I look at clothes on here and in real life and I do judge-in the sense of "I'd never wear that"
I think a lot of what is suggested on here, especially "occasion" wear, is hideous. I might say so on here. I'd never say so in real life. In real life most people's clothes are just a bit well, ordinary, a bit dull. but I'd never say so out loud.
Clothes for me, after they've fulfilled their primary functions of covering your nakedness and coping with the weather, should be fun.
Comparing this thread with a recent "how to look polished" thread makes me think the people in the "tacky" brands might be having more fun than the "polished" bunch. [dressing in the "polished" stuff sounded expensive and hard work to look expensively dull. And no, if I meet any "polished" posters I won't say that out loud either]
I've clocked one "tacky" brand I own. [And really Radley bags? Mid range, well made, long lasting and practical cross body bags are tacky??]
I don't own the brands deemed to be "tacky" on this thread because I simply don't like them - in the same way I don't own Sezanne, Phase Eight, Roman, Converse because I don't like them.
I don't think any brand is tacky except offensive and sexist slogan t-shirts and children's clothes with stupidly gendered slogans.