Stuck between 2 bags?

[Barrenfieldoffucks]

Any opinions welcomed!

First one:

https://www.whitestuff.com/p/3254/fern-crossbody/DK_BROWN

Second one:

https://www.allsaints.com/women/sale/luna-slouchy-leather-shoulder-bag/W190XD-104.html

I prefer the White Stuff one to be honest - plus you could buy all three colours for the price of almost the All Saints one!

I think they're both equally nice. But since the first one is a lot cheaper I'd go for that and buy something else too. It looks very well made.

I was going to say the AllSaints one hands down.., but admittedly I hadn’t looked at the price

I like the All Saints one.Didn’t check out the prices though.

I love the allsaints one, but the strap look a bit short.

I am big fan of cross body bags and I know the fashion now is to have a slightly shorter strap so the bag sits a bit higher but there is a limit to how short it should be.

The shape of the All Saints isn’t my style, however the White Stuff one is totally my style, I may need to order one

The AllSaints bag will be much much better quality leather than the white stuff one.

I have had beautiful White Stuff bags before which are gorgeous but the straps have not lasted well and I ended up taking one back to complain. The coating (bonding?) on the leather strap cracked badly. This was a few years ago so White Stuff may have addressed this issue by now, but if that is likely to bother you I’d go for the All Saints bag.

I like the White Stuff one more. The All Saints one looks like it is trying to be like multiple far more expensive bags (Polene do a style like this or example) so it seems a bit trendy, but it's not cheap. The White Stuff one is more unobtrusive (and much cheaper, but still leather).
The only thing that might change my mind is your frame size. I would feel like I was being consumed by the All Saints bag, but if you are tall and broad shoulders, it might suit your frame size well.

I have a similar WS bag, its years old and is aging beautifully so I'd go for the first one....

I feel like the crescent one potentially wastes useful space and will date much more quickly.

I like the look of the White Stuff bag but think it's far too big and it looks a strange longish shape. I'd prefer the All Saints bag. I do like unstructured bags.

For me, it would be all about colour. I’d get the one I liked best.

I have the White Stuff one. It's a nice bag but it annoys me that the strap is very long and there's no way of shortening it. The All Saints one is gorgeous but agree with others that it will date.

All Saints is much nicer. The colour is a lot more interesting and is a good neutral. The WS has one of those hideous linings in an attempt to look jolly. 180 quid is ok for a decent, high quality bag.

I’d go for the All Saints one - for the colour, finish and shape. I’d be tempted to get that one as it’s in the sale and get the White Stuff one in a month or so if you think you need it?

I love the All Saints one, it’s a great colour and a more up-to-date shape. Their bags are decent quality too. The other one is obvs cheaper, but I don’t know what the quality is like.

Love the All Saints one. Their bags are lovely.

All Saints one, it just looks much better and you can tell it's more expensive, it looks better made. The White Stuff one also has a hideous lining.

Neither 😅.
The WS one is too long for a crossbody they don't even show it worn that way.

The AS crescent-meh , feel its dated tbh

If your budget goes up to £180
I really like this

https://www.ospreylondon.com/en-gb/the-stella-leather-hobo-in-merlot

The All Saints one definitely 😍

I have the white stuff one in burgundy. The leather is very textured (not sure of the correct term) which means it’s not wearing at all well. Also strap is quite long even on shortest setting.

I love that All Saints one.

I don't like how tall/deep the WS one is and I'm not mad on the shape of the AS one.

I do however love that Osprey one linked earlier - buy that!

All Saints