Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

What's the right diet for you, Horizon Special

110 replies

Italiangreyhound · 12/01/2015 22:01

What's the right diet for you, Horizon Special

I am watching this, anyone else?

What's the right diet for you, Horizon Special

www.bbc.co.uk/guides/z2csfg8

OP posts:
bunchoffives · 13/01/2015 19:34

My gran used to say cut the amount you are eating by a third to lose weight. I don't think she was far wrong. on the other hand I'm fat

lljkk · 13/01/2015 20:00

Apparently I'm 65% Constant Craver. What is that supposed to mean? I suppose I could improve quality, but not otherwise wanting change.

lljkk · 13/01/2015 20:04

This explains a bit.

I don't want to lose weight so not relevant to me.

SkyHighWhy · 13/01/2015 20:16

Didn't see the programme, but did the survey. Apparently I'm not in one of their categories, although I am overweight!! Made me think there wasn't much point in watching.

SkyHighWhy · 13/01/2015 20:20

According to the woman giving the seminar I attended, who explained the science of your metabolism, your genes do affect what you can aspire to (re body shape), but the thing I remembered most was that your body use about 75% of your calorie input just to stay alive, and that if you start to cut your calories radically, your body will adjust its metabolism very quickly (days, not weeks), because it reckons it's being starved - so it starts to store fat. So, to keep losing weight, you have to keep cutting back radically - you can see this is not going to end well! Much better to reduce a little, as it's more sustainable.

TalkinPeace · 13/01/2015 20:59

SAw the programme
done the survey
been doing 5:2 for years

was REALLY impressed by the abseilers and am delighted to hear that its been life changing in a good way.

specialsubject · 13/01/2015 21:06

ignored it as the blurb seemed to be all about 'what makes you eat too much?' Although if people can identify that, and stop doing it, good.

hopefully the messages have been put through that a) yo-yo dieting is really bad b) crash dieting is stupid for the reasons above and c) if a diet needs to be repeated (the 'it works for me every time') it didn't work.

RufusTheReindeer · 13/01/2015 21:24

65% constant craver which I could have told you any way Smile

Last year I really cut down on my calories, stopped eating bread everyday and did the 5:2. I lost 2 lbs a week for about 6 weeks and then I upped my calories and continued with the 5:2 and that meant that I lost a further stone or or so by the summer holidays with out too much effort

It all went pear shaped when I came back from holiday and then gained more weight over Christmas Blush

I agree it's important to see it as a change of lifestyle and not a "diet"

I think the programme is very interesting so far as I think that everybody is different and that not all diets work the same way on people. I always gained weight on slimming world for example

skinnyinside · 13/01/2015 21:58

I just did the test and came out 37% constant craver, 36% feaster and 27% emotional eater. Not sure which diet I should follow.

Or I could follow all 3.....at the same time.

I think I am missing the point

skinnyinside · 13/01/2015 21:58

I just did the test and came out 37% constant craver, 36% feaster and 27% emotional eater. Not sure which diet I should follow.

Or I could follow all 3.....at the same time.

I think I am missing the point

Bumbiscuits · 13/01/2015 22:04

I'm not in any category like tiger but then no questions were asked about my wine consumption Hmm

Italiangreyhound · 13/01/2015 23:36

FrankelandFilly I am a constant craver too! Wink

I loved the abseiling, very brave! Lovely.

OP posts:
Want2bSupermum · 14/01/2015 01:18

DH did the test and came out as the GI diet being best for him. The 5:2 diet came out as best for me. Going to do the GI diet on a 5:2 basis! Need something that both DH and I can work with.

LongDistanceLove · 14/01/2015 01:55

Well I got constant craver and it recommended intermittent dieting.

I will give it crack and see how I do over 2 weeks, I've lost 3lbs this week, so I will see what I weigh this time next week.

GreyjoysAnatomy · 14/01/2015 02:03

Bum and tiger I'm not in a category either, we should make our own category Wink

ToastedOrFresh · 14/01/2015 02:04

SkyHighWhy - thanks very interesting. I'm glad you went to that seminar, it sounds like some good information was presented.

All diets advocate not to eat sugar and have fatty foods in moderation. Who ever said all diets are the same, I'm coming to that conclusion. I also understand that the diet industry is worth billions of pounds every year, yet every year people get fatter.

I read a newspaper article recently about a bloke who tried 10 diets in fifty days. Cabbage soup diet, Atkins etc etc. Overall he lost 33lbs. He says the diet he lost the most weight on was the NHS website - no calorie counting just moderation in what he ate.

I feel dieters get conned, well with regard to commercial diets anyway. This is because unfortunately, some overweight people believe in magic when it comes to weight loss.

No commercial diet will tell you that dieting, exercise and weight loss is a hard slog and you need inner reserves of strength to continue for long enough to lose weight and keep it off.

Anyone else think that people who lose weight successfully i.e. get to their goal weight just get abandoned by the diet organisation ? There's just not the motivation once they get to goal. There's maintenance weight plans but the excitement is about losing weight.

Being cynical, do the diet organisations just wait for people to relapse and come back to a commercial diet plan when the weight inevitably comes off. Once you've shown yourself up for being human.

ToastedOrFresh · 14/01/2015 02:06

Last paragraph should have read when the weight inevitable goes back on.

ZingTheGreat · 14/01/2015 03:55

constant craver 46% & emotional eater 38% so very close percentages

but test doesn't consider the fact tgat I'm a bf mum, so of course I'm bloody hungry the whole time.Grin

interestingly both types are recommending low fat diets and coincidentally since my gallbladder op high fat foods tend to cause trouble so I had decided I will try a low fat diet anyway. how very interesting!

(there's no way I could do an intermittent diet while bf, but I desperately need to swap to lower fat meals which seemingly will suit me anyway.)

thanks for srarting this read OP! Thanks

rollonthesummer · 14/01/2015 09:35

I did it and came out as not fitting into any of their categories!

DH did it and came out as being a feaster and needing the High protein and low GI diet. He agrees with this-loooks like plenty of lean meat and salad/vegetables which is fine for lunch (soup) and dinner but what do you eat for breakfast!?

frumpet · 14/01/2015 09:55

67% feaster here , which I knew would be the outcome of the test . I can quite happily go until 8pm before eating and then I will eat a massive evening meal washed down with a bottle of wine .

Whoreandpeace · 14/01/2015 11:49

I knew that I was a Constant Craver as I was watching the programme. I have tried every diet under the sun but couldn't manage the "deprivation" and my head thinking of food all the time. I always admired those who could just switch on and off (ie go on diets and lose weight when they felt like it). Last year I did the 5:2 (intermittent fasting) and bingo - weight started to come off. Unfortunately it plateaued and I again lost the will. I ended 2014 7 lbs lighter than I started. But I've started again this year and last night's programme really helped. I loved the bit with the "Constant Craver" guy talking to himself when he went into the petrol station, realising that it was him against the big corporations who want you to buy buy buy their sugary, saturated fat heavy snacks. I am going to follow that tactic. It's me against Cadburys!

What I can't understand is that Michael Moseley's Horizon programme about Intermittent Fasting said that you can fast on two separate days each week. Which is much easier than the two consecutive days which this Horizon programme recommends. Not sure I could manage doing that. The 5:2 is much easier after you've been doing it for a couple of weeks as your head learns to manage that this is a day when food will not play a big part and all you have to do is wait until tomorrow. But I don't think I could do TWO consecutive days on 500-800 cals per day.

t875 · 14/01/2015 11:58

Good programme, im a constant craver but cutting out the carbs and having two days of 800 calories is not going to be an easy feet!! Hmm
Been doing my fitness pal app though which is good and lost 7ibs in two weeks!!

lemonhope · 14/01/2015 12:08

I didn't watch the programme but did the online test and I am half constant craver and half feaster. The feaster part did resonate - I don't emotionally eat at all but I will eat HUGE bowls of pasta and often have seconds. Sweet things don't bother me in the slightest.

I think a low gi diet will be great and I am happy to do 5 2 if it is 800 cals a day - tried it at 500 last year and felt very miserable although I lost weight I didn't think it was worth it.

Wadingthroughsoup · 14/01/2015 12:17

rollonthesummer What about poached/boiled egg(s) with granary toast, ham and spinach? That's one of my favourite breakfasts but admittedly it takes a bit longer to prepare and eat than cereal.

Or porridge with some dried fruit?

But I don't know very much about GI so forgive me if these are unhelpful suggestions!

lemonhope · 14/01/2015 12:23

i had sardines with scrambled eggs for lunch yesterday Grin

prorbably not for everyone but it was so so delicious and I felt full until about 8pm!