Sorry OP, I think both the watches and the earrings are just really blah. I mean, they're fine. Standard issue, generic examples of watches and stud earrings.
If you're going to spend that kind of money, I'd be so disappointed with those. I can't even see the difference between the two watches, so either / or, really.
But taste is so individual, so if you like one of them, go for it, and don't be dissuaded by naysayers on Mumsnet....