Help me find a mascara please!

[missyB1]

I just keep wasting money on them and cant find one I'm happy with. My requirements are:
Doesn't clump
Doesn't smudge
Easy to remove - without hot water! I use make up remover or baby wipes.
Max £20

I've tried the gold number 7 one that everyone raves abut but it's a nightmare to get off. I hate the way it flakes all over your face. I cant use lots of water on my eyes they are sensitive and the skin around them is dry.

YSL the shock is the best mascara, I wouldn’t use anything else. Might be a bit over your budget but it’s always on offer this time of year and you can sometimes find it in TK Maxx

Collection Lash Surge!!!! It is amazing!

Benefit Rollerlash is the best I've ever used. It might be a bit over £20 but I wait for when it's on offer. They often do a deal whereby you get a mini one alongside the full sized one.

I love Benefit They're Real. I use miscellar water to remove with no issues.

Benefit roller lash only one I buy again and again

Tarte Lights, Camera, Action.

I'm converted!

Another vote from me for the Benefit Roller lash.

oooh thanks for the recommendations I'm madly googling now!

Max Factor 2000 calorie mascara. I always get cheap as chips on amazon
Turns my white blonde stumps into lucious lashes and never smudges

Believe me I’ve tried them all

Lancôme Hypnose. (Sp?)
It's on offer very often and just over your budget but amazing. And a tube lasts ages.

It's on offer at Boots and JL with extras too.

I love the boots purple number 7 with the blue stripe, but I have long eyelashes, but it does not clump or smudge. I've tried others but I always come back to it. It doesn't give volume.

Avon 5 in one.

Dior Diorshow. All I've used.

Abother vote for hypnose, as as a pp says you can get it with extras around now, one big and 3 little ones usually. I find hypnose drama the best

I love clarins be long. Just a great every day mascara. No bells and whistles just makes my lashes blacker and longer!

I always go back to Volume Million Lashes, the one in the green tube with the curvy brush.

I am currently using a Aldi one, which is not clumping. I usually use no 7 gold one, but this is better.

Benefit they're real. Every time l try others l always go back to it.

Another vote for Benefit- They're Real. Best ever.

Another vote for Max Factor 2000 Calorie

Borjois volume reveal. I have it on subscribe and save from amazon. It's around £10 or so. I don't use the waterproof one and I find it easy to remove with facial wipes. Doesn't smudge. I don't find it clumps either, but I have a new mascara every six weeks, so none of mine ever get to the stage where they go clumpy.

I think it’s between Lancôme and Benefit. Eeek! Hope I get it right this time.

The Ultimate is Estée Lauder Sumptuous Extreme.

Soap and Glory are all very good budget options too.

Agree with Benefit, though my preference is Charlotte Tilbury Legendary Lashes.