Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Teenagers

Parenting teenagers has its ups and downs. Get advice from Mumsnetters here.

Can we talk about the GIRLS ....Adolescence

124 replies

Noangelbuthavingfun · 23/03/2025 08:22

Watched the 4 part series. Gut wrenching ... I have a boy and desperately want him to value woman, their rights, respect both sexes, and turn into a well rounded human. What Jamie did it unforgivable. But I don't want to talk about that ... I've since just dipped a toe into reading this manosphere stuff and I've got to he honest if women/girls today behave like this - degrading men, bullying, branding people incels and dragging some into an anxiety ridden young adulthood that they'll never be worthy of a relationship ..... WHAT HOPE DO ANY of the sexes have . I'm appaled at hoe Girls can behave to each other (lots of friends with girls) and it opened my eyes to what they can also do to boys. Not excusing the backlash - but CAN WE TALK ABOUT THE GIRLS. They were portrayed as vile in the series too. What needs to happen here ? As I can see a world coming where boys and girls grow up with pretty screwed up views on both sides? So sad to see and I don't know what I'm looking for - just wondered if anyone else thiught about it too? As society we should be focused on both boys and girls .... I'll probably be flamed now.

OP posts:
BestZebbie · 23/03/2025 14:14

TheElginGarbles · 23/03/2025 11:52

OP, I think the tone of the response here beautifully illustrates the problem. Society is generally unwilling to consider that this is a complicated issue with responsibility in many places. People love to pile on and locate a single cause; it's all because of rape culture... but where did rape culture come from? Why do boys think hypermasculinity is attractive? Why do girls find it attractive in fantasy, but not (always) in reality? Why are there so many threads on here where people complain about normal mistakes by DH, but the response is always red flags, and divorce.

Boys and men do not know how to behave in relationships, and we don't let them try and get it wrong. We infantilise them, and complain when they try and when they give up, we claim weaponised incompetence.

The response is never rape or assault, though.

Wrt hyper masculinity being attractive in fantasy but less so in reality - hasn't this been studied and the suggestion is that it is because in a fantasy a 'dominant' man gives an 'excuse'/plausible deniability for behaving in a sexually receptive way towards them that society might otherwise condemn, but in real life nobody likes coercion and loss of autonomy (and women have other stuff to be doing sometimes).

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 23/03/2025 14:33

GlennMillersToothbrush · 23/03/2025 13:56

This is an interesting point I’ve not seen picked up on. It’s interesting he didn’t fight back and was then called by another boy as you point out.

Worryingly on X since I read a few posts about the show I have been promoted a number of videos entitled “she wanted equality and found out” these showing women and girls hitting men and boys and then getting knocked out by the man/boy.

I am male and do not follow any manosphere creators. This must also be going to teen boys phones. Very concerning.

Edited

The fact that vids like that exist , especially on mainstream platforms is part of the problem. Nevermind the fucked up algorithms that suggest it. Then you only have to watch one .. curiosity, impulse, mindless scrolling etc and then you get inundated with more videos and more extreme content.

SleeplessInWherever · 23/03/2025 14:39

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 23/03/2025 14:33

The fact that vids like that exist , especially on mainstream platforms is part of the problem. Nevermind the fucked up algorithms that suggest it. Then you only have to watch one .. curiosity, impulse, mindless scrolling etc and then you get inundated with more videos and more extreme content.

There are women, a minority maybe but they exist, who hit their male partners in the absolute belief they won’t hit them back, because they’re male.

That is still calculated violence.

The extreme behaviour there is instigated by the females.

Women often are the victims, and are the more suppressed sex, but that doesn’t give us the right to behave however we like.

GlennMillersToothbrush · 23/03/2025 14:49

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 23/03/2025 14:33

The fact that vids like that exist , especially on mainstream platforms is part of the problem. Nevermind the fucked up algorithms that suggest it. Then you only have to watch one .. curiosity, impulse, mindless scrolling etc and then you get inundated with more videos and more extreme content.

I couldn’t agree more. The algorithms are evil. I work in a highly educated environment that isn’t IT and it is astonishing how people at work and more importantly parents can’t get their heads around it.

The happy,happy,sad and then happy algorithms . Giving the dopamine hit and creating the addiction and then drawing you in. Teens and boomers and everyone else in between.

I remember when lads mags we a worry never saw a 9 yrs old with loaded but primarily school boys with unrestricted IPhones bonkers.

booksunderthebed · 23/03/2025 14:50

It certainly seemed to me Katie was being very nasty to Jamie.

Of course, that didn't mean she should be killed.

But that sort of behaviour has resulted in suicide.

Even if it just results in very unhappy people.

Travelban · 23/03/2025 14:58

It's so mindblowingly depressing, even on a largely female forum, to read "it's not all men, it's women too'. Come on. In which parallel universe have people existed? How many boys do you know who have been sexually assaulted and/or raped? Because it's rife in under 18s. Misogyny is rising like a madsive disease and we need to wake up.

The solution isn't clear but it isn't good enough to bury your head in the sand. I have 2 teenage boys and 2 teenage girls too. And no I don't think that having good role models at home is enough. Boys can get radicalized and influenced and frankly I keep an eye on mine like a hawk. But something needs to be done.

SleeplessInWherever · 23/03/2025 15:15

booksunderthebed · 23/03/2025 14:50

It certainly seemed to me Katie was being very nasty to Jamie.

Of course, that didn't mean she should be killed.

But that sort of behaviour has resulted in suicide.

Even if it just results in very unhappy people.

Totally agree.

Nobody deserves to die for bullying someone, but she was bullying him.

The girl who attacked the lad in the playground saying “you killed my friend” - he didn’t. I know we found later it was his knife, but he didn’t kill her.

The overall point is obviously that men/boys shouldn’t be violently murdering women for doing/saying things they don’t like, but I don’t think we can ignore that women and girls don’t always behave impeccably - we’re not saints.

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 23/03/2025 15:26

SleeplessInWherever · 23/03/2025 15:15

Totally agree.

Nobody deserves to die for bullying someone, but she was bullying him.

The girl who attacked the lad in the playground saying “you killed my friend” - he didn’t. I know we found later it was his knife, but he didn’t kill her.

The overall point is obviously that men/boys shouldn’t be violently murdering women for doing/saying things they don’t like, but I don’t think we can ignore that women and girls don’t always behave impeccably - we’re not saints.

No they don’t always behave impeccably, but they are also held to higher standards.

So even when they’re victims of male violence people like you come up with “well yeah, but…”.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 23/03/2025 15:28

Why are there so many threads on here where people complain about normal mistakes by DH, but the response is always red flags, and divorce.

There aren't. The things people say LTB over are not 'normal mistakes'. In fact usually they are not mistakes at all. They are almost persistent abuse, nastiness, lack of respect and/or just being a shit partner who expects the woman to be default parent and skivvy. When they are one-off 'mistakes', they tend to be very big ones. Like 'accidentally' shagging another woman, being abusive towards a child, or threatening or physically assaulting their wife/partner.

SleeplessInWherever · 23/03/2025 15:28

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 23/03/2025 15:26

No they don’t always behave impeccably, but they are also held to higher standards.

So even when they’re victims of male violence people like you come up with “well yeah, but…”.

I actually hold them to the same standards.

Nobody should be manipulating, abusing, hurting or murdering anyone else.

They’re fairly basic standards, and they apply to both sexes.

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 23/03/2025 15:31

booksunderthebed · 23/03/2025 14:50

It certainly seemed to me Katie was being very nasty to Jamie.

Of course, that didn't mean she should be killed.

But that sort of behaviour has resulted in suicide.

Even if it just results in very unhappy people.

Coercing girls into sending nudes and then sharing them all over the place has also resulted in suicides. We don’t talk about that though do we?

No, we’re talking about a girl who had already been victim to a sexual predator because she wasn’t nice and kind to another would be predator.

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 23/03/2025 15:34

SleeplessInWherever · 23/03/2025 15:28

I actually hold them to the same standards.

Nobody should be manipulating, abusing, hurting or murdering anyone else.

They’re fairly basic standards, and they apply to both sexes.

No you don’t. Because you seem to think that the girl attacking that boy is such a big deal and an outrageous act,when fights like that happen between boys every hour. But we don’t talk about that either.

And even if you are , and your post just read wrong, society doesn’t. Boys will be boys is still a thing. Girls should be nice and kind, maybe they won’t get murdered , or raped , or sexually assaulted then. If only.

SleeplessInWherever · 23/03/2025 15:40

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 23/03/2025 15:34

No you don’t. Because you seem to think that the girl attacking that boy is such a big deal and an outrageous act,when fights like that happen between boys every hour. But we don’t talk about that either.

And even if you are , and your post just read wrong, society doesn’t. Boys will be boys is still a thing. Girls should be nice and kind, maybe they won’t get murdered , or raped , or sexually assaulted then. If only.

Don’t tell me what I think, please. I’ve explained my views, I evidently know what they are.

I mentioned those two examples from the show, because that’s what we’re talking about.

We can talk about boys attacking each other, or girls being coerced into sending nudes.

They’re not the topic at hand, but I’m happy to confirm neither of those things should be happening either.

I can also tell you that when boys/men send dick pics to girls, they get shown to friends too. Girls have school fights, and bully each other for being fat/different/whatever the offence is.

Is that okay because it’s a girl/woman doing it? Of course it isn’t.

People, shouldn’t treat each other like shit. That’s the top and bottom of it for me. Accepting that involves accepting that sometimes women do that too.

marmitetoast5 · 23/03/2025 15:42

Did you watch it properly? The main character said the victim was ‘flat’ but he thought she would give him a chance as she was ‘desperate’ after her nude photos were shared. This is extremely misogynistic, seeing girls as ‘easy’ and how dare they not give any man a chance if she’s down on her luck, as if she’s not allowed to have any standards. As if she should be flattered any man would look her way! He saw her as ‘less than’ after her photos were shared and therefore more likely to say yes to him. The blame is put on her, not the boys sharing the images in the first place.

The programme is about incel culture and male entitlement some men have unfortunately adopted due to certain online cultures.

Violetparis · 23/03/2025 15:52

Can someone please explain what the red pill/blue bill references are ? I'd rather ask here than google.

Snorlaxo · 23/03/2025 15:52

@marmitetoast5 It’s called negging. He thinks that she’s going to hear that and do stuff like start wearing push up bras/ stuff her bra/send more nudes where she looks more curvy etc in order to impress him and prove him wrong. A strategy so common that it has a name (and yes, girls do this too- dick size, number of gifts etc but I’ve not heard of influencers who make money out of “teaching” this )

SerenityNowSerenityNow · 23/03/2025 15:52

People, shouldn’t treat each other like shit. That’s the top and bottom of it for me. Accepting that involves accepting that sometimes women do that too.

I get really frustrated with comments like this. They always crop up on threads discussing male violence against women.

Yes, of course women can behave badly. I don't think anyone would disagree. However, we don't have an epidemic of female violence against men and boys.

Toxic masculinity, incel culture and male violence against women and girls is a societal issue which urgently needs addressing. Cries of ' but women are shit too!' Is an unnecessary addition to the debate.

MedicineHat · 23/03/2025 15:57

Beamur · 23/03/2025 09:14

Unfortunately I think this nails it.
Isn't it something like one woman a week is killed by her husband or partner? What are the stats the other way round? Pretty tiny in comparison.
There isn't an equivalence here.
True, girls can be mean. But I don't think this is an issue that would go away if girls were 'nicer'. Men have to find a way to accept equality and rejection without having such frail egos.
Patriarchy, ego and entitlement are trapping men in unhappiness.

More like 3 women a week.

AnnaBalfour · 23/03/2025 16:00

This post is tone deaf.

A light is finally being shone on how many women and girls are suffering violence and even death at the hands of men and the appalling, disturbing manosphere and you want to talk about how WOMEN need to change?

Screamingabdabz · 23/03/2025 16:04

It didn’t take long did it? Rules of misogyny number 1: women are responsible for what men do.

How fucking depressing this thread is. One high profile opportunity to talk about male toxicity and incel culture and people say ‘well girls are vile too…’ jeez what hope do we have? 😞

Travelban · 23/03/2025 16:06

Even in the nicest schools, the girls having a few boyfriends in a row are 'loose' and have a bad reputation, whilst the boys doing exactly the same are "studs' and all the boys want to be like them. I have challenged this so many times and the kids themselves cannot explain it to me why that is. And these are 'naice' kids.

The bottom line is that girls are held to a much higher standard of behaviour at all times. Boys aren"t. There is almost an expectation from nursery to teenage years that 'boys will be boys' and much behaviour is accepted as just 'what boys do'. And this is way before we even get to incel or toxic masculinity culture.

NoBinturongsHereMate · 23/03/2025 16:08

FeministUnderTheCatriarchy · 23/03/2025 14:12

Trigger warnings - rape, paedophilia, murder, misogyny.

I’m going to be completely blunt here, because this is too serious for polite debate: incel culture and the manosphere are not just “boys lashing out” or reacting to being hurt. They are part of a growing extremist movement that glorifies rape, murder, child abuse, and terrorism, and radicalizes young men into believing women should be punished for existing.

When you suggest that the way girls treat boys is in any way equivalent to this, or somehow justifies the “backlash,” you’re not just missing the point—you’re enabling one of the most dangerous ideologies facing young people today.

Let me break down what incel culture actually is.

At the core of incel culture is the belief that men are entitled to sex and romantic attention, and women are evil for denying them. They often claim that rejection is as traumatic as being raped, something they call “reverse rape”.

Some incels argue for “enforced monogamy”, where women are legally assigned to men. Others go further, saying women should be raped as a way to restore male dominance. This isn’t fringe—it’s mainstream in many incel communities.

Incels dehumanize women with terms like:

  • “Femoid” – a non-human female, literally a female humanoid.
  • “Roastie” – a disgusting slur used to mock women’s bodies.
  • “Stacy” – a woman who should be punished for being attractive and rejecting “losers.

They believe women should be punished for choosing who they date, and that violence is justified revenge.

This culture has already claimed lives, and its heroes are mass murderers. Let’s be specific:

  • Elliot Rodger (California, 2014): Murdered six people, injured 14. His 141-page manifesto laid out his plan to exterminate women for rejecting him. He is worshipped by incels as the “Supreme Gentleman.”
  • Rodger’s quote:
  • “I will enter the hottest sorority house and slaughter every single spoiled, stuck-up blonde slut I see inside.”
  • Alek Minassian (Toronto, 2018): Drove a van into a crowd, killing 10 people, injuring 16. He praised Rodger and called for an “Incel Rebellion.” His act was labeled terrorism—the first incel-related attack to receive that designation.
  • Scott Beierle (Florida, 2018): Shot and killed two women at a yoga studio. His YouTube rants were full of hatred for women and praise for other incel killers.
  • Jake Davison (UK, 2021): Murdered five people, including his mother. Posted incel videos calling women “vile” and blaming feminism for his failures.
And it keeps going. Dozens of planned attacks have been stopped, and many more women have been stalked, doxxed, and terrorized.

Incel forums don’t just hate women—they fetishize underage girls. Many users argue that women over 25 are worthless and men should have access to “pure” girls before they can say no.

They advocate for grooming and the abolition of age of consent laws, believing that “consent” is feminist brainwashing. This leads to open fantasies about raping underage girls and treating them as breeding stock.

The “rape pill” is a common term, meaning acceptance of rape as normal and good for society. They believe mass rape is inevitable and necessary for men to reclaim control.

Some forums openly discuss rape techniques, share child sexual abuse material, and fantasize about sex slavery camps where women are forcibly impregnated.

Incels believe in an impending “Beta Uprising”—a mass, violent revolt where incels will kill women and sexually successful men in revenge.
Forums contain bomb-making instructions, blueprints for school shootings, and “kill counts” ranking the most “successful” incel terrorists.
Many incels idolize suicide bombers and mass shooters, seeing them as martyrs for the cause. This is misogynist terrorism, and intelligence agencies are alarmed. The FBI and Canadian intelligence both classify this movement as a domestic terror threat.

This is the part you need to hear: boys are being pulled into this world easily, starting with “harmless” YouTube videos about “alpha males” and “female nature.” They’re told women are liars, manipulators, and that rejection is abuse.
They’re taught to hate women and see themselves as victims, justified in revenge.
And yes, boys are hurting. But pain does not excuse hatred. Not when the result is mass violence, abuse, and dead women. Girls being unkind, rejecting someone, or even bullying is not remotely comparable to this.

Women have been:

  • Doxxed—personal info shared for harassment.
  • Stalked by incels who feel “owed” a relationship.
  • Threatened with rape and murder.
  • Murdered—by men radicalized online.
This isn’t “boys being boys” or “mean girls causing backlash.” This is organized, escalating, gender-based terrorism.

Let me be clear: suggesting girls are just as bad is not only false, it is catastrophically dangerous. It lets young men avoid accountability and gives them permission to dive deeper into hate.

We must:

  • Educate boys early about misogyny.
  • Monitor online spaces where this ideology spreads.
  • Refuse to minimize the threat.
This is a hate movement, no different from white supremacy or religious extremism. It is killing people. And we cannot fight it if we’re still asking “but what about the girls?”

The answer is protect both sexes by stopping the radicalization of boys—before it’s too late.

Quoting the whole thing because it needs repeating.

Look at the position of women in Iran and Afghanistan now. Look at photos from both countries in the 1970s.

Look at the men celebrating Trump's re-election with the 'Your Body, My Choice' slogan.

Look at Trump's anti-DEI direcrive removing photos of and references to women's participation in WWII and other historical events.

We cannot afford to be complacent.

And on the compulsory monogamy point, you may think that's only only a few extremists. But even people like Jordan Peterson at the most 'respectable' end of the manosphere have spoken in favour of this.

NoBinturongsHereMate · 23/03/2025 16:13

Violetparis · 23/03/2025 15:52

Can someone please explain what the red pill/blue bill references are ? I'd rather ask here than google.

Originally The Matrix - Neo is offered the choice of 2 pills. One will let him go back to his ordanry life and forget all about the matrix and aliens controlling the world; the other unplugged him from the matrix so he can see the world as it really is and fight it.

The idea was adopted by the incel/manosphere movement as a metaphor for 'waking up' to the horrible oppression they say men face and how they need to take back control.

MissDoubleU · 23/03/2025 16:17

Men: create the word incel, themselves, as a badge of honour to their shitty world views and justify their hatred for and belief they are in all ways above women
OP: Can’t believe these women who are calling men Incels. It’s bullying. You can see why these men hate them so much, can’t you?

Mindblowing.

WhenYouSayNothingAtAll · 23/03/2025 16:22

SleeplessInWherever · 23/03/2025 15:40

Don’t tell me what I think, please. I’ve explained my views, I evidently know what they are.

I mentioned those two examples from the show, because that’s what we’re talking about.

We can talk about boys attacking each other, or girls being coerced into sending nudes.

They’re not the topic at hand, but I’m happy to confirm neither of those things should be happening either.

I can also tell you that when boys/men send dick pics to girls, they get shown to friends too. Girls have school fights, and bully each other for being fat/different/whatever the offence is.

Is that okay because it’s a girl/woman doing it? Of course it isn’t.

People, shouldn’t treat each other like shit. That’s the top and bottom of it for me. Accepting that involves accepting that sometimes women do that too.

Yes sometimes people are shit. Men and women. Girls and boys.

But there’s a massive discrepancy in numbers , actual behaviour and reasoning.

You mentioned dick pics for example. Were those solicited?

Have you seen the everyonesinvited website? The horror of them having testimonials from hundreds of PRIMARY schools?

Have you seen the wecantconsenttothis website?

Have you done any actual reading and research, talked to any women that have been victims of male violence (many of them since childhood)? Have you listened to them? Have you actually bothered?

Have you “dipped your toe” into the manosphere to see exactly how much hate and anger and contempt those men have towards women?

Or did you just stop at people are shit and women do it too?