Long lasting eyeliner

[Plural]

I've never found one that does slide off any recommendations?

Maybelline gel in little pot is amazing. I have literally bought every eyeliner known to man and this is the only thing that stays on and doesn't give me panda eyes. I think I have greasy eyelids which causes most to slide off.

double wear

Kat Von D

@catinboots9 hhow do you apply it

I think the Maybelline one comes with a brush?

Estee Lauder zero smudge liquid eyeliner. I have oily skin and hooded lids and it stays on all day and night (and the next day if I want it to)

Bobbi Brown long wear gel lasts all day. And I regularly touch/rub my eyes.

I came across BH cosmetics liquid eyeliner on beauty bay a couple of months ago and thought I'd give it a try at £4 and it's fantastic. No smudging (and I have very oily lids) and very black; none of this building it up to get a decent colour.

There's also the 40 something pence one from Amazon which is amazing but a lot more liquid than the BH cosmetics one.

Ihave tried the Bobbi brown, and the estee lauder DW eye pencil, but both smudge on me,

The Mac liquid one. It's called long last or something. I can't get the bloody stuff off! It really does stay put. I even wore it swimming once by accident and it didn't budge.

The best I've found is a pencil; the Wunder2 super stay liner. I use a Bobbi Brown primer, too. It's not 100% perfect, but this pencil has been pretty good at not sliding off or fading.

I've spent so much trying to find a consistently good liner. Not sure it even exists!

Stila all day waterproof liquid liner.

Doesn't budge through rain, sweaty gym sessions, nights out of even sleeping with it on.

It's a pen so easy to apply and I use it nigh on every day. Great stuff!

Benefit 'they're real' eyeliner totally stays put. It does get blobby though.

Kiko waterproof has got me through many a weepy day without budging!

Another for maybeline gel

• Maybelline

Yy with a little brush that comes with it

Urban Decay 24/7 glide on eyeliner always lasts all day on me. It's really nice to apply too although it does wear down quite quickly as it is really more of a gel pencil.

Mac liquid last.
I tried all kinds.
This one is the only one to stay put and give me the deep black colour I want.
It's £16 and lasts well. I get a new one every 3 months.

Bourjois pinceau liquid eyeliner.

I've tried so many expensive brands, but this budget £7 one is my go-to every time.

L'Oreal infalliable gel crayon, CYO setting our sights kohl gel eyeliner (from Boots) and if you can find any, Cargo swimmables eye pencil. All work really well for me and my horribly oily eyelids. (I prefer pencils to anything else.)

Makeup forever brand has a great eyeliner I’ve used that stays on longer than any I’ve ever used I find it at Sephora

Budget: Rimmel Exaggerate Liquid eyeliner - I always come back to this!

Luxury: Tom Ford Eye defining pen - this lasts for DAYS!

I use Mac fluidline. It doesn't budge.

Which of these would be good for lining your upper eyelid?

I use a nyx pencil for my lower lid. But my upper eyelid is much more moveable and even if holding it with one hand I can't seem to get enough pressure to do it. Would gel be better? Should I use a brush?