Holly looked so skinny on the voice tonight

[FayeGovan]

has she lost tons of weight or what?

I didn't say she is overweight. I said that I would describe her as fat. Not the same thing at all, not even a reasonably fine distinction.

Carabos genuinely - what is the difference between 'overweight' and 'fat' then?

What's the difference between overweight and fat?

Xposted!

For me, fat is when you lose all shape, or when there's lots of you to hold.

My Nain was fat, in the proper, grandma way - lots of boob and hip to cuddle.

My gran was skinny; all bones.

I am curvey (in the wasp-waist sense; not dating ads).

Overweight is when I can't fit into my clothes. Fat (for me) would be when I had to buy lots more clothes in a much bigger size.

I too am a bit about the difference between overweight and fat. And MadameMessy, nobody on this thread has called her skinny. She isn't fat, she isn't skinny she is just normal.

I think she looks fab. Not everybody had to agree with me on that point. But fat she certainly isn't.

this girl?

She's not fat.

Carabos - are you French?

Carabos - you are being extremely silly.

If Holly is fat I want to be fat

Eh twofalls, the clue is in the thread title, she has been called skinny

I thought she looked absolutely lovely. Just right. Not skinny. How strange this thread is.

Madness......this thread is making me so angry. The girl looks amazing, and thank god she's not some skin and bone waif, I for one am totally sick of these women being held up as some sort of role model. HW looks lovely, not fat, not skinny, but healthy and surely that counts for a lot more than what bloody size she is!!!!!!!

Holly is not skinny, she is also very definitely not fat. She looks a healthy weight to me. Carabos would undoubtedly think me fat too at 5 ft 8.5 and size 12 - however my total body fat is 20.8% (BUPA health assessment) which makes me ' slimmer' than many women in smaller clothes sizes en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_fat_percentage.

carabos you clearly have serious body issues, you've been spouting this shite all over various threads recently.

skin and bone waif hmm, nor is she a flabby fat chubster.

Not pleasant when people describe other sin such nasty tones, is it? How about we show equal respect for both fatties and skinnies? hmm?

Fat? No! I liked it that she was wearing done colour rather than her usual black celeb juice ensembles!
I was more thinking, her boobs arent actually that big!

She's curvy but gorgeous, you might be skinny, angry poster, but then you might also be really ugly. I know which id rather be!

She has a beautiful figure, awlays has done. She has lost weight though, which she didn't need to.

always, even.

I would much rather be called overweight than fat - to me overweight means over my natural bmi (could lose a few pounds) fat means obese. Yes this country does have a problem with obesity but I can bet you a tenner that HW is within an acceptable bmi range and healthy weight for her height. In addition to this not every woman of the same weight and height would have an equal distribution of fat ( different body shapes etc). How very odd!

We don't help the 'obesity' problem with horrible phrases like 'normalising fat'. What a disgusting and prejudicial thing to say.

And of course holly is neither fat or overweight, anyone with eyes can see that.