What matters is you like it, of course. But I'm going to take it that by coming online to ask complete strangers - what you want is brutal honest truth? Because otherwise you'd ask your people in real life and get nice/watered down feedback.
So brutal honest feedback - it's not for me. That is the type of ring that is going to date.
If you have £2k to put towards an engagement ring then put it towards one single quality diamond because that will hold its value better than a lot of tiny tiny little diamonds that are probably terrible quality. Or do a trilogy ring and if you can't find a nice trilogy ring at the price point look at trilogy rings with a non-diamond centre stone - like a sapphire.
That ring will catch every item of clothing. You'll ruin jumpers and dresses galore. It will be impossible to resize if you gain or lose weight at a future date. It will get dirt all trapped round it.
Ah! I've just come to 2nd page of the tread...
The second ring - I love it!! It's not typical. Nicer than the trilogy sapphire I was describing. It's a bit more unusual, not something you see, but it's still a classic. It's really beautiful. It's the type of ring I'd notice on someone.
Definitely number 2 ring for me. I love how the round sapphires and how the tiny diamonds around them just really set it off. It's so much classier than the first ring.
But!! Ultimately which ring speaks to your heart? Because we aren't wearing it. My own engagement ring isn't everyone's cup of tea but I love it and that's the main thing.