Gucci belt - matte or shiny?

[SunshineOverStress]

So I know this isn’t to everyone’s taste but I have got a Gucci belt but I ordered two, one matte one shiny, and I am so stuck on which one to keep!! I have had such mixed opinions, the matte one looks more classy and would probably go with more but the shiny one definitely stands out more but I’m also worried if it would scratch more? But the shiny one was also only released last year.
I’m 29 if that makes any difference

www.gucci.com/uk/en_gb/pr/men/accessories-for-men/belts-for-men/casual-belts-for-men/gg-marmont-leather-belt-with-shiny-buckle-p-4068310YA0G1000

www.gucci.com/uk/en_gb/pr/women/accessories-for-women/belts-for-women/wide-belts-for-women/wide-leather-belt-with-double-g-buckle-p-400593AP00T1000

[Mummyofboysanddogs]

Ah nice. I really like the shiny. But have just ordered the matte for comparison! But I’ll end up sending it back I bet.
Glad you love it. Ooh yes i defo want the tan one next as well. And I think that looks better in the matte.
You’ll wear them for years in my opinion.
Thanks for replying to me x

[SunshineOverStress]

That’s what I did and it made it harder haha I’m sure you’ll love whichever one you choose! X

[Mummyofboysanddogs]

Thank you! X

[Meggymoo777]

Shiny for sure... agree with PP the matte looks more 'plasticy'