@RampantIvy I work for an independent and we stock around 40-50 brands 😊 That’s so disappointing that you don’t have any decent shops nearby. It really makes a huge difference when you can be properly fitted as all brands fit so differently and everyone’s feet are different shapes.
Its hard for me to give proper advice without knowing your specific circumstances 😊 but in general terms - you’re looking for something with good support, a PU sole for shock absorption, ideally it would be more anatomically shaped (so nothing that tapers off too much at the toe!), has a removable insole, and preferably leather.
Do you have a specific point in your foot that is affected the most by arthritis? Eg, enlarged joints like bunions, or issues with toes? A shoe with extra depth is always beneficial with arthritis. Wearing an orthotic can take away a good bit of a shoes depth which is where it becomes important to have a shoe with a decent removable insole so that you’re not having to put your orthotic on top of a fixed insole.
A shoe with deep lacing (something that opens quite far down rather than the laces starting half way up) would also be ideal as it allows for depth to be adjusted further down the foot.
If you haven’t already then I would have a look at Ecco, Josef Seibel & Gabor (comfort fit gabor styles will give additional width and depth for orthotic). I believe John Lewis stocks JS and Gabor if you have one nearby? And Ecco have their own high street stores. I don’t have much experience in dealing with “sports” footwear but I believe podiatrists would probably recommend ASICS and some New Balance styles to you. Another brand you could look at is Mephisto - although it’s a higher price point than the rest usually.
A random piece of advice just incase it applies (I’m always surprised by how many I see) - please avoid using heel grips in shoes 😊
Happy to help with any other advice I can 😊