Non-clumpy, non-frumpy but comfortable loafer shoes

[tattoolondon]

Hi style gurus! I've decided I need some loafers for work. I wear dresses rather than trousers (think Hobbs shift dress style) so they can't be too clunky, as that wouldn't go with the style. But I also want something with a bit of style. I don't mind spending a bit of money (say £150) for something good quality and comfortable. Thinking black or dark red. I looked online, Dune had some nice ones but no idea if they're comfortable...? Am in London so can go look in person but I don't have a huge amount of spare time for browsing between work and kids, so I'm trying to narrow down my options!

Moshulu have loafers and a reputation for comfort. I can only speak for their slippers but those are fabulous! I believe they have a wine-coloured loafer among their selection.

They also have a neat brogue which I was eyeing up earlier. And a sale!

www.moshulu.co.uk/womens-shoes-c4/loafers-c58

Chunky Leather Loafers - Dark Brown - & Other Stories GB

The ones I linked to come in black as well. They're a bit chunky bot not overly so, imho anything less chunky is frumpy.

A few of these look promising, depending on your shoe size and preference. Mine are massively chunky, these are more restrained:
www.flannels.com/women/shoes/flats/loafers#dcp=1&dppp=59&OrderBy=price_asc&Filter=APRI%5E%C2%A350%20to%20%C2%A3100%2C%C2%A3100%20to%20%C2%A3250

These are nice... out of stock online in my size in the dark brown (which I think I prefer to black)... might be able to find in store. I don't know the brand, any thoughts on quality?

They have to go with work clothes ie shift style dress / jacket, fairly formal, which is why I'm thinking too stacked up would look odd? I have little sense of what looks right, hence coming here!!

To be honest I think the size of the shoe with a shift dress is related to the legs- my legs are chunky and muscular in shape so delicate shoes look a bit odd on me. On the other hand, a broader or chunkier shoe looks good because it balances the thickness of my legs. Someone with very slender or shapely legs might find that a fine shoe works better to keep their look formal/semi-formal because visually it’s more coherent with their more delicate build.

I've just got these from M&S in black. Reasonable price and really comfy.

https://www.marksandspencer.com/suede-trim-loafers/p/clp60707925?intid=mobile_app_pdp_share

I’ve got two pairs of these and have worn them every day for work for the last few years. I have a desk job but out onsite a fair bit and they are so comfy
https://www.houseofbruar.com/suede-tassel-loafer-brown-ta05360midbrown/?locale=gpb&glCountry=UK&glCurrency=GBP&src=webshp&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=16455698786&gbraid=0AAAAAC8kpApsb4fnDF3w2nE34b31r1B0X&gclid=CjwKCAjw_-3GBhAYEiwAjh9fUPpBfDEnl44V3YcLha_2E8je1jrBazXyv3IPMMAgPkTkOOomuH5TwhoClDsQAvD_BwE

Thanks. I’m thinking to go chunkier than I’d first planned. Think I’ll head to & Other Stories and take a look at theirs. Must be comfortable though, some of the loafers I’ve seen online look like the leather is really rigid.

I like these because they aren’t too clumpy.
www.johnlewis.com/john-lewis-pennie-patent-leather-penny-loafers-bordeaux/p111855069

Have look at Duke and Dexter Penny Loafers | DUKE + DEXTER share.google/7XCmIgRVnuy8lqlEN Women's Penny Loafers | DUKE + DEXTER share.google/7XCmIgRVnuy8lqlEN
They might not be quite what you are looking for but I have two pairs, which I wear with dresses, and they are definitely not frumpy! Young people comment on them often :)

https://www.google.com/aclk?sa=L&ai=DChsSEwishuPnrIGQAxXVlVAGHTfjDzsYACICCAEQAxoCZGc&co=1&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIrIbj56yBkAMV1ZVQBh034w87EAQYASABEgI-C_D_BwE&sig=AOD64_1-eJ3joE4jxs2E4fa8kb4wMFusbw&ctype=5&q=&ved=2ahUKEwixmd7nrIGQAxW7WUEAHTFxIWMQwg8oAHoECAkQDQ&adurl=

I have these very well made soft uppers and a good comfortable sole. Comes up a bit on the narrow side.

I have these Dine ones , they are so comfortable. The leather is so soft and they have a removable padded insole as well. Am tempted to get a second pair in another colour
https://www.marksandspencer.com/leather-bar-flat-loafers/p/clp23008984?intid=mobile_app_pdp_share

I got some from Mango the other day which are very comfy because the back is very soft. They're marketed as "moccasins" rather than loafers but they are definitely loafers! I have normal to narrow sized feet, so possibly not the best for a wide foot.

shop.mango.com/gb/en/p/women/shoes/flat-shoes/suede-moccasins-with-buckle_17083317

I have ankle boots from them, happy with the quality.

Russell Bromley Brewster. My best friend and mum both bought them after they saw mine. I have them in black and brown leather, have already replaced once (with another black and brown pair) because I wear them constantly!

I've got these and I haven't loved a pair of shoes this much in ages. They are really comfortable too no need to break them in and the soles are really bouncy

https://www.timberland.com/en-gb/p/women-10086/stone-street-platform-buckle-shoe-for-women-in-dark-red-TB0A4188EIW

Ooh lots of good options coming through!

Some of these are rather lovely - liking the chestnut and cream…

House of Bruar is usually roundly dismissed on here but they have quite a few nice traditional loafers, and a few come in reds and black.

They’re not all patent, I just picked these for a link and I think they’re pretty.

Dalston Clean Loafer by Russell and Bromley should fit the bill.
You’ll need to up your budget though!

https://www.russellandbromley.co.uk/dalston-clean-loafer/243927?srsltid=AfmBOoqHy1v5eG7KwO7u4O_I3q-jOIcxt_XnrjatbOwusKv0sXmpkI5w
Sorry, here’s the link!

Following with interest, the perfect loafer is the holy grail for me. I need a 42 wide or a 43 and so many of these aren’t available for big feet.

with big feet a chunky loafer can be too huge, 45 and never found the perfect one yet but FWIW OP I’m on my second pair of these, which are incredibly comfortable

https://www.clarksoutlet.co.uk/hamble-oak/20346713-p

I love this brand very comfortable shoes.