I wouldn't wear the first pair because they remind me of Chelsea boots but with buckles and I loathe Chelsea boots on most people, most times they never look quite right. Those boots look like frumpy boots with buckle straps on, however they do look comfortable if you don't care how you look.
The Shuh ones are a better shape but look just as cheap as the first ones, in a more uncomfortable way, however if I had to choose it would be those, but that's because of the style, not the perceived quality.