I can't decide if I love or hate these shoes

[Zombiefly]

I'm strangely drawn to them...

Definite no from me I'm afraid.

I like them

They make me feel weird because they look like you couldn’t wear socks or tights with them so you’d get a sweaty foot and they’d do that thing that slippers do where they walk a bit faster than your feet and trip you up.

nope!

If you wear them with a skirt they'll look all wrong. Or cropped trousers for that matter.
If you wear them with long trousers the hem will find it's way underneath your heel
Aside from that, they are fugly.

How bizarre, I had some very similar mules from the river Island sale in about 1995. Those were hideous and I hardly wore them because they didn't actually go with anything, and these are about 150% worse

They look enormous.
And I think they would look (a bit) better if they actually fitted the model instead of being two sizes too large.

They make her feet look like hooves. Really unflattering. Can't imagine what you could possibly wear them with.

Hideous!

I don't hate them but I can't picture anything in my wardrobe I would wear them with.

Also, I like the brown but not the black so much.

If you like mules maybe check out River Island, I noticed they have plenty.

Ha ha yes as a pp said they look like hooves!

I'm also intrigued by them in a so-ugly-they're-not kinda way. No idea what I'd wear them with though... Culottes?

And the brown is way better than the black for some reason as pp have said.

But I have learnt this week that my style is way off the Boden/seasalt vibe here (I also loved the French connection pink culottes in a previous thread ) And I've never thought of myself as a particularly out there dresser!

I'm a fan!

I quite like them!

I think they’re great. You’d have to wear them right though: definitely not with long trousers. Long skirt/dress, cropped trousers but not Capri, flares etc. Of course you’d have to be tall, skinny and ideally 19yo to pull them off

I think there's definitely something good about them. Buy them, try them on with half your wardrobe and see what they go with then decide if you want them. I'd not buy them because I don't do heels. But mules I love, I got an awesome pair in the sales last summer that did not get enough wear last year and I'm longing to wear again.

They look like orthopaedic shoes for a camel.

Loopy
Lady

I’d assume the person wearing them was a slighty bonkers but fabulous fashion nut. Go for it! I think they’d look alright with culottes or wide legged trousers.

GinZing - scarily these are River Island!

Get them OP if you like them.

I think an apt name for them would be the reduced boot.

They're not for me, but my fashion obsessed SIL would rock those! Frayed, ankle length flared jeans, black jumper and camel coat.