Are these shoes nice or naff?

[Iusedtobeapenguin]

My shoe radar is way off. Sitting there in the box I don't like them but when I try them on with jeans I look in the mirror and think they look nice. I am really out of touch shoe-wise so would appreciate any opinions! www.clarksoutlet.co.uk/griffin-milly/26120148-p

I would sell those on if you can. I don't like the sole.

Sorry I thought they were old ones you had sat in a box. Misread your OP. I would return those.

I like them - but I've no taste lol so don't take my word for it!!

I think they are totally fugly …. Sorry x

Well, I like loafers 😊

Looks like a nice comfortable shoe.

We like them. They look like shoes.

Ha almost unanimous then! I don't mind if you're brutal about it, I can return them for free 🙂. I am so bad at picking shoes - could someone point me in the direction of some nice tan leather loafers please?

I love them.

I think they're dull but not naff, but then like poster above I also have no taste and tend to like weird-looking stuff 😂

I like them, I like a loafer with a short tongue, theyre nice for summer. Not super keen on the sole, but you dont really see that anyway.

They are dull but sturdy looking. I wouldn't buy them.

I quite like some loafers but they're dull and functional. I picture them being worn with slacks.

They look fine to me. Neither Uber stylish nor Uber fugly. Just comfortable everyday type shoes to sling on to run about to shops and such.

Missing the point but just want to mention I haven't heard anyone saying 'naff' since mid 1990's!

Hoping it's making a comeback 😁

Return them

I like them.

Oh no! I'm so confused now the opinions are more even - and I'm being swayed by the 50% off.....

My problem is that shoes that I think look ok are apparently horrible, and big old chunky ones I imagine a granny would wear are apparently in (Birkenstocks come to mind - I just don't get them?)

I think they will look a better when you've worn them in a bit. There's a boring formality to them but I think over time they'll come into their own.

I can't stand them.

Tan shoes should be banned

I have the same pair, and they actually do look good with jeans.

Handy for whacking large spiders with big otherwise it's a massive NO.

They look like the shoes Barbara Woodhouse used to wear.

I think they are fine.
I look like comfortable, practical shoes.
No more no less.