Help! Which boots? Pics

[ellsbellls]

I am feeling incapable of making a decision between these boots and I really don't need both pairs!

Roll top ones - nearly £200 (eek). Have loved them for ages - particularly the roll top - and finally succumbed. Lovely soft leather. But... do they look a bit wide around my calves and perhaps they feel a bit big, clunk a bit when I walk (could obviously try a smaller size).

Suede slouch - £75 (reduced from £155 - bargain ). Really comfortable, perfect fit. But ... are they likely to get ruined quickly? Do they look a bit, well, less stylish or something than the other pair?

Also a bit worried about spending loads on ankle boots when they've now been around for years and may soon feel dated. I'm normally good at making decisions but feel idiotically incapable on this

Please help!

Slouch boots but they both make me think of Peter Pan. The blue dress is lovely!

I think both boots are a really strong look, (in a good way not a euphemistic way) and have fallen victim to one of S&B’s periodic conservative streaks. However I personally would trash the suede ones within a week and the roll tops in a month so they’re unlike to be good PPW. I agree with PPs that brown stack heel Barbie knee-length boots would be a safe bet for this year.

These remind me of the 80s sorry. To be worn with skinny jeans, a sequinned batwing jumper and a scrunched mullet.

And your point is? 😂

No

I think they’re both awful, sorry.

These are a much nicer shape - from H and M