Flo, why do you hate Le Guin?? (never mind, don't tell me, leave me with my love) (I am able to be critical of her writing myself tbf)
Red - I dunno. The picture is very small so from here it just looks like a scarf. Isn't part of the point that it very obviously is supposed to be a jumper? It doesn't look bad or anything, but I'm thinking that if it at first looks like a scarf and only upon closer inspection becomes a jumper then you veer into "why jumper as scarf?" territory. Which is so arbitrary and ridiculous really haha.
This is not a look I could pull off at all by the way. I am very much in need of things to be a bit streamlined, all flappy bits get caught in door handles and so on for me. Pas très Parisienne. If I draped a scarf I'd end up like this ancient librarian in town many moons ago - let me tell you the story. She must have been a few years past retirement age already, and seemed older. Quite short, and stooped. In my mind she was 103, she felt that old. Clothing style was what we in Sweden call "kulturtant" - Gudrun Sjödén, Marimekko, Nanso plus home-grown artsy knits and stuff. I'm not disparaging, there's a part of me that aspires to this style since I think a kulturtant is rather a nice thing. Anyway, over one shoulder she had draped a large triangular scarf. Just the one shoulder. Hanging there, more importantly slipping off from there. I remember my landlady in Paris doing this. She fastened it sneakily with a pin, also it was Hèrmes. This was prob Gudrun and no pin.
I asked her for help to find a book that wasn't on the shelf. She slowly dragged the scarf back up to the shoulder, checked computer, dragged scarf back, shuffled over to trolley with recent returns, pulled at scarf, shuffled back to me, pulled at scarf, sighed, shuffled out into library to locate book with me trailing behind, stopping every now and then to fix scarf, book not there, sigh, adjust scarf, shuffle to somewhere else, SCARF...
I nearly combusted.