Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

And then there were none - BBC1

310 replies

VeraClaythorne · 26/12/2015 21:24

Anyone watching?

OP posts:
Davros · 30/12/2015 14:38

Features!

BeautyQueenFromMars · 31/12/2015 16:06

I think they did it brilliantly, apart from adding the swearing. A bit of language doesn't usually bother me, but I really don't think it belongs in anything Agatha Christie.

RustyBear · 31/12/2015 23:30

Actually, characters in Christie's books do swear, it's just that she never put the actual words, just eg 'Lombard swore'

Destinysdaughter · 01/01/2016 00:08

But how did the judge know about all these people and that they had all murdered someone...??

Dipankrispaneven · 01/01/2016 00:47

I take it that he researched it, maybe with the help of the agent who popped up at one point to deal with the employment of one of the victims, possibly Blore.

CakeNinja · 01/01/2016 04:32

The programme doesn't deal with enough of the finer details. Just aswell I've bought the book - which was sceptically the plan!

CakeNinja · 01/01/2016 04:33

I meant to type POSSIBLY sceptically the plan Xmas Grin

JasperDamerel · 01/01/2016 07:50

I just wanted to recommend the AC dramas on R4Extra at the moment. I'm in the middle of The Sittaford Mystery and it is excellent.

scarlets · 01/01/2016 17:06

Destinysdaughter - you asked how the judge knew about their wrongdoings - the book makes this clear, but for some reason the tv adaptation didn't. In the case of Vera, he got chatting to the child's uncle Hugo on a cruise liner, who told him of his suspicions surrounding his athletic fiancée's supposed inability to catch a small child. He found out about the General via two military gossips in a London gentlemen's club. His cancer nurse told him about Dr Armstrong's drunken surgical error, which she had witnessed. I think he found out about the pregnant girl's suiciide from another patient, when he was recovering from his cancer surgery in a convalescence home.

In the book, there were no outright murders in the back stories. The servant didn't smother the old lady, he withheld her medicine so that she died "naturally". The detective didn't stamp on the man in the cell, he fabricated evidence and the hapless victim died shortly afterwards in prison. The General didn't shoot his love rival in the head, but deliberately sent him on a dangerous mission into enemy fire. The point of the book is that they weren't murderers in the eyes of the law, but amoral/reprehensible people who had got away without being punished for causing these deaths.

Also, the "killers" didn't achieve their happy-ever-afters. Vera didn't marry and get rich, despite Cyril's death. The General's wife died immediately after the War so he ended up single anyway. The servant didn't inherit enough money from the old lady to leave service. Emily's moral crusade was doomed and she was a laughing stock. The detective failed to be promoted. The doctor descended into alcoholism and his reputation suffered.

Samantha28 · 01/01/2016 17:17

Thank you scarlet, I was wondering about all of that

Blondeshavemorefun · 01/01/2016 19:09

just watched one and two, have read comments up to 2nd and avoided anything past 9pm

so dont know who did it, but know who didnt as dead Grin

will watch no 3 in a tick

few thoughts, not sure if been covered

very racey cossie with bits out of it

faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar too big white towel Grin

why did the offal dissapeer

such small suitcases for all yet all have dressing gowns and several sets of clothes

there was a small boat left behind when on the beach, where did that go, or did the bloke who brought threm over in the boat take it?

where is bloke in boat, meant to come am with milk and bread, yet now in evening and not arrived ....... is he mr owne

refuse to google poem and ruin ending for myself

back in an hour :)

LassWiTheDelicateAir · 01/01/2016 19:38

such small suitcases for all yet all have dressing gowns and several sets of clothes

I noticed that. It's another example of Tardis suitcases. Very common in films and television.

The book explains the characters' actions and motivations much better.

Also the "10" don't include the judge. In the book included in the 10 is also Morris the fixer-upper who was paid to hire Vera, Lombard, Blore and procure the island. He is killed too but off the island.

The villagers are instructed to ignore any SOS signals as they are told there is an experiment going on. The villagers do actually ignore this instruction (a group of boy scouts see SOS signals being flashed) but can't get there before everyone is dead because of the weather.

LassWiTheDelicateAir · 01/01/2016 19:55

In the book, there were no outright murders in the back stories. The servant didn't smother the old lady, he withheld her medicine so that she died "naturally"

If this could have been proved this would be a crime, possibly even murder. There is intent leading directly to the death. An accused might have pled guilty to manslaughter/culpable homicide.

The detective didn't stamp on the man in the cell, he fabricated evidence and the hapless victim died shortly afterwards in prison. No intent to kill and no direct link to the death.

The General didn't shoot his love rival in the head, but deliberately sent him on a dangerous mission into enemy fire. Again no intent and no direct link.

The point of the book is that they weren't murderers in the eyes of the law, but amoral/reprehensible people who had got away without being punished for causing these deaths

Marston had no intent. His actions might have been reckless or careless driving but causing a death by driving doesn't necessarily mean the more serious crime is committed.

Armstrong might have been tried for manslaughter /culpable homicide.

Brent- no crime at all.

Claythorne- clearly intent - I wonder if that would be another manslaughter /culpable homicide.

Lombard - no crime, no duty of care owed to the natives and no intent.

Duckdeamon · 01/01/2016 19:56

That's interesting scarlet, and IMO makes the judge of the book even more of a murderous type.

Watched this over new year and found it entertaining and dark. Aiden thingamy was sexy of course, have never seen poldark as didn't like the premise that the character is a tosser to his former gf and his wife, but can see the appeal!

Didn't like the hallucinations, too simplistic.

Duckdeamon · 01/01/2016 19:59

Watched it with friends and agreed before the scene on the beach with phillip and vera that when it got down to just two, you'd either have to trust the other person (and decide that someone else must be hidden and be the killer) or try to kill them.

I said I would have shagged/shot sexy aiden. DH was appalled Blush I am more ruthless and evil and less trusting than him apparently.

Blondeshavemorefun · 01/01/2016 22:33

Watched no 3

It was the judge Shock

Didn't expect that. Never assume if dead that they aren't the murderer

So that's where the offal went Grin

So basically he reliesed he like killing and as was dying anyway thought he would gather them all together and kill them

NoahVale · 02/01/2016 18:51

gonna watch this tonight

redannie118 · 02/01/2016 21:06

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns, and so we've agreed to take this down now.

Destinysdaughter · 02/01/2016 22:40

Scarlets, thank you so much for that explanation, it all makes sense now! X

regenerationfez · 02/01/2016 23:00

Scarlets thanks for that. I watched the second and third episodes. Didn't realise I'd missed the delicious Douglas Booth in the first one so need to catch up but I might dig up the book too. It sounds really goodGrin

NoahVale · 03/01/2016 06:58

i read the spoiler before i watched sadly.
i saw the film, but couldnt remember.
Last night, watching this I was convinced they all committed suicide

Roystonv · 03/01/2016 07:36

Enjoyed it but would have liked a bit more lightheartedness at the beginning to give more of a contrast to later events.

CousinChloe · 03/01/2016 08:29

I am still a bit spooked by this (watched it all live, in MIL's pretty big and hence slightly scary house!) and even reading this thread for the first time has just got me a tiny bit anxious about going to make a cup of tea on my own...

Dipankrispaneven · 03/01/2016 09:38

You only have to worry if you've killed someone and got away with it, Chloe.

Duckdeamon · 03/01/2016 15:02

And you've accepted an unusual invitation for lots of cash! So are greedy in addition to murderous!

The agency that handled the "recruitment" would surely be under investigation!

Swipe left for the next trending thread