I joined this summer, and Autumn 2023 was my first bottle. Hated it, so back it went! At least the returns process was painless. Rather than a refund, I opted for an archive bottle (Spring 2022) which I love. It's a very light scent, though, so probably one I'd save for springtime to wear.
I think I will see what Winter 2023 is like, and will then decide whether to stay on the ledger or not. It is a lot of money, but I do love the idea of a seasonal bottle each quarter. Something to look forward to. I'd rather go for a smaller bottle and less money, though.