hanna's party. It makes me wonder if, if he can lose it as easily as that, could he really play such a long game?

Perhaps to throw them off? If he is truly A, possibly losing control so easily would make them assume it couldn't be him.

Bloody good points.

Just been out for my first C25K crawl run. I promised myself three back-to-back episodes while I'm working, if I completed it. Guess what I'll be doing all morning! 😂

Orange I am liking your style! 😏

And Super I like the way you make me think and analyze everything!

Great...now I sound like an asslicking wanker...😂😂

Ezra is so damn creepy. Ugh. And such an aggressive twat too.

My clues come from this: www.imdb.com/title/tt1578873/fullcredits?ref_=tt_cl_sm#cast

Maya (Bianca Lawson) is there only from 2010-2012
Whereas the others, the main crew, plus Lucas, Cece and Archer/Elliot, are all there for 2017...

I have to say I think we would have seen Lucas in at least one happy relationship by now if he wasn't still obsessed with Hanna...

I mean Emily has had like 34 different gal pals already, but for Lucas to have none at all? Suspicious...

Could they have been credited for flashbacks etc?

I really like Ezra but watching from the beginning again makes me think he is creepy. At what point I wonder did he stop using Aria and start loving her? I've just watched the storm episode in season 1 and his behaviour seems so manipulative and controlling. If Aria was on MN she would have been told to LTB

Whirlwindhugs how on earth did I not realise that the actress who played Maya also played Kendra?! she looks exactly the same!

Orange I also picked up on the Maya anger when Emily's dad came home. Surely she should have been happy for Emily

Right now Lucas and Maya are at the top of my list. Can anyone enlighten me on the VH theory? I did notice that she was hanging around the school for an awfully long time on the day of the SATs in the storm

www.wetpaint.com/pretty-little-liars-final-episodes-questions-1562973/

Yeah so CeCe is likely to be credited for flashbacks, or isn't actually dead which is you know, classic Liars.
It's why I am absolutely sure that Uber A can't be Maya, though, or she would be credited for 2017.

That makes sense travelling. Hmm, no maya tbf I think I read somewhere that after nearly 20 years of playing teenagers Bianca Lawson wasn't going to do it anymore

Orange - I think you're totally right that if it's NOT Lucas the liars will still think it's him and possibly he'll die protecting them...

Morning!

Rusty the VH theory was mine, and not a popular one .

I haven't even been down the "Is Cece Really Dead?" road yet. This may be a little far fetched even for PLL...they identified the body, etc.

I've been looking for more connections between Maya and...well...everyone! She was sort of friends with Jenna. She may have something on her, and we know Jenna can keep a "not really dead" secret. MK claims that Cece panelled Jenna because she knew that Ali was alive. I call bullshit on this one. Usually we are given answers through flashbacks/explanations (eg, Cece never said the words "I drove the car into Emily's house, but the "well, no one got hurt!" tells us she did). Jenna being clobbered has never been mentioned.

Also Noel. Maya may have witnessed something at one of the partirs she went to, and has been using this to blackmail him into keeping secret the fact that she is alive. This may also tie in to rumors that Holden is coming back. He went to the parties too! Why would he be coming back, except to fill in one more blank which gets The Five closer to the truth?

Whirlwind - so Lucas dies, like Snape did in HP? I can totally see that.

Noel is also a creep. Makes sense that the actor was the original choice for Ezra! Speaking of, did you know Emily (Shay) auditioned for Spencer's role? Weeeeird.

Hmm...Shay as Spencer? Glad she got the part of Emily.

Orange oo why do the people think Holden will come back?

Also, rememeber when Alison came back during s1-2 in Emily and Hanna's dreams (the barn, the hospital) and then it turned out those were real?

"Spencer" is with Hanna in her dream when she gets tortured in s7.
Twin? Mask?

I think the guy that plays Holden was on set. The cast snaps a lot backstage (I'm amazed they kept who A is secret!)

I'm on the Ali visiting Hanna in hospital ep now. She says that telling the wrong person the truth is what got them there. Who, and what?!

Also, Lucas sneaking in and kissing Hanna is weird but whatev. He is weird.