I might be asking for too much, please tell me if what I want doesn't exist!
From a mascara I want volume and length, no smudging or panda eyes.
I've tried so many at various price points
Charlotte Tilbury pillow talk -look like kung fu panda within minutes of application and an odd brush that's finicky to get used to.
YSL volume effet faux cils , smudgy went claggy very quickly
Lancome Idole just not great, also smudgy
Glossier lash slick, not dramatic though, I already have quite long lashes and could barely tell any difference with this on
L'Oréal volume million lashes both smudgy and flaky
Too faced better than sex - mascara every wear, too clumpy , smudged terribly
Maybelline lash sensational too wet/smudgy