Are these shoes nice (they are sooo comfy)

[pippitypoppitypoo]

www.johnlewis.com/dune-galleon-ridged-loafers/grey-leather/p3999328?size=6

Thinking for work. In the grey colour (which is like a minky grey). Or are they too frumpy? They are so comfortable

Haha! Thanks all for your views! I think I'm actually going to keep them. I really like them for some reason. I work in an office but one that's very smart casual and I can definitely get away with these most of the time.

If you are 80 they look lovely.

These?
www.shoeaholics.com/nara-silver-leather-naturalizer

It's a no from me...sorry

I am old and I wouldn't wear them, but maybe they look better on a younger person.

No, not really.

I don't like the texture of the leather or the colour. But the shape is fine and if they're very comfy then I say keep them. I wouldn't see them on someone I think anything of it, I just wouldn't buy them for myself. They're not frumpy imo.

They are an affront to my eyes!

I'm going against the grain here OP, I quite like them, as with all things it depends entirely upon how you style them.

Certainly much better than the link someone else posted. They're super-wrong!

I think you've managed to link to a pair of shoes that are in danger of making crocs look stylish by comparison....

Awful

They're fine

I really like them! I also like to be comfortable but think these are stylish too, would work with shorts/casual summer dress/cut off denim Capri type pants. I’m tempted to get some myself! The two other suggestions from pp, I really don’t like and would say they are frumpy!

Erk..

I put comfort over style all the time but I wouldn't wear those shoes if you paid me.

I have some similar Dune loafers and they are brilliantly comfy. They're lovely OP.

(Im 25, not 80 for those saying they are old ladyish)

Sometimes it's good to get other people's opinions just to crystallize your own. If you're a fan of the comfy shoe I can recommend 'hotter' brand though some might think they're a little middle-aged. (I don't care cos I am!)

Actually I like them though I prefer them in the black. They are smart/casual, look really comfy and would allow me to walk at the high speed I'm usually charging around at. Yes it will depend on what you wear them with but I'm sure you've considered that. 😁

They are inoffensive and the snake effect keeps them from being too plain. Not my first choice admittedly but I'd take them over the other shoes linked (inc. Office loafers) which are hideous.

No no no no no

Dislike. They look plasticky.

I like these:

https://www.johnlewis.com/john-lewis-partners-orla-slip-on-platform-moccasins/p3909437?sku=237482396&skwcid=2dx92700044049287424&tmad=c&tmcampid=2&gclsrc=aw.ds&&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIr7SGGf2p4wIVBp3VCh2XcA2NEAQYASABEgIDTPDBwE

But honestly, wear what you want, and style them carefully, as someone else said.

Is this casual ageism a requirement in Style & Beauty? Can people not insult a shoe without insulting a generation?

Days are too long for sore feet wear them and be comfy I amseeing more and more women wearing flat comfortable shoes i think good for them

They're hideous