Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Beauty Advent Calendars Thread 13 - lucky for us, unlucky for Ryan the Bot

969 replies

SheilaFentiman · 16/10/2026 11:18

Welcome to Thread 13 and happy unboxing to all who sail (sale??) in her as we swap tips, tricks, frustrations and joys of the BAC/FAC journey.

Not too long until Black Friday discounts so keep your fingers crossed and some room on your credit card Xmas Grin

Key link for all the calendars via the very lovely MaryBD of the calendars https://beauty-detective.com/category/beauty-advent-calendars/

Though lots of ACs are out of stock already, so beware (and extra double beware of anything Selfridges Fragrance related!!)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
52
Advententhusiast · 20/10/2026 15:14

IlovePond · 20/10/2026 15:04

@Advententhusiast - I am sorry to hear about your Harrods issue.

Do they expect you to hop on a plane?

I hope you can get it sorted.

Thanks. They werent that informative. Just that the store needs to sort it out so we will see. If nothing comes of it I will email Valmont. Its their product after all.

To those who have received new advents, have fun with it.

BeanNaGealai · 20/10/2026 15:23

Benny12 · 20/10/2026 13:33

yes she did that with me too …a blatant tactic

First chapter in CS 101.

MidnightMeltdown · 20/10/2026 15:44

Advententhusiast · 20/10/2026 14:02

Well Harrods customer service is absolute dogshit.

I have a problem with the Valmont. The lid was crooked and when I opened it up the seal was loose. It was clearly misprinted/misplaced on the jar. Some of the product was on the side.

So I email, within 72 hours blahblah blah. Nothing after 5 days. So I WhatsApp them. You need to return the product in the actual store. Yeah, about that I am an international customer so send me a shipping label and Ill happily oblige. Harrods: no it needs to be returned instore. Again, International customer. Do better. So they tell me to contact the H beauty store. They dont have an email. I need to call them. Sigh

Its not a super big deal I guess but the cream only lasts 6 months after opening and it wasnt properly sealed. Its one of the expensive items as well.

Ive read others that didnt have to return the peoducts or instore. Seems so random.

Harrods can be awkward with their customer service regulations.

One year, I had a conditioner missing from my calendar. Instead of just sending me the conditioner, I had to return the whole calendar, by post, at my own expense, and then upload receipts to claim the postage money back from Harrods, before reordering the calendar! What a faff!

Customer service departments really lack common sense at times.

DidILeaveTheGasOn · 20/10/2026 15:52

I should be receiving my Shiseido order tomorrow, I'm interested/a little perturbed to discover what has and has not been included from the original order.
The cavalier attitude to the GWP inclusion is so odd to me. The GWP is the sweetener that got me through the door. And the three free samples.

Cadeaukatze · 20/10/2026 15:52

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

I had a look and I also noticed that the gift disappeared when I went to the basket to pay, so I left it.

Clearly I made the right decision.

I was having a similar issue with another (not beauty) website but eventually managed to get the right code in and get my free gift (hopefully - it was in the confirmation anyway!)

SheilaFentiman · 20/10/2026 15:54

YY @DidILeaveTheGasOn - I added it to my basket but decided against in the end. If the code didn't stack with GWP, that's not uncommon, but there should be a message before checkout saying 'sorry, these offers cannot be combined'

OP posts:
XEmeraldx · 20/10/2026 16:12

Am I insane for being about to cave on the Selfridges fragrance advent calendar on eBay and using parcelflow to get it to me? 😬

Peridot1 · 20/10/2026 16:50

To be honest @XEmeraldx I would hold off. There are so many of them on there not selling. I’d wait till the prices come down.

Benny12 · 20/10/2026 16:50

IlovePond · 20/10/2026 15:02

@Benny12 - my hesitation stems from TP reviews where customers have returned things to Shiseido and have - allegedly - not been refunded, regardless of their rights.

My very limited dealings with them this week would suggest that they don’t give a monkey’s about CS.

I just feel sick about the whole thing, (which is obviously an over reaction, but the tone of the last email was appalling and has really upset me).

Completely Understandably .... makes my blood boil that they treat people like that and Im sensing you aren't up for a tooth and nail fight with either .. ?

XEmeraldx · 20/10/2026 16:51

Peridot1 · 20/10/2026 16:50

To be honest @XEmeraldx I would hold off. There are so many of them on there not selling. I’d wait till the prices come down.

That’s solid advice, thank you. My calendar impatience is making me weak

ClutteredPalace · 20/10/2026 17:14

XEmeraldx · 20/10/2026 16:12

Am I insane for being about to cave on the Selfridges fragrance advent calendar on eBay and using parcelflow to get it to me? 😬

Edited

Im tempted to get one, despite my anti reseller rants, but I'm going to wait till the prices come down. Hopefully if they're stuck with them for a while and dont make much profit, it might help deter them.

Botanique · 20/10/2026 17:38

IlovePond · 20/10/2026 14:56

Guys, I’m sorry to keep going on about this, but I have just had another response from Shiseido.

This reply stated that the GWP was deliberately removed from my order because I used a promotional code.

The previous two emails basically said it was my mistake for not checking the GWP was still added.

I don’t have any words - at least not any I can post on an open forum.

Oh, I'm so cross for you. Awful CS.

I was too late to halt my order, and it looks like it's shipping tonight. The GWP is on my order, but I'm not holding my breath. I've already checked the returns info.

Did you pay directly, or through any third party thing, like Klarna or something, that might add a layer of protection?

My plan of action is to receive the order, and if all is well, cancel my account immediately and send an email citing my CS concerns after reading a MN thread, if no one here objects.

I know that I'd be feeling ruffled by it, it's so annoying for you.

IlovePond · 20/10/2026 17:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

IlovePond · 20/10/2026 17:50

@Botanique - thank you for the solidarity but I’d rather you didn’t mention the thread - I could see them coming after me for something or other🙀

However, the fact that you have the GWP proves what I said earlier - the welcome code isn’t a promotion in itself - or if it is, they are not applying its usage consistently. I would expect that you will get it as it’s on your order.

I’m sure my GWP just fell off the order in error. All they had to do was either cancel my order or send me the GWP.

Part of the problem was that the site was so glitchy that I couldn’t get PP to work so had to use a cc instead.

SunnyPinkMoose · 20/10/2026 18:00

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

Oh @IlovePond this is truly disgusting , I would be fuming . I had a similar thing with YSL I forgot to add /missed that the GWP had dropped off . I messaged them , they said they couldn’t send separately but I should re order and not take delivery of the first order . So I did that . Simple enough you say ……..noooooo it took six weeks and me threatening to go my credit card company to get the refund . They just ignored me and my emails . Honestly it’s been a bit of a disheartening set of threads with all the dissapointment , missing /broken items and delayed deliveries and just outstanding poor customer service . As I said to the Selfridges , in fact all of the people I have ever complained too know it’s not them as an individual but their companies policies fault ( I’ve done a stint in this arena in insurance so I’ve had my fair share of angry customers) but but but their is always always a way to resolve an issue if the will is their . And if you can make an upset customer happy it goes a very long way and really does make people recommend you . It’s such a shortsighted attitude they are taking . Another on my list of won’t buy online .

put it away or use it all in a flurry 🥰

but don’t let them steal anymore of your time or suck anymore joy out of your day

IlovePond · 20/10/2026 18:04

I agree @SunnyPinkMoose - I am letting it go.

It’s also very possible I am overreacting 🙀

SucksToBeYou · 20/10/2026 18:23

SunnyPinkMoose · 20/10/2026 18:00

Oh @IlovePond this is truly disgusting , I would be fuming . I had a similar thing with YSL I forgot to add /missed that the GWP had dropped off . I messaged them , they said they couldn’t send separately but I should re order and not take delivery of the first order . So I did that . Simple enough you say ……..noooooo it took six weeks and me threatening to go my credit card company to get the refund . They just ignored me and my emails . Honestly it’s been a bit of a disheartening set of threads with all the dissapointment , missing /broken items and delayed deliveries and just outstanding poor customer service . As I said to the Selfridges , in fact all of the people I have ever complained too know it’s not them as an individual but their companies policies fault ( I’ve done a stint in this arena in insurance so I’ve had my fair share of angry customers) but but but their is always always a way to resolve an issue if the will is their . And if you can make an upset customer happy it goes a very long way and really does make people recommend you . It’s such a shortsighted attitude they are taking . Another on my list of won’t buy online .

put it away or use it all in a flurry 🥰

but don’t let them steal anymore of your time or suck anymore joy out of your day

Edited

To counter this, Liberty have excelled themselves today. I ordered their bath and body kit last week, and it arrived on Saturday with the AA body oil lid loose, which had saturated through the wash bag and all over the delivery box.

I emailed them and asked them to just replace the oil stained wash bag and the half empty oil, as the rest of it was able to be cleaned. They offered me a £50 gift card in apology, as they are unable to send individual items out. I did accept and say thank you, but also said that it was disappointing as I specifically wanted the wash bag, as it was so pretty. They have now sent me both the £50 gift card AND a replacement kit! I was astonished. Excellent CS from Liberty.

Botanique · 20/10/2026 18:25

That's fine IlovePond I won't mention MN or this thread. I hope you love the calendar at least, if you do decide to keep it.

Noeggsontoast · 20/10/2026 18:54

Some pics of the HHFAC as promised for those interested , I’ve made two pics sensitive in case people don’t want to peek inside the drawers. Completely open it’s huge! Now it’s going away until December.

Sensitive content
Beauty Advent Calendars Thread 13 - lucky for us, unlucky for Ryan the Bot
Beauty Advent Calendars Thread 13 - lucky for us, unlucky for Ryan the Bot
Sensitive content
Beauty Advent Calendars Thread 13 - lucky for us, unlucky for Ryan the Bot
Beauty Advent Calendars Thread 13 - lucky for us, unlucky for Ryan the Bot
Botanique · 20/10/2026 19:09

Oh that's GORGEOUS Noeggs

I'm not bothered about missing any of the BAC this year, but this one, this one. What an absolutely gorgeous thing it is😍

SunnyPinkMoose · 20/10/2026 19:10

Noeggsontoast · 20/10/2026 18:54

Some pics of the HHFAC as promised for those interested , I’ve made two pics sensitive in case people don’t want to peek inside the drawers. Completely open it’s huge! Now it’s going away until December.

Wow 😮 that is a thing of beauty ! That’s is going to be the one that got away I think 🥴😂😂😂 not that I could justify it after everything else but I will defo look out for this next year . Do keep us updated on it all I’ll be so interested on how things smell etc 🙂

Isabelle70 · 20/10/2026 19:15

Noeggsontoast · 20/10/2026 18:54

Some pics of the HHFAC as promised for those interested , I’ve made two pics sensitive in case people don’t want to peek inside the drawers. Completely open it’s huge! Now it’s going away until December.

Wow that’s huge, you will have the whole of Harrods department store set out.
The BAC looks like a corner shop in comparison!

JoRaRaRa · 20/10/2026 19:16

@Noeggsontoast oh that is so gorgeous 😍 Enjoy!

DidILeaveTheGasOn · 20/10/2026 19:16

@SucksToBeYou I love that! Nice to see some good luck coming your way, after the SFAC shite.

omg @Noeggsontoast It looks like a stately home turned into an advent calendar, oh my word! I am in awe and not at all going to see how much it is. What? I’m not!

hattie43 · 20/10/2026 19:24

@Noeggsontoast that is beautiful, my friend is going to be thrilled when he opens that Christmas morning . I have bought 7 calendars this year and that is the stand out winner . Pleased I got one for me now aswell as it did seem extravagant.