Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

THE CHOIR 9PM BBC2(not as naff as it sounds, think kids/xfactor)

146 replies

7swansaswimmingup · 04/12/2006 20:26

Choirmaster Gareth Malone is a man on a mission. He believes Britain's schools are bursting with untapped singing talent and he's determined to prove it by starting a competitive choir from scratch in a school that's never had one before. But there's a twist. He wants to get them good enough to compete in the World Choir Games in China by the end of the school year.

Gareth's choice of school is Northolt High an everyday comp and the auditions are an exhausting affair. From wannabe R&B divas to timid 11-year-olds singing nursery rhymes, Gareth sees 160 kids from which he needs 30. There are some real gems, including 15-year-old Chelsea Campbell. But it soon becomes apparent behind the slick voice is a dubious school record. She's being transferred to another school because of 'behaviour issues'.

For the lucky few there are ecstatic scenes when they are given the news they've made it through auditions. But then the real work begins. The group have just four weeks to produce singing good enough to qualify for the World Choir Games. Gareth battles poor attendance, lack of commitment and some terrible singing by the boys in his bid to realise his dream. Has he bitten off more then he can chew? [AD,S]

OP posts:
DumbledoresFairy · 11/12/2006 22:37

Is that because you wouldn't know whether they were faking it or not harpsi?

DumbledoresFairy · 11/12/2006 22:41

Gareth

MrsJohnCuSackFullOfPresents · 11/12/2006 22:42

oh - actually I know him after all that
he DOES look like David Tennant

have found clips on the BBC website but they won't load at the moment

DumbledoresFairy · 11/12/2006 22:43

He has dark hair and is on the skinny side. I can't see any other resemblance between him and DT.

7swansaswimmingup · 11/12/2006 22:44

he really looked like him when they filmed in looking out of the window.

dumblesdores, tell your hubby to leave MY gareth alone, he doesnt look too girly

OP posts:
MariNativityPlay · 11/12/2006 22:46

Thought it was wonderful - apart from that shocker of a Head of Music. I found her demeanour really depressing.
Choral music is full of Gareths - and some of us can confirm that they are hot stuff can't we MrsJC
Am really rooting for Enock to sing with his sister in China Was snuffling away when their dad finally got his visa

MrsJohnCuSackFullOfPresents · 11/12/2006 22:49

hot stuff most definitely
however now I have realised I know him I can't possibly think in those terms any more!

def look of Tennant around the eyes and nose and a general perky geeky demeanour

maryhadaharpsichordyeahlord · 11/12/2006 22:51

god yes Marina, I know lots of lovely men like Gareth. I cannot recommend them highly enough

7swansaswimmingup · 11/12/2006 22:51

where do you know him from mrscusack, you must tell me so i can camp outside his house

OP posts:
maryhadaharpsichordyeahlord · 11/12/2006 22:53

"a general perky geeky demeanour"
ah yes, that would be my particular area of interest
MrsJC and Marina I must introduce you to our musical director... very easy on the eye.

MariNativityPlay · 11/12/2006 22:53

I am singing on home ground in Jan MrsJC - another choir baby, I am godmother, and her uncle is conducting for the day as BS is taking the Juniors off to Southwark (where hopefully the Bishop will not be throwing toys at them).
Can't wait
Definitely a Tennantish look around the eyes but better looking and basically more talented IMO.

MariNativityPlay · 11/12/2006 22:55

Where is a drooling festive emoticon when you need it harpsi.
Gareth reminds me of a delightful colleague who, unfortunately for his many lady admirers, bats for the other side. But he is just a gorgeous personality. Everyone loves him.

maryhadaharpsichordyeahlord · 11/12/2006 23:02

our musical director (a very dear although slightly shall we say high maintenance friend ) has a very wide ranging appeal across the ages and sexes. As a safely married friend of his, I must say I have considered producing a printed leaflet:

"No he isn't gay. I don't know if he has a girlfriend. No you haven't got a chance love. But thanks for your interest."

MissMistletoe · 11/12/2006 23:27

I didn't watch this last week, but did tonight. My DD (aged 10) has been involved in choirs, and recently performed at the Pavilion Theatre. I thought it would be interesting, and it was. I think maybe some of you have been a bit hard on the music teacher. I admit she wasn't inspiring, but perhaps some of those kids just aren't interested in learning instruments. They don't seem the type, tbh. My DD and DS (8) both play piano and dd plays violin and they both play recorder, and I know how committed kids have to be to practicing etc. It made me wonder what does the music teacher actually do if none of the kids are learning music. It was surprising, and a shame, that in a school of that many pupils that none of them have taken up instruments. There could be so much hidden talent.

MissMistletoe · 11/12/2006 23:29

DD noticed Gareth's resemblance to David Tennant too. I was surprised at how young he is to be so experienced in choral music etc.

julienetmum · 11/12/2006 23:39

The schools that dh work in are very similar to this one. Deprived inner city area, low self esteem and low expectations.

But when children are given the opportunity they can and do shine. Yes there is a huge amount of apathy but for the head of music to say there was no raw talent in broken male voices. Give a decent motivated singing teacher some time in schools like that and they will find some, I guarantee it.

RTKangaSANTAMummy · 12/12/2006 00:38

Gareth's musical mission
By Benedict Moore Bridger
Comment | Read Comments (1)

Gareth Malone with some of the pupils of Northolt High School
LONDON Symphony Orchestra choirmaster Gareth Malone is a man on a mission. His aim to uncover raw singing talent in a typical comprehensive school and - in just nine months - create a school choir that is good enough to compete in The World Choir Games in China, forms part of a new BBC2 documentary called The Choir.

Step forward Northolt High School, which has no tradition of classical music and no formal choir.

The programme follows a group of 30 R&B-obsessed 15-year-olds selected to form the school's first-ever Phoenix Choir, as they struggle to achieve success under Gareth's expert direction.

"Northolt is typical of hundreds of secondary schools across the UK," said Gareth. "It's an ordinary comprehensive, with kids from all sorts of backgrounds.

"When I arrived I was shocked by the standard of singing," he continued. "This was yet another secondary school that had forgotten how to sing. When I was at school I sang every day but here there was no assembly singing, no choir, no orchestra, no folksongs and certainly no classical music."

The children, all who had never sung properly before, had just seven rehearsals before recording an entry CD for the games.

Advertisement continued...
"At first the choir were terrified to make a sound," Gareth explained. "They would happily talk, but sing? No. Not above the sound made by a small kitten."

To get the "lions' roar" needed, Gareth resorted to drastic measures. A trip to London's Barbican Centre was the first turning point: "When I put them on that vast stage to perform solos, what I'd previously seen as a bad attitude revealed itself as blind terror," he said.

"One 15-year-old, Chloe Sullivan, had been so afraid of failing that she had almost stopped trying but, gradually, she and others began to open up."

Filming started in the winter term of 2005 and maintaining the pupil's interest was a big challenge for the experimental choirmaster.

"The cold winter months of early 2006 were awful," he admitted. "It felt as though I was cruel and was torturing the kids with classical music. They were resistant to everything.

"I struggled to keep the momentum as we waited for the result of our application for China.

"I despaired of their commitment as the novelty wore off - misery infected everyone and that was pretty hard to take."

Despite the difficulties, the children involved grew with confidence, something which Gareth says was "a real highlight".

"I was nervous that I would fall flat on my face," said Gareth. "But some of them really began to love the music.

"All of them learnt a lot about singing and they learnt how to be a team - how to support each other and how to be patient when others are struggling.

"That, to me, was worth all the effort."

MrsJohnCuSackFullOfPresents · 12/12/2006 05:24

I just know him via LSO people (know quite a few of the admin staff there)

lovely about the singing on home ground Marina! (and obv keep your ear to the ground for any interesting gossip for me! Still freaked out that BS conducts my niece now...)

harpsi yes, I am forever harbouring pathetic crushes on the consumptive and the geeky. and there are so many of them hanging around the circles I move in.

maryhadaharpsichordyeahlord · 12/12/2006 07:50

Mrs JC I woke up thinking about the lovely Gareth and his delightful cheekbones [festivedrool]
luckily I have last night's episode recorded on sky plus
when you come back to the UK, you me and Marina should go out and was lyrical on the many delights of the fey

MrsJohnCuSackFullOfPresents · 12/12/2006 09:16

most definitely harpsi!
even developed a mini temp crush on the lovely pale youth who served me in Borders today.
preg hormones a bit out of control now I fear...

fartmeistergeneral · 12/12/2006 12:27

I am PMSL at description further down of Gareth having a hairless body!!!! And there was another funny comment re him that I cannot remember now!

I feel like I'm finding skinny guys more and more attractive??? Yes, very David Tennant, in fact DT is actually ginger by nature too. Slight tinges around beard and arms. I think I find him attractive too because, at school he must have been ginger and skinny and yet still is confident/slightly arrogant which is a very attractive quality IMO.

PMSL at 'opera friends'. Don't know why, but just looked an odd bunch of people.

fartmeistergeneral · 12/12/2006 12:30

In fact, Ewan McGregor also has hidden ginger qualities. Comes across all mousy brown at first appearance, then as soon as the beard comes in - there you go!

fartmeistergeneral · 12/12/2006 12:34

Also, I found his lifestyle quite attractive. Nice flat (not fabulous, but like the fact that musician types are never VERY rich), long black coat and scarf (like a man who isn't afraid to wear a scarf, like my dh), living in London, goes to his job teaching old folk to sing (some looked very strange - almost dosser-ish!) and hangs out with 'opera friends' who span ethnic and gender boundaries.

I am a suburban hw living in a white middle class area where all people do is watch Jeremy Kyle.

Am thinking of writing to Gareth to see if he is willing to take me away from all this.

Also, I am the only one posting on this thread and am talking to myself!!!!!

fartmeistergeneral · 12/12/2006 14:49

oh, must add...

(although I realise I am the only person on mn today who watched this and am STILL talking to myself)

the boy crying at the end, when they previewed next week's show! His Jingle Bells audition! You couldn't make it up!!!

MariNativityPlay · 12/12/2006 14:56

I was fascinated by his haircut, bless him